- Your View |
- Message Boards |
- Polls |
- Sky Cast
The great P4P debate
With Floyd gone, who is boxing's new No 1? Adam Smith kicks off the debate - and wants YOUR verdict...
Back to story
With Floyd gone, who is boxing's new No 1? Adam Smith kicks off the debate - and wants YOUR verdict...
Back to story
Sign up to our FREE Friday email. Each issue is stuffed with exclusive sporting news, soccerettes and competitions.
Play our free Soccer Saturday Super 6 competition and you could win £100,000.
Comments
Ryan Fardon says...
1. Pacquiao 2. Calzaghe 3. JM Marquez 4. Cotto 5. Margarito 6. Pavlik 7. Hatton 8. John 9. Hopkins 10. R Marquez I wanna see Mayweather come back and paste Cotto he ain't in the same league. Also i'm surprised few of you haven't but Chris John in there very good but underated fighter!
Posted 11:28 30th June 2008
Chris Igay says...
I believe that Floyd isn't retired yet...He will be back so i'm putting him as no.1 1-Floyd, 2-Pacman Pacquiao, 3-M.Cotto, 4-Calzaghe, 5-J.Marquez, 6-Pavlik, 7-D.Haye, 8-Hatton, 9-Israel Vazquez, 10-Chris John
Posted 11:19 30th June 2008
Terry Duckworth says...
for me its 1. Joe Calzaghe 2. Pacquiao 3. Haye 4. Cotto 5. Pavlik 6. Hatton 7. Juan Manuel Marquez 8. Nate Campbell 9. Vazquez 10. calderon
Posted 10:05 30th June 2008
Allan Inting says...
You have to look how the boxer entertain and give excitement to the viewers. For me the its; 1. Pacquiao 2. Calzaghe 3. Cotto 4. Pavlik 5.Campbell 6. Marquez 7. Hatton 8. vasquez 9. Klitschko 10. Juan Diaz
Posted 01:11 30th June 2008
Ross Cunningham says...
My pound for pound : 1. Manny Pacquiao 2.Joe Calzaghe 3.Miguel Cotto 4.Kelly Pavlik 5.Chris John 6.Paul Williams 7.Juan Manuel Marquez 8.Ricky Hatton 9.Ronald "Winky" Wright 10.Israel Vazquez
Posted 22:58 29th June 2008
Ryan C says...
1. Pacquiao 2. Calzaghe 3. Cotto 4. Vazquez 5. Pavlik 6. Juan Manuel Marquez 7. John 8. Haye 9. Hatton 10. Calderon FACT!!!!!!
Posted 19:31 29th June 2008
Lee Dennett says...
1:PACQUIAO - 2:COTTO - 3:CALZAGHE - 4:PAVLIK - 5:VAZQUEZ - 6:MARGARITO - 7:HAYE - 8:JM MARQUEZ - 9:GUZMAN - 10: MARQUEZ
Posted 17:45 29th June 2008
Adam Brolin says...
1)calzaghe 2)pavlik 3)pacqiao 4)cotto 5)kessler 6)juan lopez 7)marquez 8) vasquez 9) haye 10) ponce de leon
Posted 17:41 29th June 2008
Adam 24 says...
why do you all have pavlik in the top 10? he doesnt even make the top 20, suspect chin and just a come forward fighter, no skill to him and berto hasnt proven himself yet 1) Pacquiao 2) Calzaghe 3) Cotto 4) Juan Manuel Marquez 5) Vazquez 6) Calderon 7) Kessler 8) Abraham 9) Valero 10) Rafael Marquez
Posted 15:05 29th June 2008
Liam Mcnamara says...
1.Joe Calzaghe 2.Pacquiao 3.Cotto 4.Roy Jones Jnr 5.David Haye 6.Kelly Pavlik 7.Bernard Hopkins 8.Oscar De La Hoya 9.Rick Hitman Hatton 10.Sugar Shane Mosley
Posted 13:17 29th June 2008
Jim Peplinski says...
1) Manny Pacquiao 2) Miguel Cotto 3) Joe Calzaghe 4) Kelly Pavlik 5) Juan Manuel Marquez 6) Winky Wright 7) Antonio Margarito 8) Rafael Marquez 9) Shane Mosley
Posted 09:45 29th June 2008
John Barr says...
