By Rob Lancaster Last updated: 8th January 2009
Flower: Leading contender
With Peter Moores' departure from the role of England coach on Wednesday leaves the ECB facing a tough decision ahead of a crucial year.
Whilst a temporary replacement will be found for the upcoming tour to the West Indies, a permanent appointment is expected in time for the start of the summer.
An Ashes series looms large on the horizon while there is also an ICC Twenty20 World Cup to come on home soil during 2009.
So who are the major candidates for the role? We take a look at some of the names in frame, as well as offering a few outsiders who could come under consideration.
Already part of the national set-up as a batting expert, Flower was reported to have been offered the opportunity to take over the top coaching job on a temporary basis for the trip to the Caribbean. However, a major stumbling block in terms of his long-term appointment could be any allegiance to former boss Moores. The former Zimbabwe left-hander certainly has an international pedigree having scored over 10,000 runs in Test and ODI's.
Is it possible that in the space of just four years Giles could go from Ashes-winning player to England coach? A recurring hip problem forced his retirement from playing two years ago but he quickly moved into management by becoming director of cricket at his county, Warwickshire. The move paid off last summer as he steered the Bears back to Division One in the four-day format. He has also been involved with England in recent times as a part-time national selector but this vacancy may have come too soon for him.
The former Australia all-rounder was one of the leading contenders for the position when Duncan Fletcher's reign came to an end after the 2007 World Cup. At that stage Moody had led Sri Lanka all the way to the final and was believed to be keen on the England job having settled in the country during his time with Worcestershire. Instead Moores was deemed the man, and Moody decided to accept the chance to return home and coach Western Australia, somewhere that he plans to remain for the foreseeable future.
Whatmore is a much-travelled coach who has excelled in the one-day game, an area where England certainly have room for improvement. He has enjoyed two spells in charge of Sri Lanka, his first including their stunning World Cup win in 1996, and was last on the international scene with Bangladesh. Since then he has been working at India's National Cricket Academy, though he would surely jump at the chance of returning to the top level of the game. If the ECB want someone with experience Whatmore, who was in charge at Lancashire during the late 1990s, could be their man.
The South African looked to the leading contender for the role when it seemed likely that Kevin Pietersen would still be the captain, as the pair had worked together at Natal. Andrew Strauss' sudden appointment does not mean that Ford is now out of the running though - and neither should the fact that Kent were relegated from the top flight last summer under his leadership. As well as knowing the county game, Ford has experience of the international scene having enjoyed a successful spell of South Africa that saw the Proteas win eight of the 11 series they played while he was in charge. His CV impressed both India and New Zealand when they were searching for a new coach, though the 48-year-old ended up in neither role.
If the ECB want another Englishman at the helm of their national side then few could have pressed their claims in recent times than Cook. The Middlesbrough-born opener led Durham to their maiden trophy as a first-class county in 2007 with victory in the Friends Provident Trophy final before then going one better the next summer, as they ended up as Division One champions in the longer format of the game. He has been with the north east county since 1991 and has helped mould several internationals through the ranks, not least Steve Harmison.
As unlikely as a return for the former England coach may be, there can be no doubting the fact that a lot of cricket fans would like to see the powers-that-be bring back a man who helped the national team rise from some of their darkest days to claim the Ashes at the end of one of the most remarkable Test series ever seen on English soil. Such memories make it easy to forget that Fletcher finished with a 5-0 drubbing at the hands of Australia and a disappointing World Cup campaign. He has since taken on roles with Hampshire and South Africa and may not be keen to step back in the firing line.
Shane Warne and Stephen Fleming are two outside shots. Both demand instant respect as two of the best cricketing brains from the modern era. Both have now had a break from the international arena since making their farewell appearances. The appointment of Warne, for so long England's tormentor, would be sensational news, particularly with his first series in charge being against Australia. Like Flower, Ottis Gibson is another already in the set-up having been installed as bowling coach by Moores, whilst there will always be public support for former internationals, particularly Sky Sports' commentary trio of Nasser Hussain, David Lloyd and Sir Ian Botham.

