Grand Slam glory for France

Les Bleus triumphant but England impress in Paris

By Mark Kendall   Last updated: 21st March 2010   Subscribe to RSS Feed

Grand Slam glory for France

France celebrate Grand Slam in Paris

Related links

Teams

Also see

A 12-10 victory ensured France clinched their first Six Nations Grand Slam since 2004, but they were pushed all the way by a much-improved England at the Stade de France.

It was far from a spectacular display by the French all of whose points came in the first half courtesy of three Morgan Parra penalties and a Francois Trinh-Duc drop-goal.

Les Bleus were strangely hesitant for much of the match and were happy to play a game of control for the most part with the boot of Trinh-Duc dictating their tactics.

By contrast England put in easily their most impressive display of the tournament and, as demonstrated by a stunning early try from Ben Foden, showed plenty as an offensive force with some eye-catching running rugby.

But in the end they were left to rue a couple of second-half openings that went begging as France held on to seal their clean sweep.

It was the hosts who were on the board first after Dylan Hartley was blown for not throwing in straight at the line-out just three minutes in.

That handed the French an excellent attacking platform and, after England had also subsequently been pinged at the scrum, France hit the front as Trinh-Duc landed a rather ugly but effective drop-goal.

But England hit back in magnificent style with the kind of incisive, fluent three-quarter move that their critics have been crying out for.

Mike Tindall played a key role in securing territory before the ball was quickly spun through the hands of the back-line from right to left, culminating in Chris Ashton flicking a superb first-time pass to Foden who scampered over in the left corner - Toby Flood adding a wonderful conversion from the touchline.

It capped a hugely encouraging start for England, the visitors full of purpose and adventure, securing quick ball for their back-line and thrusting forward with ball in hand at every opportunity.

However, they were somewhat undermined by the elements, with their positive opening derailed by the onset of heavy rain which turned the contest into an increasingly cagey affair with France kicking for position and managing to turn the screw.

Morgan Parra missed a long-range penalty after Simon Shaw was caught offside, but the Wasps second-rower was quickly penalised again for a rash tackle and it proved the lock's last contribution as he was forced off with an injury to his right arm and replaced by Tom Palmer.

But Parra made the most of his next opportunity with the boot on 18 minutes as Riki Flutely was caught playing the ball at the ruck whilst off his feet, handing the Clermont scrum-half a straightforward penalty chance in front of the sticks which he slotted with ease.

English indiscipline

Parra was at it again five minutes later, France edging back ahead, without having had to work particularly hard to do so, as England were penalised for collapsing a scrum.

Indeed, while the French were some way from their best, they continued to assert themselves on the back of English indiscipline with fastidious referee Bryce Lawrence quick to punish the visiting pack in particular.

Prop Dan Cole was again penalised for collapsing the scrum on 33 minutes, England's fifth infringement at the scrum, and Parra made light of the difficult conditions to fire over the resulting penalty as France pulled 12-7 ahead.

England manager Martin Johnson moved ruthlessly to stem the penalty count at the break as he hauled off both Cole and Hartley and replaced them with the more experienced David Wilson and Steve Thompson.

The changes had the desired effect, England making much the better start to the second period.

They should have had reward for their efforts as they defied the slippery conditions with a sharp handling move on the blind side which released Ashton.

But, with just Clement Poitrenaud ahead of him, and Flutey in support, the Northampton winger spurned the golden opportunity as he opted to put in an early kick ahead and was beaten to the touch-down by the retreating French full-back.

With France happy to try and contain, and the rain having ceased, it was England who continued to demonstrate their attacking flair and they were agonisingly close to another score in the 61st minute after a superb break from Mark Cueto.

The Sale winger hit the line at pace and scythed through the French defence but crucially lacked close support and, having been hauled down inside the 22, England saw the chance escape altogether as Danny Care knocked on.

Like that of Ashton, it would be a missed opportunity they would ultimately come to regret.

Despite his back-line looking the most dangerous they had for many moons, Johnson decided to shuffle his pack on 63 minutes and introduced Jonny Wilkinson for Flutely and England's all-time leading points scorer promptly showed why as he kicked a superb long-range penalty to drag England back within two points.

But that was to be as close as England would get with France happy to run down the clock during the closing stages as they carefully and safely protected possession through a series of controlled, slow phases from their forwards.

While it hardly came with a flourish, it mattered not a jot to the ecstatic crowd in the Stade de France as they jubilantly saluted the Grand Slam at the final whistle.

Click Here for Your Free Bet

Comments (17)

  • Page 1 of 1
  • 1

Fred Artesani says...

