Tom-orrow's world

England coach set to turn to youth to help pull off a Four Nations shock

By Rob Lancaster   Last updated: 2nd November 2009  

Tom-orrow's world

Smith: Taking a chance with his squad selection

Instead of turning to familiar faces the England boss has decided he has to bring the future into the present, selecting raw prospects Kyle Eastmond, Richie Myler and Sam Tomkins

Quotes of the week

LIVE ON SKY SPORTS
Watch every game from the Gillette Four Nations LIVE on Sky Sports, starting with England v France on Friday - for full tv listings click HERE

Also see

It is perhaps no surprise that Tony Smith should look to turn over a new leaf during the autumn months as he gambles on some fresh faces to re-ignite England's fortunes.

After a dismal World Cup campaign last year that yielded one win from four games, the Gillette Four Nations has been viewed as a chance to start afresh.

Perhaps still smarting from those performances Down Under (none worse than the 52-4 loss at the hands of Australia), Smith has decided to move out the old and welcome in the new.

By rewarding form and potential over long-standing reputation, the Australian now naturalised on these shores has taken a major gamble with his squad.

The odds - despite having home advantage - seemed stacked against him. Apart from their Melbourne mauling, England also lost back-to-back clashes with eventual winners New Zealand in their World Cup debacle.

Compete

Although they do have a fine record against tournament newcomers France, a heavy win over Bobbie Goulding's side in the opening fixture will soon be forgotten if they fail to compete with the southern hemisphere sides.

So with the pressure on, Smith's squad list is perhaps a risky play, a chancing of the arm. Perhaps, though, he realises that there is nothing to lose, and that it is better to go for broke rather than fold without much of a fight.

As Kenny Rogers once famously sang: "Now every gambler knows that the secret to surviving, is knowing what to throw away and knowing what to keep'.

Those that have been discarded include Leeds scrum-half Rob Burrow and St Helens stand-off Leon Pryce, two men who were the fulcrum of the side for the World Cup 12 months ago. The pair of half-backs may not have hit top form during the Super League campaign but their omissions were still a shock.

So too was the absence of Jamie Jones-Buchanan from the 24-man party, though competition for places in the pack is at an all-time high.

Up front England can certainly compete with any nation, experienced old heads like captain Jamie Peacock and Adrian Morley being joined by James Graham and Sam Burgess, who is NRL-bound for next year.

Gareth Ellis has just completed his first year playing in Australia, being named Wests Tigers' player of the season, and it will be fascinating to see how his game has developed since he left Leeds, who have just five players (six if you count the departing Lee Smith) in the squad despite securing a hat-trick of titles at Old Trafford recently. In the end only nine who appeared in the Grand Final made Smith's final cut.

Instead of turning to familiar faces the England boss has decided he has to bring the future into the present, selecting raw prospects Kyle Eastmond, Richie Myler and Sam Tomkins.

He will hope that in the space of a warm-up win over an under-strength Wales team and a few training sessions he can find an ace up his sleeve.

Smith should know plenty about Myler having signed the scrum-half from Salford for a hefty transfer fee. Eastmond has risen to prominence playing in a number of roles for St Helens, and he may be most effective off the bench.

Trump card

Tomkins, on the other hand, could be Smith's trump card. Thrust into Wigan's team midway through the season, the half-back went on to be crowned Super League's young player of the year while also being named in the prestigious Dream Team for '09.

Considering he is only 20 it is asking a lot for Tomkins to make England a winner instantaneously, yet it is hard not to be enthused by his obivous talent.

He showcased his skills with a hat-trick against the Welsh in Bridgend, including one solo try that saw him produce a stunning step off his left foot to cut through the first line of defence before racing around the full-back.

If Tomkins (or Eastmond or Myler, for that matter) can produce something similar against the Kangaroos or the Kiwis, then Smith will be vindicated in his selection policy. Perhaps he knows that while he may not cash-in this time around, there will be further chances to win it all at the top table in the long run.

Comments (8)

  • Page 1 of 1
  • 1

Gavin Hurst says...

