Blogs & Opinion


Kevin Phillips on Juan Mata and why January window should be scrapped

Kevin Phillips - Kevin Phillips Posted 30th January 2014 view comments

I've never been fortunate enough to be sitting in a dressing room when a £37m player has walked in as my club's new signing - but I guarantee Juan Mata's arrival at Manchester United would have given all of their players a huge lift this week.

Mata is a wonderful, top quality player and for someone like him to join your squad at this stage of the season gives you a real boost - and that's especially so for a club such as United with the well-highlighted problems they've been going through.

Juan Mata: Big signing, big impact at Man Utd, reckons Kevin

Juan Mata: Big signing, big impact at Man Utd, reckons Kevin

United needed a fillip and to bring in a player of that quality and calibre is a massive coup.

Mata showed on Tuesday night what quality he's got - and that's as a player who isn't 100% match fit at the moment. He's a massive asset to the football club and you'd like to think he'll bring the best out of the players around him.

I've seen many players sulk when someone's been signed in their position but I've also seen players take up the challenge and raise their game.

Kevin Phillips
Quotes of the week

Bringing class like that to the club is going to help United do what they want to do this season - which is challenge for fourth spot, with the title now out of the question.

It's common throughout football that competition raises players' standards.

Players want to perform better because they don't want to lose their place to the new arrival, while players in other positions can improve when they know they'll be playing alongside a top player.

I remember when I was at Birmingham we brought in Alexander Hleb on loan from Barcelona and I couldn't wait to play alongside him. Although it didn't work out and he wasn't a great success, you knew he had quality and if you linked up with him things could happen.

I imagine Wayne Rooney, Robin van Persie and Adnan Januzaj will be excited at the thought of linking up with a player like Mata because they know he will set up chances which can only benefit the team.

Reaction

Of course, there are some players who will react in a different way. I've seen many players sulk, shy away or throw the towel in when someone's been signed in their position.

But I've also seen many players take up the challenge and end up being a better player by trying to hold onto their spot.

Instead of getting the hump you can think: "I'm going to challenge this player, raise my game and try to give the manager a problem about his selection'. I certainly know which way I'd be going as a player - I'd rather compete and try to show them I'm better.

Big new signings also have a positive impact on young players at football clubs.

If you're a youngster at Manchester United and you can't learn from watching the likes of Mata, Rooney and Van Persie train then you shouldn't be in the game!

When I was an apprentice at Southampton I used to sit and watch the first team training because you can learn so much from the way they go about things, but also the way they are off the pitch, in terms of their attitude around the training ground.

Deadline Day

Mata is the biggest signing of this January transfer window so far but, like most people, I'll be tuning into Deadline Day on Sky Sports News to see which other deals go through.

However, as much as I enjoy watching it on the telly - and Jim White adds to it all with his excitement - I'm siding on the opinion that there shouldn't be a January transfer window.

I feel it can unsettle a lot of players, it can unsettle managers and it can unsettle owners. For me, it's not the best thing for the game.

In this window clubs certainly pay over the odds for players because they need to get people in - but it's also a stressful time for players.

For the first time in my career I signed for a new club on Deadline Day last January and it was manic!

I only found out on the morning of the move that I was going to be switching clubs. By 6pm I was rushing into my car to drive to South London to sign for Crystal Palace.

I guess that's the way it is at the moment - but I'm pleased to say I'll just be watching Deadline Day unfold on TV this year rather than being involved in it.From the Super Bowl to the Showdown on MNF, it's a great weekend on Sky Sports. Click here to upgrade

back to top

Other Football Experts:

Latest Posts in Football:

Latest News RSS feeds

Live transfer updates

Get all the done deals, breaking news and gossip, including the latest on the futures of Schurrle, McManaman and Fletcher.

Chelsea v Liverpool live

Welcome to Sky Sports' live text commentary from the Capital One Cup semi-final second leg between Chelsea and Liverpool at Stamford Bridge.

Capital One Cup live

Chelsea host Liverpool live on Sky Sports, with a place in the Wembley final at stake - follow our blog for the latest from Stamford Bridge.

Regional Paper Talk

The latest from the regional papers as Andrea Pirlo says Juventus team-mate Paul Pogba won't return to Manchester United.

Bojan out for the season

Stoke forward Bojan will miss the remainder of the season after sustaining a knee ligament injury against Rochdale.

Features

Juan Cuadrado: We profile the Fiorentina winger who is a Chelsea transfer target

Juan Cuadrado: We profile the Fiorentina winger who is a Chelsea transfer target

His national team boss says he’d fit in perfectly at Barcelona, but Sky sources understand he wants to join Chelsea.

Capital One Cup: Chelsea have enjoyed recent success against semi-final opponents Liverpool

Capital One Cup: Chelsea have enjoyed recent success against semi-final opponents Liverpool

Liverpool can take plenty of heart from their performance against Chelsea in the Capital One Cup semi-final first leg, but their recent record against the Blues suggests they face an uphill task at Stamford Bridge on Tuesday night.

Transfers: We look at the players who may be on Louis van Gaal's Manchester United shopping list

Transfers: We look at the players who may be on Louis van Gaal's Manchester United shopping list

Manchester United seem set to spend big this summer - but who is on Louis van Gaal's shopping list?