Although France's scrum was better during the first half, some refereeing decisions were, to put it mildly, baffling and gave France their scoring advantage. England made the right changes in the second half and I was disappointed to see the "best team" of the championship giving up playing at the end, and setting up controlled rucks with no intention to either go forward or create an opening for the three quarters. They realised Wilkinson could engineer a drop goal and that England was better at running the ball (met by a superb French defence), so they eventually devised a way to stop the game altogether. No doubt it is within the rules of the game, but hardly the spirit. Surely the "brains" who have changed so many rule will have to think of a new one where, when the ball is clear of the ruck, it MUST be picked up and played, not just watched for a good thirty seconds (at least): the last ten minutes were a complete travesty and did no credit to the spirit of the game. So although France deserved the Six Nations, seeing them playing to avoid defeat by avoiding engaging the other side and making no effort to make progress, lest they lose the ball and be exposed in their weaknesses, was in my view a very unsportmanly way (and a boring one too) to secure the grand slam. It is not just about titles and sponsors lads... it is also about RUGBY. This being said, Ashton not taking the one on one struck me as an incredible decision for an England XV, and I will keep speculating about what could have happened if he had kept running and if he had noticed he was not alone with Flutey running in support. And yet it was the same Ashton who gave a great pass for the try. To sum it up: I was frustrated during the first half with England's weaker scrum, and with the referee being so fussy against England. The second half had thirty great minutes, then the last ten showed a sad yet effective French tactical decision.

Posted 21:40 22nd March 2010

Les Greenwood says...

Why do we always kick possesion away at critical times? It has always baffled me. We were handed the ball at least 3 times in the last 5 minutes, following French mistakes. What do we do - kick the ball back to them!! You can't score if you haven't got the ball, for heavens sake! The sensible thing to do would have been to plug away until we were in a positin to win with a drop-goal.

Posted 20:58 21st March 2010

Jonny Boy says...

just as i've been saying, pick the talent you have and not the old guard and things will pick up.........as a welshman i have to say that england should have won that game......as for the whingers going on about the ref, grow up.......yes, he wasn't the best but your team performed and performed well, clearly a good foundation......there's some more youngsters to come......but i still think that if greater improvment is the goal the rfu need to get rid of Jonno, after all, the talent we saw against the French was there at the start of the 6N, it was only public opinion that made him change his mind.....but credit where it's due, England did good.

Posted 18:42 21st March 2010

Simon Stoddart says...

England might have grounds to be brassed off by some very one sided officiating on Saturday night - but the overall table is right and sums up their overall performance. And much of that is down to the management of the side and some truly weird selections. The good thing about the France game was no soporific postmatch (sp)interview with Steve Borthwick who is not worth his place in the side let alone be captain. Someone out there tell me what Nick Kennedy has done wrong and why was Courtney Lawes not in the squad - and how does Louis Deacon get in the side ahead of Kennedy and Lawes? Delon Armitage was superb last season but has patently not been the same this time around after his injury - Foden should have started two or three games ago. And Chris Ashton has been in great form all season - but only the Monye injury saw him get a look in. The likes of Kennedy, Lawes, Ashton, Foden, Gerachty and Cipriani should all be well into accumulating vital Test Rugby experience by now - the next RWC is next year and, sadly, England the way they are currently managed will probably get no further than the first knock out stage. Well played in Paris fellas. But like last season - it was only one game (France again) where they showed what they are truly capable of. Frustrating or what?

Posted 18:31 21st March 2010

Jacob O'keeffe says...

Who was awarded the RBS man of the match in this game?

Posted 18:14 21st March 2010

Bill Delamare says...

Why do we have referees, i.e. ex backs?, who do not know how the scrum works giving penalties for not binding when the french prop is pulling back anf boring in - this makes it very difficult to bind properly and then ignoring french backrow players peeling off and standing next to the scrum. I hope he had a good night in Paris because he ruined the match.

Posted 17:36 21st March 2010

Mike Tetley says...

It is strange how one game changes peoples opinions of MJ and his coaching staff France did not play well but England only played well for part of the match. Flood did no better than Wilkinson would have done England need a scrum half who can pass the ball without taking two paces England also need a game plan that is not tied to the MJ era,a game plan that promotes flair and attacking abilities Foden Ashton Tindall showed these abilities. What England needs is coaches who culivate them not tie them down Please do not blame the ref anyone who has played rugby knows you see how he is going to control the match and then play within his interpretation of the laws professional rugby players should know this

Posted 17:18 21st March 2010

Scott Jackson says...

