Blogs & Opinion


Celtic were outclassed by Barcelona in the Champions League, says Andy Walker

Andy Walker - Andy Walker Posted 2nd October 2013 view comments

It's not often Celtic lose at home in the Champions League but they can have no complaints in falling short to one of the most technically gifted sides to appear in Glasgow, even allowing for the fact that Barcelona weren't at their best.

In an atmosphere that can't be bettered anywhere in Europe, it was just too much to ask for Celtic to replicate the astonishing result at the same stage last season when the Scottish champions won a famous victory.

Fraser Forster's performance was a rare positive for Celtic

Fraser Forster's performance was a rare positive for Celtic

Without the genius of Lionel Messi, a front three of Pedro, Fabregas and Neymar supported by Xavi, Iniesta and Busquets completely dominated possession for long spells but to Celtic's credit, they defended deeply and restricted their more illustrious opponents to very few chances.

But when they did get the ball, Celtic's passing was a huge let down for the fans who were desperate for their men to have some sort of controlled possession, if only for a short time.

Ajax at home is now pivotal in terms of Celtic's European future this season and somehow, Celtic have to find a way of taking one or two of the relatively few chances they create in this magnificent tournament to survive.

Andy Walker
Quotes of the week

But Celtic will rarely play against a group of players with that level of technique. Barcelona move the ball so quickly and their first touch and instant control all over the pitch is fabulous to watch.

The game's biggest talking point was of course the red card shown to Celtic's captain Scott Brown.

Neil Lennon was at great lengths defending his leader in public but privately he must wonder why he was so stupid. A captain leads by example and my first thought was that it was a great foul to give away, Neymar's pace was carrying him away from Brown and into a dangerous area. A cynical foul, worthy of a yellow card, was professional and crucially would allow his teammates to regroup.

Petulant

But the petulant kick when Neymar was on the ground was the act of an immature schoolboy. It's debatable whether any contact was made but from the referee's view, the intent was clear and he quickly swapped the yellow he had in his hand for a red.

Years ago, Brown was renowned for being a bit of a hothead who would often lose his composure but in recent years I thought he had grown out of that and was now showing a level of maturity you'd expect from a Celtic captain.

The changes Neil Lennon made to his team almost worked wonders. A wonderful piece of control set James Forrest up for a stinging left-foot half-volley that brought out a tremendous save from Victor Valdes.

From that corner, Charlie Mulgrew almost gave Celtic the lead but the simple truth is that Celtic have had opportunities to score against both Milan and Barcelona and have failed to find the composure and ruthless, clinical finishing you need to survive against some of the best teams in Europe.

Excellent

What they do have is a goalkeeper who, apart from flapping at a cross on the stroke of half time, enhanced his reputation as someone who can perform on the big occasion.

Fraser Forster was excellent in last season's Champions League campaign and some of his stops late on to deny Barcelona a second goal were world class.

Ajax at home is now pivotal in terms of Celtic's European future this season and somehow, Celtic have to find a way of taking one or two of the relatively few chances they create in this magnificent tournament to survive.

back to top

Other Football Experts:

Latest Posts in Football:

Ray Wilkins

Wilkins: Rooney for captain

Ray Wilkins says Wayne Rooney is the "standout candidate" for the England captaincy....

Jamie Carragher

Carra: Gerrard hard to replace

Jamie Carragher says there’s no natural replacement for Steven Gerrard in the England team....

Martin Tyler

Tyler: We need Stevie's values

Steven Gerrard can inspire the next generation of England stars even in retirement, says Martin Tyler....

Latest News RSS feeds

Live transfer updates

Didier Drogba edges closer to Chelsea return, Atletico Madrid eye Javier Hernandez and New York City sign Frank Lampard.

Jose considers Drogba return

Jose Mourinho has confirmed he is considering bringing former Chelsea striker Didier Drogba back to Stamford Bridge.

Rodgers expects Gerrard deal

Liverpool manager Brendan Rodgers is expecting a new contract to be 'sorted' for captain Steven Gerrard.

Giggs: Van Gaal like Fergie

Ryan Giggs has hailed Louis van Gaal’s early impact and has acknowledged the similarities with Sir Alex Ferguson.

Carroll set for surgery

West Ham's Andy Carroll is to have surgery after suffering an ankle injury which could keep him out for four months.

Features

Trevor Francis questions whether Hart or Caballero will be Man City's goalkeeper

Trevor Francis questions whether Hart or Caballero will be Man City's goalkeeper

Trevor Francis says the International Champions Cup will provide the first indicator over Joe Hart's future in the Manchester City team, following the arrival of Willy Caballero.

Manchester United boss Louis van Gaal has found early success with 3-5-2 and might be tempted to stick with it

Manchester United boss Louis van Gaal has found early success with 3-5-2 and might be tempted to stick with it

One of the first questions put to Louis van Gaal in his opening press conference as Manchester United manager was whether he would be introducing the same formation and philosophy right through the club’s youth system.

Why new signing Willy Caballero has the ability to usurp Joe Hart as Manchester City's first-choice goalkeeper

Why new signing Willy Caballero has the ability to usurp Joe Hart as Manchester City's first-choice goalkeeper

With Joe Hart celebrating title success with Manchester City after five consecutive wins to finish the season, it is easy to forget that for the second campaign in a row the England goalkeeper had struggled.