Blogs & Opinion


Celtic's clash with Dundee looks a complete mis-match, says Andy Walker

Andy Walker - Andy Walker Posted 18th February 2013 view comments

With 44 points separating top from bottom, this weekend's live SPL clash between champions-elect Celtic and relegation-threatened Dundee has the look of a complete mis-match.

It's been that sort of season in Scotland's top flight.

Following the extraordinary demise of Rangers and the restructuring of Scottish football that saw the Ibrox club placed in the bottom tier, Dundee were given just over a week to prepare for life in amongst the top 12.

Barry Smith: still on a steep learning curve, says Andy

Barry Smith: still on a steep learning curve, says Andy

It's fair to say they have been out of their depth. Just three wins from 26 league games so far underlines how difficult Dundee have found the sudden adjustment to a more demanding environment.

Celtic, with the remarkable resources they have in comparison to everyone else, have built the type of lead in a one-horse race that hasn't surprised anyone.

The trick for Lennon and his backroom staff will be to ensure they provide Champions League football again next season as most Celtic supporters I speak to find it difficult to imagine their club without it.

Andy Walker
Quotes of the week

Thankfully, their supporters have had a successful Champions League campaign to brighten their season.

Attitude

Despite the recent 3-0 first leg defeat at the hands of Juventus, the Champions League has provided tremendous highlights and as Neil Lennon said in the build-up to what was a magnificent atmosphere in Glasgow's East End, it's the biggest show in town.

The trick for Lennon and his backroom staff will be to ensure they provide Champions League football again next season as most Celtic supporters I speak to find it difficult to imagine their club without it.

On a number of occasions this season, Celtic have struggled to raise their game in some SPL fixtures and Sunday's lunchtime clash will be all about how Celtic approach this one.

If their attitude is spot on, then another six goals to match what they notched last weekend at home to Dundee neighbours United could be on the cards.

Tough

Dundee have their pride to play for and manager Barry Smith is still on a steep learning curve.

Just before the January transfer window opened, Smith's future as boss was debated in the boardroom and he was given the green light to continue their fight to escape the drop. In my view it's the correct decision.

Smith has shown himself to be capable of lifting a club from the depths of administration and putting a winning team on the park.

Being completely unprepared for life in the top flight was unforeseen and he deserves the chance to build a side that will be able to compete next time around.

This is a club that has come through really tough times with players being made redundant and Smith has shown enough leadership to merit a longer stay in a job he relishes.

What little quality Smith can call upon is hindered when injuries and suspension kicks in.

Compare that to Celtic who could easily rest 11 first team regulars and still have players of international quality on view.

back to top

Other Football Experts:

Latest Posts in Football:

Andy Walker

Walker: Celtic must capitalise

Celtic are the ‘luckiest team in the world’ and must seize their chance against Maribor, says Andy Walker....

Guillem Balague

Balague's best buys

Guillem Balague picks his top 15 under-the-radar signings set for a big La Liga this season......

Martin Tyler

Tyler's stats and facts

Which team has lost the most Premier League games ever? Martin Tyler's stats and facts column is back!...

Latest News RSS feeds

Rojo completes United move

Manchester United have completed the signing of Marcos Rojo from Sporting Lisbon.

Celtic claim Maribor draw

Celtic claimed a 1-1 draw with Maribor in Slovenia in the first leg of their Champions League play-off clash.

Barcelona take appeal to CAS

Barcelona are appealing to the CAS after FIFA upheld their transfer embargo.

Live transfer updates

Man Utd confirm signing of Marcos Rojo, Edin Dzeko signs new Man City deal and QPR land Leroy Fer from Norwich.

Mackay not heading to Palace

Sky sources understand Malky Mackay will not now be appointed as manager of Crystal Palace.

Features

Premier League Transfer: New signing Marcos Rojo must prove the critics wrong once again at Manchester United

Premier League Transfer: New signing Marcos Rojo must prove the critics wrong once again at Manchester United

It’s not Arturo Vidal or Mats Hummels but it seems Manchester United finally have a new signing in £16million man Marcos Rojo. The Argentine defender will arrive at Old Trafford with more questions than those believing him to have the answers. No matter. Rojo has proved the critics wrong before.

Champions League playoff: Arsenal survive Besiktas test with Calum Chambers impressive in the centre of defence

Champions League playoff: Arsenal survive Besiktas test with Calum Chambers impressive in the centre of defence

It was a night that always threatened to be ghastly for Arsenal, the type of long European trip that smacks of the clichéd banana skin so early in the season.

Transfer News: Sky Bet rate Liverpool's chances of signing each of the strikers on their reported shortlist

Transfer News: Sky Bet rate Liverpool's chances of signing each of the strikers on their reported shortlist

In a recent statistical write up by Whoscored.com, over 60 per cent of Skysports.com readers named Marco Reus as the much-needed forward they believe Liverpool should sign before the summer transfer deadline.