Blogs & Opinion


Fining top level footballers is relatively inconsequential, says Johnny Phillips

Johnny Phillips - Johnny Phillips Posted 29th January 2013 view comments

Last week's leak of the club fines being enforced at Arsenal for players who fail to comply with a set of rules set out by Arsene Wenger and his staff made for an entertaining, but hardly illuminating, read.

Wenger himself didn't appear too put out about the leak, expressing disappointment that the list of fines went public but seeing the funny side when he was asked why Per Mertesacker was the player responsible for collecting them.

Carlos Tevez: had his four-week fine reduced to two after the PFA's intervention

Carlos Tevez: had his four-week fine reduced to two after the PFA's intervention

"The Germans do well economically and we respect that," the manager said, with a glint in his eye, at his press conference. "They are the only ones that make money in Europe. That's why we've chosen a German."

What the list did confirm was how insignificant fines for players at the highest level of the game really are. Surely the time has arrived where fining a top Premier League player is no longer a deterrent for any kind of misdemeanour?

I know of one Premier League player last season who was fined two weeks' wages for a serious breach of club discipline at training. That fine still hasn't been collected.

Johnny Phillips
Quotes of the week

At Arsenal the maximum any one player can be fined for breaking every single rule on one occasion is £4,450. And it would require at least two matches, along with some inappropriate behaviour during the week, to incur that amount.

Here's the list in full:

Non-attendance of unused player at home game: £1000

Late for training: £250-500

Late for treatment/massage: £250-500

Late for travel: £500

Late for matchday meal: £250

Wrong matchday kit: £100

Inappropriate clothing outside dressing room: £100

Outdoor shoes in dressing room: £100

Newspapers/laptops/phones in the medical room: £100

Newspapers in dressing room: £100

Non-production of urine sample on two consecutive weeks: £200

Phone calls in the building: £500

Not participating in commercial activity: £500

Last week Theo Walcott signed a new contract worth over £100,000 a week making him the top wage earner at the Emirates Stadium. But let's not equate these fines to his salary. The other top earners are capped at a mere £90,000 a week, which works out at £4.68 million a year. That is just over 176 times the average salary in the UK, which stands at £26,500 per annum. So that £4,450 bill for committing all 13 offences on the fines' list is the equivalent of the average man in the street being fined just 25 quid.

Sometimes footballers incur the wrath of their clubs on a much more serious level. Yet the Professional Footballers' Association rules state that the maximum amount a club can fine one of its players is two weeks' wages.

We saw last season how Carlos Tevez had his four-week fine imposed by Manchester City - for the incident on the bench at Bayern Munich in the Champions' League - halved because it contravened PFA regulations. A two-week fine is a significant amount to a player lower down the leagues, but at the top level it is relatively inconsequential.

Then there is the issue of how these fines are collected. Not every club has an efficient German to ensure the club's coffers are well stocked. I know of one Premier League player last season who was fined two weeks' wages for a serious breach of club discipline at training. That fine still hasn't been collected. I suspect he's not the only one to have escaped financial penalty in these circumstances.

Many of these fines are issued to make a point, so that clubs are seen to be doing the right thing, with little intention of them ever being collected. In the event that Tevez did actually cough up £500,000 it is unlikely to have impacted much on an annual salary in the region of £13 million.

Hitting players in the pocket is all well and good for those on a modest salary, but at the top level can the idea of fining players ever have been so utterly pointless as it is today?

back to top

Other Football Experts:

Latest Posts in Football:

Guillem Balague

Choose van Gaal

Louis van Gaal is ideal to replace David Moyes at Manchester United, says Guillem Balague....

Martin Tyler

Champs minus blanks

Martin Tyler has stats on David Moyes' final game, Liverpool's clean sheets and perfect penalty-takers....

0 comments

Chris Kamara

An undignified exit

Chris Kamara says Man Utd have lacked dignity in their handling of David Moyes' departure....

Latest News RSS feeds

Liverpool vow to strengthen

Ian Ayre is confident Liverpool will be able to attract their top targets in what promises to be a busy summer.

Mourinho to rest key players

Chelsea boss Jose Mourinho is ready to make wholesale changes to his starting XI for Sunday's encounter with Liverpool.

Pearson surprised by campaign

Nigel Pearson admitted he didn't expect Leicester's dominance after his side took the title with a 1-0 win at Bolton.

Chelsea suffer double blow

Petr Cech will miss the remainder of Chelsea's season after suffering a shoulder injury in the draw at Atletico Madrid.

Wilkins: Ancelotti for United

Ray Wilkins believes Carlo Ancelotti would be the perfect man to replace David Moyes as Manchester United manager.

Features

Ten reasons why David Moyes had to go

Ten reasons why David Moyes had to go

Only 10 reasons? The fact that this will be the reaction of many Manchester United fans goes some way to illustrating just how disastrous David Moyes’ time in charge of the club has been. Here’s a discussion of some of the problems that have led to his exit…

Runners and riders

Runners and riders

With Man United searching for a new manager for the second time in a year, we examine the candidates.

Football Podcast

Football Podcast

The sacking of Manchester United boss David Moyes dominates the latest Football Podcast.