Strauss - Fletcher improved my game
Gilchrist to join Middlesex
Double trouble for India
South Africa A v England - Trott
Flower - Courageous Monty
Lee may consider retiring
Villiers - Win has lifted us
Arthur criticises England tactics
| Fixture |
|---|
| Sunday 22nd November |
| One Day Int Second Match |
| South Africa vs England |
| Monday 23rd November |
| Test Match First Test |
| New Zealand vs Pakistan |
| Tuesday 24th November |
| Test Match Second Test |
| India vs Sri Lanka |
| Thursday 26th November |
| Test Match First Test |
| Australia vs West Indies |
| Friday 27th November |
| One Day Int Third Match |
| South Africa vs England |
| Sunday 29th November |
| One Day Int Fourth Match |
| South Africa vs England |
| Wednesday 2nd December |
| Test Match Third Test |
| India vs Sri Lanka |
| Test Match Second Test |
| New Zealand vs Pakistan |
| Friday 4th December |
| Test Match Second Test |
| Australia vs West Indies |
| One Day Int Fifth Match |
| South Africa vs England |
| Result |
|---|
| Friday 20th November |
| One Day International Series |
| South Africa vs England No Result |
| Test Series |
| India vs Sri Lanka Match Drawn |
| Tuesday 17th November |
| Tour Match |
| South Africa A vs England England won by 4 wickets. |
| Sunday 15th November |
| International Twenty20 Match |
| South Africa vs England South Africa won by 84 runs. |
| Friday 13th November |
| International Twenty20 Match |
| South Africa vs England England won by 1 run. (Revised target - Duckworth-Lewis system) |
| International Twenty20 Series |
| Pakistan vs New Zealand Pakistan won by 7 runs. |
| Thursday 12th November |
| International Twenty20 Series |
| Pakistan vs New Zealand Pakistan won by 49 runs. |
| Women's Twenty20 International |
| West Indies Women vs England Women England Women won by 6 wickets. |
| Wednesday 11th November |
| One Day International Series |
| India vs Australia No Result |
| Tuesday 10th November |
| One Day International Series |
| South Africa vs Zimbabwe South Africa won by 212 runs. |
Expect fireworks in the International Sixes League as Graeme Smith's South Africa tackle England.
Watch the highlights from South Africa's win in the second Twenty20 International on skysports.com.
Catch up on all the latest from the Sky Sports commentary box with David Lloyd's tweetings.
Watch the highlights from South Africa's win in the second Twenty20 International on skysports.com.
Read what Sky Sports' experts and bloggers have been talking about over the last seven days in sport...
Sky Player has joined forces with Xbox 360 to allow you to watch Sky Sports through your games console.
It's a miserable day for Nasser Hussain - in more ways than one - in his video blog from Centurion Park.
Bumble looks ahead to England's tour of South Africa - and proposes his own 'Strictly' TV show.
Comments (13)
Rob Eason says...
I believe Rob Key should be in the England side and then would have certainly got the job as he is a excellent captain for Kent and should have played far more games for England than he has thus far. I think Ford is the ideal man for the job but if i was thinking out of the box as such i would like Stephen Fleming though as he was a brillant player/captain, we have too many coaches with england though Gibson?, Flower, Fielding coach?. Come on Giles you Toff sort it out!
Posted 07:33 15th January 2009
Graham Bywater says...
I think it will be a very big risk in selecting an Aussie of any description to be the England cricket coach. Especially when we will be playing a Ashes series in such a short space of time. The ECB should carefully go through the application and I sure that there is a British coach who can do the job and can get the best results and is who more suited for this and capable. This is not being prejudice(maybe just a little bit). It would not feel right winning the Ashes this way. I'm sure the Aussies would die first before picking a British coach for the Aussie cricket team. Also, the Aussie team has more problems than we have having lost two series at home. We have a great chance of winning the Ashes and make up for the last shameful defeat in Australia, but not with a Aussie coach. Possible, Duncan Fletcher could be coach again as he has a lot of respect with the England players and has something to prove after the last Aussie series.
Posted 19:10 11th January 2009
Graham Bywater says...
