Valuev (L) lands against Holyfield
WBA champion Nikolai Valuev claimed a majority points decision to end Evander Holyfield's hopes of becoming the oldest ever title-holder.
Holyfield put up a brave display and ensured those who had predicted an entirely one-sided contest were proved utterly wrong.
The 46-year-old, who was always the busier of the two fighters, used his greater mobility to cause the 7ft Russian problems and was awarded a draw by one of the three judges at ringside.
However, Valuev was given victory by scores of 116-112 and 115-114 by the other two to ensure he retained his title.
Holyfield, who entered the ring some 44 kilos lighter, as well as 11 years older, than his opponent enjoyed the support of the crowd present in Zurich.
Valuev fought at long-range for the most part with some solid but unspectacular jabs.
The Russian failed to land with any really big shots, troubling Holyfield only a couple of times with glancing blows.
But while no doubting the veteran American's heart, he struggled to truly impose himself on his giant opponent and Valuev dealt with his attacks, seeing out victory despite Holyfield's desperate late efforts.
"I saw it the other way from the judges but I'm not disappointed by my performance," Holyfield said afterwards.
"He's a tough opponent, the sheer size of him is of course the main factor but he fights well with it too and that's the problem."

Haye is enjoying the moment
Bring on the Klitschkos!
David slays Goliath
McCloskey v Rasillav - Luck of the Irish
Watt backs Haye for victory in Nuremberg
McCloskey v Rasillav
Behind the scenes with Valuev
David and Goliath preview
Tim Hobbs watches Billy Joe Saunders go it alone for the first time - and continue his winning start to pro life.
Find out how to book David Haye's WBA heavyweight title clash with Nikolai Valuev on Sky Box Office.
Wayne McCullough says that Chris Arreola showed heart but not enough brain against Vitali Klitschko.