Tbh Why cant the english just be happy with what they got ? has it really got to the point where your mumbling and muttering over a game that was fair played ? cause if really u are then it just proves how much of a bunch of bad losers you are.. i guess you think that you played fair in the scotland vs england game yeh ? i'm scottish and tbh france did play poor last night and england was top of their game yet the winners a winner and remember it was ONLY by 2 points. france deserved their 6 nations glory, u deserved your chance to prove you could beat them. france played poorly last night perhaps due to the fact they knew they didn't have to win to get the 6 nations cup. they would of won it either way. in the scotland vs england team i was screaming at the tv cause of the times where i clearly seen a english player getting away with something he should of been penalised for.. In the end if u look at the draw we had against england. then add the fact we bet ireland ( with 2 missing players including patterson ) it makes us the overall better players cause wait a sec... didn't they beat you ? get over your loss and lick your wounds dry as its only a loss. not like you've not had it before . its only cause its against perhaps the best team in the 6 nations this year, that your complaining just to prove a point when the points only to yourself.

Posted 15:58 21st March 2010

James Sivad says...

I was disgusted with the standard of refereeing it was absolutely disgraceful... how much did the French pay the ref to throw the penalties their way?! This referee should be struck off and never allowed to referee another game at any level. France were out-played and their backs were made to look second best. I will congratulate some of their key players on a fine tounament some of the French players are still world-class and beyond reproach, but this game was deeply floored with very,very bad refereeing decisions.

Posted 13:35 21st March 2010

Denis Welch says...

There's no doubt that France deserved to win the Championship but they didn't deserve this win. Apart from the Lions first test have you ever seen such a one-eyed performance from a referee? The connection if you didn't already know? The same referee. The number of examples are too many to list here but if you taped the game have a look again The French loosehead never bound on Cole's arm preferring to twist in and under. He repeatedly pushed England defenders further back than they legally needed to be. How can he call advantage over after two passes from an infringement 5 metres from the line? And do the papers mention it? No. He is without doubt the most incompetent referee in the game today.

Posted 12:25 21st March 2010

James Halsted says...

It is clear that previous performances have been so poor simply because MJ has not had the best available players on the pitch; and there is probably still further to go on that basis. 99% of those commenting on these bulletin boards would have picked a team similar to yesterday's from the start of the season with I believe substantially better results. While Lawrence Dallaglio seems to be blaming Rob Andrew, clearly MJ and his staff bear responsibility for selection and training. Nonetheless in his day Rob Andrew was one of the most boring players possible, and it is not difficult to believe that he has also had something to do with the recent constipation of the English team.

Posted 12:06 21st March 2010

Kenny Wall says...

Will comment on the game as I saw it. Considering France were top of 6 nations I thought they were poor and England played all the rugby. Its sad that it seems to have got to the stage where the referee decides who wins a game. Well done England - and very, very, lucky France.

Posted 12:06 21st March 2010

Daniel Bramley says...

That's how England should play rugby. That was a good team, but we didn't get beaten by the French, we got beaten by the referee.

Posted 10:32 21st March 2010

Ben G says...

England can play rugby!!!!!!! Foden played very well. Ashton spurned a chance, but he has potention, it was great to blood him. Dan Coles was harshly treated, but will learn how to play the ref. We lost, but with pride and now I feel more encouraged about the team. Why on earth didn't the England management consider this team weeks ago?

Posted 10:02 21st March 2010

Gary Mann says...

What has become apparent during this year's 6 Nations is that the referees seem to have very little idea of the rule changes. The ref in the France v England game was a total disaster area. On many occasions he seemed to ignore illegal play by the French only to penalise England in the same phase of play for something that even the experienced players in the commentary box couldn't fathom. We need refereeing consistency in the game.

Posted 06:58 21st March 2010

David Stroyd says...

Well done France, on winning the Championship. Tonight they showed that even on the back foot they can win. As an England supporter tonight was very encouraging, well done England. It does beg the question. Why didn't Martin pick that team from the start? I am a huge Johnson fan as a captain and player. But as a manager? Why take off the best player on the pitch? Why did we have to wait until tonight to see how we all know England can play? I'm sure had we had come into the game tonight unbeaten, then we would have found a way to won the match and lifted the title. But fair play to the French, they are good!

Posted 23:52 20th March 2010

Daniel Pampel says...

At long last justice has been done! In the past the English have beaten the French by playing the same type of game, where France had scored more tries and still ended up losing because of the English boot. So well done France

Posted 23:50 20th March 2010

  • Page 1 of 1
  • 1

Add Comment*

Send us your views

Are you a Sky Sports subscriber?

*All fields required, your email address will be kept private