Division Two of the nursery looks a real tricky puzzle to solve as most have plenty to prove. A chance is taken with CHIBCHAN, who based on his debut run looks well-treated on handicap debut and his sire has produced plenty of Wolverhampton winners. Green Pearl has a similar profile to the selection and also has a claim off his current rating as does Silken Thoughts after finding just the one the better last time but he might be a little exposed. Silver Shine took a bit of a step forward on his latest and this looks easier so has to be considered however Chibchan is the tentative vote in a tight looking race.
Green Pearl (IRE) 4-1 (9-2) Led until entering final 2f, weakened quickly over 1f out, 8th of 14, 16l behind Majestic Dubawi (8-10) at Bath 6f 2yo mdn aut (5) sft in Aug.
Restless Bay (IRE) 20-1 (9-3) Dwelt, in rear, headway over 1f out, never nearer, 8th of 15, 10l behind Unex El Greco (9-3) at Leicester 7f 2yo mdn (4) sft in Aug.
Memorabilia 12-1 (9-0) Led, clear 5f out, ridden and hung right over 1f out, headed and no extra well inside final furlong, 5th of 8, 2 1/4l behind Dew Reward (7-12) at Bath 1m 2yo hcp 0-75 (5) gf.
Blackleyf (IRE) 25-1 (9-3) Slowly away, switched right to rail, held up behind, pushed along over 3f out and a lot to do, stayed on strongly inside final furlong, nearest at finish, 4th of 12, 5l behind Golden Tempest (9-3) at Kempton 6f 2yo hcp 0-70 (5) pol.
Tamareen (IRE) 13-2 (9-4) Tracked leaders, ridden over 1f out, faded inside final furlong, 9th of 12, 8l behind Golden Tempest (9-3) at Kempton 6f 2yo hcp 0-70 (5) pol.
Chibchan (IRE) 7-1 (8-10) In touch, under pressure over 2f out, soon weakened, 10th of 11, 12l behind Newport Arch (8-12) at Newcastle 7f 2yo mdn (5) gs in Aug.
Silken Thoughts 11-1 (8-11) Chased winner, ridden and chance 2f out, kept on one pace final furlong, 2nd of 12, 3l behind Red Oleander (7-12) at Lingfield 7f 2yo hcp 0-75 (5) gs.
Norwegian Liberty (IRE) 9-2 (8-7) Tracked leaders, ridden over 2f out, weakened over 1f out, last of 3, 14l behind Hortensia (8-9) at Hamilton 6f 2yo clm (6) gd in Aug.
Dunmore Boy (IRE) 17-2 (8-8) Hampered start, in touch, ridden and weakened over 1f out, 7th of 8, 5l behind Indian Ballad (9-5) at Carlisle 5f 2yo hcp 0-75 (5) sft in Aug.
Silver Shine (IRE) 14-1 (9-3) Slowly into stride, in rear, headway 3f out, pushed along over 2f out, no impression from over 1f out, 3rd of 6, 10l behind Bussa (9-3) at Nottingham 6f 2yo mdn (5) gs in Jun.
None Sweeter 5-1 (9-0) Close up, ridden over 2f out, soon weakened, 10th of 13, 8l behind Whats For Pudding (7-7) at Newcastle 6f 2yo hcp 0-70 (5) gd.
Magic Cross 8-1 (8-3) Behind, headway over 2f out, soon chasing leaders, never on terms, 5th of 9, 4l behind Loki's Revenge (9-7) at Warwick 5f 2yo hcp 0-75 (5) gs in Aug.