I think it will be a very big risk in selecting an Aussie of any description to be the England cricket coach. Especially when we will be playing a Ashes series in such a short space of time. The ECB should carefully go through the application and I sure that there is a British coach who can do the job and can get the best results and is who more suited for this and capable. This is not being prejudice(maybe just a little bit). It would not feel right winning the Ashes this way. I'm sure the Aussies would die first before picking a British coach for the Aussie cricket team. Also, the Aussie team has more problems than we have having lost two series at home. We have a great chance of winning the Ashes and make up for the last shameful defeat in Australia, but not with a Aussie coach. Possible, Duncan Fletcher could be coach again as he has a lot of respect with the England players and has something to prove after the last Aussie series.
Posted 19:10 11th January 2009
Peter Raw says...
We can discuss as long as we like about Moores replacement.It will not replace the main culprits in this affair,namely the ECB hierarachy.I agree that Graham Ford should be appointed,but I would rather see the appointment of a captain with proven international pedigree namely Robert Key
Posted 18:42 9th January 2009
Ian Henderson says...
Bring back Bumble!!!!!! He will inject a bit of fun round the camp.
Posted 13:03 9th January 2009
James Vinden says...
Bill Langford - I hope you aren't being serious when you mention Mike Watkinson???? As a Lancastrian I'm gutted he's still in charge of us, let along give him charge of the National Team. Proven player he might be, experience he has, nice guy he is, top coach...... I don't think so. Lancashire have one of the best squads in the country - and the signing of Lou Vincent, the release of Stu Law and Dominic Cork, the persistance with Mark Chilton as a front line batsman. All these issues suggest that he might not be the best decision maker. Do you still want him in charge of the National Team???
Posted 08:48 9th January 2009
Andy Burke says...
As an Englishman in Australia, the shock on the news and in the printed press on the possibility of Shane Warne being considered is tremendous viewing. It's likely to see him dragged into the Aussie fold as a selector initially to keep him out of our clutches. That said, we could do a lot worse. Get him, Darren Berry and Snape from the IPL team they looked after and we will be on our way, to good results, (the bar and the bordello might well follow but it will be good fun!)
Posted 03:32 9th January 2009
Bill Langford says...
I believe Mike Watkinson should be given the role as head coach. He has had many strong years as a coach but also has experience playing at the highest level, meaning he should hae the respect of someone like Kevin Pietersen. When Duncan Fletcher left there were rumours at the time that Mike Watkinson would be offered the role and I don't see what has changed in the last few years.
Posted 19:56 8th January 2009
Michelle Jordan says...
I think Botham would be the ideal choice. Not only has he had the best experience at top level as both batsman and bowler, but he would command the utmost respect from his players and the ECB. Through his professional role as a commentator throughout the world, he has had the opportunity to stay in tune with the up to date modern game and voice his opinions and advise accordingly. He is an absolute cricket legend, and would give England a fresh boost that other sides would only envy. Bring back Beefy!
Posted 17:31 8th January 2009
Rich Evans says...
Graham Ford has to be the leading contender, despite KP standing down as skipper. Ford, along with a strong captain in Robert Key, has forged a formidable Kent team, especially in the one-day game where England have traditionally struggled. He has proven international pedigree as a former coach of South Africa and I believe we should appoint a new manager from outside the current coaching set-up to really freshen things up. The appointment of Peter Moores was all a bit too cosy for my liking. Also - regarding the possible appointment of Andrew Strauss as permanent captain - he wasn't in the team last year and is by no means a guaranteed starter. The ECB really need to get this appointment right. But, such is our squad that, who are guaranteed starters? Pieterson, Flintoff and, errrr...
Posted 15:52 8th January 2009
Nathan Brown says...
I'd like to see Ashley Giles come into the England squad but in a different role to that of a coach. The captain is the man who should lead all aspects of the team from tactics to selection which is why KP should still be captain. Giles should be brought into a managerial role so he can organise team training sessions and provide advice to the captain.
Posted 14:16 8th January 2009
Stuart Cadman says...
Get 'Beefy' Botham in the job! He knows what he's doing and would no doubt give the England team a kick up the backside that they need in the shorter form of the game! The big back-up for him being selected is that he knows how to bat and bowl and therefore could help with both sides of the coaching. I think if he became coach he could really move this england team forward.
Posted 11:57 8th January 2009
Jeff Langlanius says...
I would like to see us approach Shane Warne for the coaching role. We already know all about his cricketing brain having seen what he has done with Hampshire and Rajasthan Royals in the IPL.
Posted 11:34 8th January 2009