Blogs & Opinion


Brian Carney:

Real Steel contenders

The big talking points in the world of rugby league

Brian Carney Posted 14th September 2011 view comments

Each week Brian Carney takes a look at six moments in Super League that have made the headlines - and not always for the right reasons!

Players, coaches and decisions all come under Brian's scrutiny as he picks his 'Set of Six'.

Find out who and what caught Brian's eye this week - and then use the feedback form below to have your say...

Man of Steel contender Sam Tomkins

Man of Steel contender Sam Tomkins

WARRINGTON WOLVES
League leaders trophy and a landmark moment for the club. Cup wins have now been followed with league consistency. It's been a long and at times traumatic journey from the old Wilderspool ground to the new Halliwell Jones Stadium. The club have worked hard off and on the field and will, as an organisation, see this first league trophy as a well-earned reward.

Special credit should go to Angela Powers and her moving piece featuring Dale Laughton, Kris Radlinski and Adrian Vowles. All three spoke from their own personal experiences about the pressures facing retired rugby league players and struck a note I'm sure with many

Brian Carney
Quotes of the week

PLAY-OFFS
it took until the last round to sort out the top eight. Does anyone see a credible threat coming from outside the top three this year? Huddersfield have had a poor final quarter of the season, Leeds have pedigree but are hit and miss this year and both Hull clubs have gone as far as they will go. Catalans Dragons can possibly cause an upset but they also have the unsettling (for their coach) tendency to concede a lot of points in 80 minutes. Just my opinion and if I'm wrong it means that we will have had the thrilling underdog wins that we all love in sport.

CASTLEFORD
One team that missed out. They were in the top eight all year and miss out on the play-offs in the final round. A disappointing end for their departing coach, Terry Matterson, however he must be satisfied with the effort his injury-hit side put in against Hull KR - brave is the word that springs into my mind. If they produce that with a full deck they will be hard to beat next year.

MAN OF STEEL
Who is your tip? Rangi Chase? Sam Tomkins? Michael Monaghan? All have shone for their clubs and have at times this year been head and shoulders above anyone else on the field. Match-winning performances have rightly seen these three installed as award favourites. Chase and Tomkins have been spectacular but my vote goes to Michael Monaghan. I see him as so integral to Warrington playing so well this season. Smart decisions at dummy half and a strong defender means I rate his all round game as the best in the league. For that reason, not just excellence but few weaknesses, he's my Man of Steel.

VOTING SYSTEM FOR MAN OF STEEL
A lot of different voting systems have been tried and now the vote rests with the players of Super League. If the RFL want stick with that then fine, but I have reservations about it. The award should recognise excellence throughout the season. Players play a game and can watch two others on a weekend (providing they are not playing in the televised game). That leaves a minimum of four, possibly five games that players don't see and can't know how other players have fared. That means they vote essentially on who plays well against them. A publicised voting system like the Dally M awards allows for year-long promotion of the award ( sponsorship opportunity?). The RFL would need to assemble a credible panel of weekly assessors (media, former coaches/players, fans), allocate them each a game and publicise the weekly results.

STATE OF MIND
I spoke last week of the State of Mind campaign. Round 27 dedicated as the State of Mind round was an overwhelming success. National television and print media coverage during the week leading up to the games was excellent as was Sky Sports coverage of the campaign. Special credit should go to Angela Powers and her moving piece featuring Dale Laughton, Kris Radlinski and Adrian Vowles. All three spoke from their own personal experiences about the pressures facing retired rugby league players and struck a note I'm sure with many. It is hoped that State of Mind will continue to promote mental health amongst the rugby league community for years to come. For more information go to http://www.stateofmindrugby.com

Comments (2)

  • Page 1 of 1
  • 1

Paul Smith says...

I can't belive that Sam Tomkins is still being concidered for the man of steel as he has brought the game into distribute in one of the games biggest moments . I know he was fined by the league & his club but has he is one of the games big stars and will have lots of youngsters looking up to him, ithing an example should be made of him & others that are in the spot light to show the yongsters that this is not the way we play our game.

Posted 15:54 21st September 2011

Tom Ayers-mason says...

Rangi Chase or Joe Westerman should get man of steel and Catalan were very impressive against Hull Kr and bye bye morgan no one liked u :D

Posted 22:14 17th September 2011

  • Page 1 of 1
  • 1

back to top

Other Rugby League Experts:

Latest Posts in Rugby League:

Phil Clarke

It's Grand Final time!

Phil Clarke looks at previous finals between rivals Wigan and St Helens, but who does he think will win?...

comments

Latest News RSS feeds

Kiwi beats Burgess to award

Rugby union convert Sam Burgess has lost out to New Zealand star Shaun Johnson for the 2014 Rugby League gold boot.

McGuire relishing Leeds opener

Danny McGuire says he is looking forward to playing alongside Liam Sutcliffe in the traditional Boxing Day fixture

Bird loses Titans captaincy

Greg Bird has been stripped of the Gold Coast Titans captaincy after he was caught urinating in public.

St Helens' Hand loaned out

Young St Helens prop forward Jordan Hand has rejoined Whitehaven on loan for the 2015 season.

Hull KR sign Campese

Hull KR have signed experienced Australian playmaker Terry Campese from Canberra Raiders for next season.

Features

Our experts gives their view on what we can expect from Sam Burgess

Our experts gives their view on what we can expect from Sam Burgess

Sam Burgess has been named on Bath's replacements bench for Friday's clash with Harlequins at the Recreation Ground and much is expected of the former rugby league star known as 'Slammin Sam'.

Warrington Wolves have used mixed martial arts to prepare for Super League 20

Warrington Wolves have used mixed martial arts to prepare for Super League 20

There’s not many sports people that can teach a rugby league team how to be more physical, but the Warrington Wolves have found just the thing.

Four Nations: What do the four teams need to do to reach the final?

Four Nations: What do the four teams need to do to reach the final?

In the most competitive tournament since it was regularised in 2009, all four teams go into this weekend's final round-robin fixtures in the Four Nations Series with a chance of reaching the final in Wellington on Saturday week.