1.Pacquiao, 2.Calzaghe, 3.Pavlik, 4.Cotto, 5.De la hoya, 6.Hatton, 7.Chris john, 8.Haye, 9.Hopkins, 10.Juan manuel marquez. Joe Calzaghe in 2nd because he got decision over Hopkins who i thought won it by 2 rounds. Within a year kelly pavlik will be no 1
Posted 22:48 28th June 2008
Jatin Parmar says...
1. Miguel Cotto 2. Manny Pacquiao 3. Joe Calzaghe 4. Israel Vasquez 5. JM Marquez 6. Kelly Pavlik 7. Joan Guzman 8. Ricky Hatton 9. Antonio Margarito 10. David Haye ...I'd like to give very special praise to the Golden Boy who is still a better boxer than Mayweather! Oscar would have made my list had he fought more in recent years! Up-coming mentions would include VICTOR ORTIZ and ANDRE BERTO!!
Posted 17:09 28th June 2008
Ben Garnett says...
It's actually really tough when you think about it! Can I leave Winky out due to inactivity? Is De La Hoya still a force? Arrrghhh! I'll give it a go.. 1. Calzaghe 2. Pacquaio 3. Cotto 4. JM Marquez 5. Pavlik 6. Calderon 7. Vazquez 8. R Marquez 9. Mijares 10. John Just missing out... Mosley, Margarito, Haye, Hopkins, Winky and DLH.
Posted 16:54 28th June 2008
Ben Garnett says...
It's actually really tough when you think about it! Can I leave Winky out due to inactivity? Is De La Hoya still a force? Arrrghhh! I'll give it a go.. 1. Calzaghe 2. Pacquaio 3. Cotto 4. JM Marquez 5. Pavlik 6. Calderon 7. Vazquez 8. R Marquez 9. Mijares 10. John Just missing out... Mosley, Margarito, Haye, Hopkins, Winky and DLH.
Posted 16:54 28th June 2008
Tom Podmore says...
1. Manny Pacquaio. 2. Joe Calzaghe. 3. Miguel Cotto. 4. Juan Manuel Marquez. 5. Ivan Calderon. 6. Israel Vasquez. 7. Christian Mijares. 8. Ricky Hatton. 9. Joan Guzman. 10.Kelly Pavlik.
Posted 16:08 28th June 2008
James Brannan says...
1) Pacquiao 2) Cotto 3) Calzaghe 4) Juan Manuel Marquez 5) Vazquez 6) Hatton 7) Pavlik 8) Haye 9) De La Hoya 10) Rafael Marquez. Hatton has to be in there, he has only lost one fight and that was against one of the greatest ever! And De La Hoya is the only boxer who has really challenged Mayweather.
Posted 12:50 28th June 2008
Jake Shaw says...
1) Manny Pacquiao 2) Joe Calzaghe 3) Miguel Cotto 4) Israel Vasquez 5) Kelly Pavlik 6) Juan Manuel Marquez 7) Rafael Marquez 8) Ivan Calderon 9) Christian Mijares 10) David Haye
Posted 11:56 28th June 2008
Kingsley Walker says...
1) Pacman 2) Pavlik 3)Cotto 4) DeLaHoya 5)Vasquez 6)Hopkins 7)Jones jr 8) Margarito 9) Williams 10) Calzaghe I would have cotto higher but i feel he needs to prove himself against margarito, jones jr although coming off two defeats he still remains one of the best boxers ever. Williams and Margarito are in there because these are two of the most feared boxers out there.
Posted 11:47 28th June 2008
Matt Pritchard says...
1 Pacquiao, 2 Cotto, 3 Calzaghe, 4 JM Marquez, 5 I Vazquez, 6 John, 7 Pavlik, 8 Haye, 9 Calderon, 10 Hatton... Mayweather should've fought Cotto before he 'retired' but for boxing politics, Calzaghe should fight Pavlik for his legacy instead of the over the hill Jones Jnr, Haye, would be high if not for the mickey mouse div that is the cruiseweight, and Hatton is just in there, yeah he did get taken to school by Mayweather but Mayweather is classed as the One of the modern Greats... Hopefully Pac Man can win tonight and set up a fight with Hatton, that would be a fight worth seeing...
Posted 09:15 28th June 2008
Add Comment*
All fields are required