Blogs & Opinion


Most strikers would have gone down in Matt Jarvis' position

Kevin Phillips - Kevin Phillips Posted 18th April 2014 view comments

The Matt Jarvis penalty incident at Arsenal this week has sparked plenty of debate.

Should the West Ham winger have gone down when Bacary Sagna caught him? Should the ref have given him a penalty although he stayed on his feet?

It's a grey area and one that needs to be sorted out.

Jarvis: Had every right to go down, says Phillips

Jarvis: Had every right to go down, says Phillips

Personally, I probably would have gone down.

We're trying to stamp out diving and I'm all for that - but if there's contact in the box you have every right to go down. And no one could have had any complaints if Jarvis had done so.

The intent was there from Sagna to try and get something on the player because the ball was well away. I'm pretty sure if that had that happened outside the box the ref would have blown for a foul but because it was in the box and he had to make a huge call he's opted not to take that decision.

Instinct

Maybe with Jarvis not being a striker that instinct wasn't there.

We're trying to stamp out diving and I'm all for that - but if there's contact in the box you have every right to go down.

Kevin Phillips
Quotes of the week

Generally, as a winger, he's taking the full back on and getting in crosses. He doesn't usually want a free-kick, he wants to beat his man and put the ball in the box. But any striker would have gone down. And you couldn't have any complaints whatsoever.

I commend Jarvis for trying to stay on his feet but it's not something many strikers would do.

Yes, as Gary Neville said after the game, British players do try to be honest like that. No disrespect to the foreign players in this country but if that was a foreign player he would have gone down. But that's the natural instinct of a centre forward. When you're in that penalty box you're looking to gain an advantage.

Referees need to look at themselves as well, though.

If the ref had given West Ham a spot-kick he'd have done himself no harm whatsoever and shown he was brave enough to give the decision.

Referees need to be a lot stronger. Obviously Jarvis is trying to stay on his feet because he feels he has an opportunity but if the ref can see he has no chance of getting the ball then I think he has to award the foul.

If refs don't award free-kicks and penalties when players are fouled but stay on their feet, then what incentive is there to not go down?

back to top

Other Football Experts:

Latest Posts in Football:

Graeme Souness

Souness: Stevie still a star

Graeme Souness says Steven Gerrard would still get into the starting XI of any Premier League team....

Guillem Balague

Balague: Contenders not ready

Athletic, Sevilla and Valencia haven't yet got what it takes to crack the top three, says Guillem Balague....

Gary Neville

Neville blames Toon signings

Gary Neville says Newcastle boss Alan Pardew is suffering for failing to sign enough experience....

Latest News RSS feeds

Vydra stunner seals victory

Matej Vydra's thunderous strike got Billy McKinlay's Watford tenure off to a great start with a 1-0 win over Brentford.

City pegged back by Totti

Manchester City endured yet another night of Champions League frustration as they were held to a 1-1 draw by Roma.

Matic header edges Sporting

Nemanja Matic's header earned Chelsea three away points against Sporting Lisbon in the UEFA Champions League Group G.

Tuesday live!

Follow all of the midweek action from across the Champions League and Football League, including Man City and Chelsea.

Blackburn stunned by Rotherham

Rotherham proved they have what it takes to prosper in the Sky Bet Championship after beating Blackburn 2-0.

Features

Champions League ones to watch

Champions League ones to watch

PARIS SAINT-GERMAIN V BARCELONA

Champions League: Andre Villas Boas has made a strong start to his time in charge of Zenit St Petersburg

Champions League: Andre Villas Boas has made a strong start to his time in charge of Zenit St Petersburg

“If we win all nine matches, Zenit will be champions.” The words of Andre Villas Boas upon being named Zenit St Petersburg manager in March seemed wildly optimistic given the circumstances.

Champions League: Francesco Totti hoping to star for AS Roma against Manchester City at the age of 38 years old

Champions League: Francesco Totti hoping to star for AS Roma against Manchester City at the age of 38 years old

If the country’s island mentality dictates that Zlatan Ibrahimovic had to score four goals in an international friendly for Sweden before having his genius recognised in England, then Francesco Totti really is in trouble. The Roma icon’s record on English soil is bewilderingly bad.