I agree with Rich. How on earth based on Myler's performance against Wales could he be even carried through to the 17? Was clearly very rusty and did nothing against a very poor Wales team which a young lad should have been running rings around (like Tomkins did). Surely everybody can see that he has been picked based on the fact that Smith is the Warrington caoch...same applies to Chris Bridge...decent player but by no strech an international.

Posted 17:23 22nd October 2009

Rich Collins says...

So Smith has incuded Myler (playing for Warrington next year) after his shocking perfromance against Wales. WHY! Surely Maguire and Sinfield do enough kicking and can get the team around the park so that Tompkins or Eastmond can do their individual runs. Beggars beleif that you have a halfback out of form and lacking match practice and you overlook 2 of the most exciting in-form halfbacks in the english game. After the Last World Cup I would like to think Smith has learned some lessons. From this squad I doubt it.

Posted 12:10 22nd October 2009

Phil Russell says...

I.agree with sceptical man france is the weakest side in the group.the players tony smith has picked is a mystery to me but every picture tells a story.

Posted 11:34 22nd October 2009

Steve Low says...

So Tony Smith has left out Sam Tomkins the greatest recent talent the sport has produced, after his 3 try performance against the Welsh. Like Sceptical Man I too fear for Englands chances in the four nations unless he is resting his star for the big games and giving the likes of Eastmond a run out against the French in what should be a straightforward victory. The selection of James Graham also beggars belief. Here is a man who did not perform in the world cup and who has demonstrated, with his now famous televised sulk against Leeds, that he is not the type of player we need to represent our country. Better to have played the much improved Ben Harrison or certainly drafted him into the squad following O'Loughlin's withdrawal. Of course I will be cheering the lads on which will hopefully include Sam by game 3.

Posted 07:59 22nd October 2009

Steve Inglis says...

I agree with sceptical man, Smith must be off his head. I agree with blooding the younsters against wales and france this may be fine but when it comes to the big boys we havn't got an ounce of experience if mcguire doesn't play and at the rate smith is picking myler (over rated) and tompkins we will loose badly. They are both good players but what happens when the first big hit comes in on either of them, they will be targeted by both new zealnad and Australia. To be honest i think england are playing the wrong scrum half, Eastmond is by far the better scrum half compared to myler and he should be playing along side mcguire at stand off. It looks like we are also out of options at centre i think thats why O'Loughlin was there against Wales. Shento is the only recognised centre unless you play bridge there, Senior should have been called back up after the season he has had and considering Atkins is injured. yes we have a pack that competed eith the best, this has been the case previously but our back line? no where near as good as the two best teams in the world. Big losses ahead i think.

Posted 14:35 21st October 2009

Very Worried says...

the worst and more. I think the forwards will hold their own but the backs are really lacking world class talent. O'loughin was going to be used in the centres to try and cover up the dearth of genuine large quick backs in this country. With the loss of senior to the international game who else can pose any sort of threat out wide. I can not think of any centre, wing or full back who qualifies to play for England that is going to keep the aussies awake at night with worry. We are going to try and win these games up the middle and the aussie defence is just too good to allow that to happen

Posted 11:06 21st October 2009

Colin Quinn says...

This squad is a joke. Regardless of form Leon Pryce is one of the few world class players that we have. He should be in the starting 13 not just the squad. Both he and Burrow are better than Tompkins

Posted 23:00 20th October 2009

Sceptical Man says...

So Tony Smith has picked this squad on current form and also for the future. On current form ? Myler hasn't played for 10 weeks before Firdays game, he must be a wow on the playstation. For the future ? Smith is going to union in 6 weeks time, is he going to keep popping back to play in internationals ? Also O'Loughin, a forward, gets injured and we call up a winger as replacement because "we have adequate coverage in the pack" So why pick him in the first place then ? Anyone else fearing the worst ?

Posted 14:37 20th October 2009

  • Page 1 of 1
  • 1

Add Comment*

Send us your views

Are you a Sky Sports subscriber?

*All fields required, your email address will be kept private