Blogs & Opinion


Andy Walker: Celtic's lack of signings might halt their Champions League progress

Andy Walker - Andy Walker Posted 21st August 2013 view comments

Let's be clear about one aspect of Celtic's surprising 2-0 first leg defeat in the Champions League play-off tie against Shakhter Karagandy from Kazakhstan: Neil Lennon's men still have a chance of competing in Europe's premier club competition.

The Scottish Champions are more than capable of scoring three or more goals against a side that I would describe as no more than decent at this level.

Shakhter's style of play is direct, they are physically strong and powerful in the air and their approach to the second leg in Glasgow will not change. They will defend in numbers.

Missing out: will Celtic make it into the Champions League group stages?

Missing out: will Celtic make it into the Champions League group stages?

But it's a position Celtic should not be in.

After coining in £20million from last season's wonderful Champions League campaign, Victor Wanyama was sold to Southampton for £12million. That was a superb piece of business.

Taking a chance on the young Kenyan internationalist for a fee of around £1million just two seasons ago has proved to be a major triumph for Celtic's recruitment policy.

While I certainly understand why the Scottish Champions choose to invest in potential and young players as their model for recruiting players, it will be a real slap in the face for the Celtic fans if a lack of quality signings means they'll miss out on competing with Europe's elite.

Andy Walker
Quotes of the week

Then Gary Hooper, a man who scored regularly in both domestic and European competition and who most recently netted twice in Celtic's Scottish Cup final success against Hibs, opted for the lure of the Barclays Premier League when he signed on at Norwich City for around £5million.

Hefty

Again, a deal that makes sound business sense. Hooper could have stayed for the rest of his contract and left for nothing so receiving a hefty fee now is understandable.

On top of that, Kelvin Wilson returned to Nottingham Forest for a fee believed to be in the region of £2million.

Wilson highlighted the important family issues that meant he would be much more comfortable living closer to home so, once again, Celtic were prepared to do business.

Banking the best part of £40million in such a short space of time is the stuff that every other Scottish club can only dream about.

But where are the quality replacements to ensure another season of Champions League football was likely in Glasgow?

This two-legged qualifier was a date ring-fenced in the calendar as the most important tie of the year and Celtic are undoubtedly a weaker side without 3 of the players who served them so well in Europe last season.

Reckless

At a time when serious competition for the league title is non-existent, the Celtic supporters have chosen to pay good money up front to renew their season tickets.

European football at the highest level gives them the excitement and drama they long for.

And while I certainly understand why the Scottish Champions choose to invest in potential and young players as their model for recruiting players, it will be a real slap in the face for the Celtic fans if a lack of quality signings means they'll miss out on competing with Europe's elite.

No-one is advocating reckless spending by the Celtic board. But why not pay a premium for one or two players when there is so much at stake?

The reality is that Neil Lennon's men are chasing a two-goal deficit under the lights in Glasgow next Wednesday that will define Celtic's season.

It will be a slap in the face for the Celtic fans if their team haven't been in the best possible position to return to this level of competition.

back to top

Other Football Experts:

Latest Posts in Football:

Latest News RSS feeds

Premier League: 10 questions

We look at the big talking points ahead of a key weekend in the Premier League.

Redknapp: Reds need big win

Liverpool can get back in the top-four race with a win over Arsenal, says Jamie Redknapp.

Hart signs new City contract

Joe Hart has signed a new long-term contract which keeps him at Manchester City until the end of the 2018-19 season.

Wenger: How I signed Sanchez

Arsene Wenger says it was Arsenal's consistency and style of play that convinced Alexis Sanchez to choose London over Liverpool.

Van Gaal chasing perfection

Louis van Gaal will continue to demand more from Manchester United despite Sir Alex Ferguson telling him: 'It's results that count'.

Features

Tyne-Wear Derby: Ex-Sunderland midfielder Jack Colback is now a Newcastle favourite following his summer move

Tyne-Wear Derby: Ex-Sunderland midfielder Jack Colback is now a Newcastle favourite following his summer move

Former Sunderland midfielder Jack Colback has quickly won over the Newcastle fans and could be a key figure in the Tyne-Wear derby, writes Adam Bate...

Premier League questions: Can Brendan Rodgers silence his critics? And will Villa Park be Man Utd's haven again?

Premier League questions: Can Brendan Rodgers silence his critics? And will Villa Park be Man Utd's haven again?

With another huge weekend of Premier League football ahead of us, we ponder 10 questions that will be answered by Monday evening...

Five classics

Five classics

Liverpool v Arsenal is a fixture steeped in history and with the pressure on both bosses ahead of their Super Sunday clash, this weekend’s meeting could be another one to remember.