Blogs & Opinion


Jamie Carragher says Tottenham and Everton should have had penalties during their 0-0 draw

Jamie Carragher - Jamie Carragher Posted 3rd November 2013 view comments

Everton and Tottenham were both wrongly denied penalties which could have altered the course of their 0-0 draw at Goodison Park, according to Jamie Carragher.

Referee Kevin Friend waved away Tottenham's first-half penalty claim after Seamus Coleman appeared to trip Jan Vertonghen in the box.

And then the referee went on to deny Everton a penalty when Coleman was felled by Vertonghen only to regain his feet and hit a scuffed shot that failed to trouble Hugo Lloris in the Tottenham goal.

Denied: Jan Vertonghen cuts across Seamus Coleman before being felled in the penalty area

Denied: Jan Vertonghen cuts across Seamus Coleman before being felled in the penalty area

Carragher and Saunders were adamant that both penalty appeals should have been awarded in the 0-0 draw. Read a full match report here.

Of Coleman's 66th-minute appeal, Carragher said: "He is may be not sure if he is going to get the penalty. He should get the penalty but he also has half a chance in the box on his left foot.

We are giving the referee a bit of stick for not giving the penalty but his positional play is fantastic. But you think, 'how has he not given it'.

Jamie Carragher
Quotes of the week

"May be he made the referee's mind up by the fact that he carried on. We are giving the referee a bit of stick for not giving the penalty but his positional play is fantastic. But you think, 'how has he not given it'. He is not unsighted.

"Really we should be talking about two penalties that have been given."

Fellow expert Dean Saunders agreed with Carragher's verdict and on Vertonghen's claims for a spot-kick in the first half, he said: "Vertongen can't go anywhere; he has got to go over. He didn't dive and it is a blatant penalty. Kevin Friend has a great view but he does not see it as we do."

But Saunders admitted that neither side had warranted the victory, with the draw seeing Tottenham move up to fourth and Everton remain in seventh.

"I don't think either team did enough to win," he said. "The goalkeeper [Lloris] did great for Tottenham at the end after being concussed; he made a couple of good saves. But apart from that it was quite an even game."

back to top

Other Football Experts:

Latest Posts in Football:

Andy Walker

Walker: Celtic must capitalise

Celtic are the ‘luckiest team in the world’ and must seize their chance against Maribor, says Andy Walker....

Guillem Balague

Balague's best buys

Guillem Balague picks his top 15 under-the-radar signings set for a big La Liga this season......

Martin Tyler

Tyler's stats and facts

Which team has lost the most Premier League games ever? Martin Tyler's stats and facts column is back!...

Latest News RSS feeds

Mackay not heading to Palace

Sky sources understand Malky Mackay will not now be appointed as manager of Crystal Palace.

Barcelona take appeal to CAS

Barcelona are appealing to the CAS after FIFA upheld their transfer embargo until January 2016.

Live transfer updates

Swansea sign Federico Fernandez, Juventus target Man City's Stevan Jovetic and Man Utd agree a deal for Marcos Rojo.

Merson: Ramsey a 'big loss'

Arsenal will miss "go-to man" Aaron Ramsey in their Champions League second-leg clash with Besiktas, says Paul Merson.

No Liverpool bid for Balotelli

AC Milan insist they have not received an offer from Liverpool for their controversial striker Mario Balotelli.

Features

Premier League Transfer: New signing Marcos Rojo must prove the critics wrong once again at Manchester United

Premier League Transfer: New signing Marcos Rojo must prove the critics wrong once again at Manchester United

It’s not Arturo Vidal or Mats Hummels but it seems Manchester United finally have a new signing in £16million man Marcos Rojo. The Argentine defender will arrive at Old Trafford with more questions than those believing him to have the answers. No matter. Rojo has proved the critics wrong before.

Champions League playoff: Arsenal survive Besiktas test with Calum Chambers impressive in the centre of defence

Champions League playoff: Arsenal survive Besiktas test with Calum Chambers impressive in the centre of defence

It was a night that always threatened to be ghastly for Arsenal, the type of long European trip that smacks of the clichéd banana skin so early in the season.

Transfer News: Sky Bet rate Liverpool's chances of signing each of the strikers on their reported shortlist

Transfer News: Sky Bet rate Liverpool's chances of signing each of the strikers on their reported shortlist

In a recent statistical write up by Whoscored.com, over 60 per cent of Skysports.com readers named Marco Reus as the much-needed forward they believe Liverpool should sign before the summer transfer deadline.