Blogs & Opinion


Jamie Carragher says amazing stats from Manchester United v Fulham game only tell half the story

Jamie Carragher - Jamie Carragher Posted 9th February 2014 view comments

It was a tough day at the office for David Moyes and United as rock-bottom Fulham snatched a dramatic 2-2 draw at Old Trafford.

Steve Sidwell put the Cottagers in front in Sunday's game but they were unable to hold back the United tide as Robin van Persie and Michael Carrick gave the home side the lead. However, Darren Bent swooped in injury time to claim the equaliser for Fulham.

Pressure on Moyes after draw with Fulham

Pressure on Moyes after draw with Fulham

United had 31 attempts on goal, with nine on target compared to Fulham's six attempts and three on target. United also had a record amount of passes - 649 and 81 crosses - yet it still finished 2-2 and Jamie Carragher says the stats cannot tell the whole story.

"I don't think you can look at those stats and say how well Manchester United played," explained Carragher on Sky Sports.

MATCH HIGHLIGHTS

Sky Sports subscribers can watch video highlights of the 2-2 draw between Man Utd and Fulham.

"I think the way Fulham played, you were always going to batter them on the stats. Fulham looked more comfortable out of possession. When they had the ball, they did not really know what they wanted to do - I have never seen a team defend so deep in my life.

"United may have had more crosses than we have ever had - but it was not the quality of crosses you would expect from Manchester United."

Former assistant manager Mike Phelan agrees and says that the quality from United just was not there.

"To say that was disappointing would be an understatement, it is more devastating than anything else," added Phelan.

"We saw what Fulham did to Manchester United is what Manchester United usually do to other teams - they win the game when they have to.

"It was an unbelievable game from a tactical point of view. You see Fulham defending, defending and defending - their game plan was really working. And then it wasn't working and then it was back on track again.

"All credit to Fulham, whose game plan came through in the end, but massive disappointment for Manchester United who really should be winning football matches with all those attempts on goal. The quality was just not there.

"Stats can give you a false impression and can hurt United more, they dominated in possession but did not win the game. You can harp on and harp on about possession but in reality that is not always what the game is about; it's about winning the game and creating chances to score goals."

The new Fulham?

The draw will give Fulham a much-needed boost to get off the bottom of the table and Carragher says it will be interesting how they approach their next game - at home to Liverpool.

"Can you take those tactics to a home game?" asked Carragher. "Liverpool are in great form at the moment and will go there expecting to win. It will be interesting if Fulham manager Rene Meulensteen goes the same way or if he goes for it a bit more - or even if they have the legs to go for it after today.

"As a coach, we know that Meulensteen is very forward thinking, very offensive and very attacking but up to now, it has not worked. So it will be interesting to see if this is the new Fulham from now until the end of the season."

United are now nine points away from fourth-placed Liverpool and while their manager David Moyes may feel that they can chase down that coveted top-four spot for a place in the Champions League, Carragher disagrees.

"I don't think they will make the top four now - it is too big a gap."

back to top

Other Football Experts:

Latest Posts in Football:

Latest News RSS feeds

Paulista to sign for Arsenal

Villarreal have confirmed Gabriel Paulista is close to joining Arsenal, with forward Joel Campbell going the other way.

FA Cup: Day of upsets

Chelsea and Manchester City both suffered shock home defeats in the fourth round of the FA Cup.

Ronaldo off as Real snatch win

Gareth Bale’s late penalty earned Real Madrid a dramatic 2-1 win at Cordoba, after Cristiano Ronaldo had been sent off.

Mourinho 'ashamed' by defeat

Jose Mourinho said he was ‘ashamed’ by Chelsea's ‘unacceptable’ FA Cup fourth-round defeat to League One Bradford City.

Bradford knock out Chelsea

Bradford City caused one of the greatest FA Cup shocks of all time as they came from 2-0 down to stun Chelsea 4-2.

Features

FA Cup fourth round: Five talking points

FA Cup fourth round: Five talking points

Shock home defeats for Chelsea and Manchester City took the headlines on Saturday as the underdogs had their day in the fourth round of the FA Cup.

Massimo Cellino at Leeds United: We chart the Italian's time in charge at Elland Road

Massimo Cellino at Leeds United: We chart the Italian's time in charge at Elland Road

Following news Massimo Cellino has stepped down as president and director of Leeds United – until April, at least - following his disqualification by the Football League, we look back on his tumultuous time in charge of the club…

Eredivisie: We look at the title race ahead of Ajax v Feyenoord, live on Sky Sports

Eredivisie: We look at the title race ahead of Ajax v Feyenoord, live on Sky Sports

Ahead of De Klassieker on Sky Sports on Saturday, between Ajax and Feyenoord, we take a check on the Eredivisie to see how the title race is shaping up…