Blogs & Opinion


Jamie Carragher praises Pablo Zabaleta ahead of Manchester derby

Jamie Carragher - Jamie Carragher Posted 19th September 2013 view comments

When you talk about Man City's most important player it is hard to look past Vincent Kompany.

Sergio Aguero and Yaya Toure are key but if they are missing you have more people to replace them with, whereas if Kompany is out you don't really see City being able to call upon someone of his quality as cover.

Class act: Carra likes the 'no frills' Zabaleta

Class act: Carra likes the 'no frills' Zabaleta

I think you saw that last season when he had a period out of the team through injury and if he has a long spell out this year it could be a similar story, even though City have signed the experienced Martin Demichelis.

But another of City's most important players is certainly Pablo Zabaleta; he was in the PFA Team of the Year last season and got my vote for that because there are no frills with him and he just gets on with the game.

Zabaleta never stops running and never starts complaining and is the type of guy that every professional footballer wants to play alongside.

Jamie Carragher
Quotes of the week

He does everything with the minimum of fuss and has kept Micah Richards, a quicker, stronger and more athletic player, out of the right-back spot for the majority of time he has been at the club because he is such a competitor.

Zabaleta never stops running and never starts complaining and is the type of guy that every professional footballer wants to play alongside; he is like Gary Neville - but better!

Quiet

City haven't hit the ground running this season - but that's not a complete surprise.

There were fantastic in the first game against Newcastle, which they won 4-0, but they have got a new manager and four or five new players and it is going to take them time to find their feet.

City lost to Cardiff a few weeks back and then had to go to Stoke - which is never easy and is especially tough for people who have never experienced it before - so they have had it tough and the new boys have been pretty quiet.

Fernandinho, along with Yaya Toure, was outstanding versus Newcastle on Monday Night Football and Jesus Navas gave them pace and width, too

But since then there has been a bit of a lull, though lots of teams have been like that with the international games disrupting some of the rhythm.

I hope there is a rhythm to Sunday's Manchester derby and it lives up to the billing that the United-Chelsea game on Monday Night Football didn't.

People have said David Moyes was cautious when he took United to Liverpool, but he went 4-4-2; things didn't really happen for them on that day at Anfield but it was not as if they went out there thinking negatively.

Going out to win games has been United's style and that won't change under Moyes, but if we get an early goal on Sunday that could make the game even more exciting.

We saw how lively things got when Swansea took the lead almost straightaway against Liverpool on Monday and a similar situation could really light things up at the Etihad.

Physical

It's intriguing to compare City and United's squads, too.

David De Gea has improved a lot since he joined Man United a couple of seasons ago, bulking up and getting used to the demands of the Premier League, but I would still rather have City's Joe Hart as my 'keeper because he is a great physical specimen.

However, if I was asked to pick between the strike forces of City (Aguero, Edin Dzeko, Alvaro Negredo and Stevan Jovetic) and United (Wayne Rooney, Robin van Persie, Danny Welbeck and Javier Hernandez), I would go for Moyes' options.

There's not a lot in it but all four of United's strikers are proven in the Premier League - some, of course, to a bigger extent than others - whether that's starting games or coming off the bench to make an impact, but a few of City's forwards still need to show they can cut it in England.

Selecting the best striker amongst those eight names is tough and you could argue that it is Rooney, who played extremely well in the Champions League against Bayer Leverkusen on Tuesday night and can operate in the hole or right up top.

But I would say at this precise moment it is Van Persie, who has had a few great years stretching back to his time at Arsenal and was probably the deciding factor in United winning the title last year.

back to top

Other Football Experts:

Latest Posts in Football:

Ray Wilkins

Wilkins: Rooney for captain

Ray Wilkins says Wayne Rooney is the "standout candidate" for the England captaincy....

Jamie Carragher

Carra: Gerrard hard to replace

Jamie Carragher says there’s no natural replacement for Steven Gerrard in the England team....

Martin Tyler

Tyler: We need Stevie's values

Steven Gerrard can inspire the next generation of England stars even in retirement, says Martin Tyler....

Latest News RSS feeds

Live transfer updates

Liverpool sign Dejan Lovren and are linked to another Southampton star in Jay Rodriguez, after Loic Remy deal collapses.

Rodgers: Remy deal is off

Brendan Rodgers has confirmed that Liverpool have pulled out of a deal to sign Loic Remy but refused to clarify why.

Hull's Maguire bid accepted

Hull have had a second bid for promising Sheffield United defender Harry Maguire accepted by the League One club.

Wenger: Chambers is a gamble

Arsene Wenger admits signing Calum Chambers from Southampton is somewhat of a gamble, but one he believes will pay off.

Mata backs van Gaal mentality

Juan Mata has hailed Louis van Gaal and believes that the Dutchman will bring a winning mentality to Manchester United.

Features

Didier Drogba's return to Chelsea is a sentimental one but the striker can still make an impact on and off the pitch

Didier Drogba's return to Chelsea is a sentimental one but the striker can still make an impact on and off the pitch

“It was an easy decision - I couldn't turn down the opportunity to work with Jose again. Everyone knows the special relationship I have with this club and it has always felt like home to me.”