Persist with Ponting

Persist with Ponting

Bumble reflects on the MCG and says Australia need to make changes - but not to the captaincy.

Back to story

Comments (22)

  • Page 1 of 2
  • 1
  • 2

Paul Nayler says...

Bumble , do you think there is a resemlance in Tremletts action to the Great Glen Mc Graths, I feel the rythym in the run up is very similar and the line and length is very close to the great man.

Posted 01:12 4th January 2011

Melvyn Platt says...

I am very annoyed at batsman who try to play the sweep shot and usually get out to it.I seem to remember a test match years ago when at least four batsmen were out trying to play that shot.Coaches should tell them to forget it.If the ball is outside or on off stump and short then drive into the covers.The young lad batting at 3 for the aussies could have made a lot of runs before he played the sweep.I blame Dennis Compton.

Posted 06:41 3rd January 2011

David Rattray says...

wat u think of KP,s comments is he claiming too much credit r has his arguements some credence or has his ego taken over again sometimes he talks when he should be listening

Posted 21:24 2nd January 2011

Ian Watson says...

Bumble Agree with your comments - I think Shane Watson is an asset who will develop rather than a liability. My question is there were so many team borderline talented Aussies just a few years ago who surely aren't all over the hill, whats happened to them all? Hauritz, Bracken, Tait, Kreycza, White, Clark, Jacques, Hodge Some decent players there, Clark , Bracken and Tait especially.

Posted 20:51 2nd January 2011

Keith Walmsley says...

Just starting a night shift and cant wait for the test to begin time for history for this brilliant england team, they are that good in the words of a football crowd" its just like watching Australia" I am now 50 years old and still bear the scars of messers ! lillie and thompson blowing england away sat in my shorts with me dad hoping for a win ! Day 3 at melbourne was fantastic,i hope the England management keep investing in the team/and the infrastructure,You get what you pay for! retain Andy flower at all costs. With regards to ricky ponting i feel a little sorry for him,he is only as good as the team and i in no way condone his arguments with the umpire (yellow card / red by by) but its just his burning desire to beat the old enemy ! who wants to be the man who captained the aussies to 3 ashes defeats, Once again well done england and keep the boot on the chin rattlers throats!

Posted 20:01 2nd January 2011

Abhijit Guha says...

to bumble, you english are really over the moon with 2 tests victory over australia. remember they are behing you in icc rankings and presently their team is probably the poorest since 1985. and what are u talking about making bouncy and pacy pitches in england next summer? it will help england against srilanka, but against india? see what they did to sa in durban... remember in england in 2007.. we won 1-0.. we beat u convingly in india in 2008.. so please see the reality and then speak .... and another thing.. if you take the averages of indian batsman in sa/eng/aus and compare it with yours in these 3 places, you will still see their averages is higher than yours.. so we will request you to make the most bouncy and lively pitch ever in engalnd next summer.. then see the result...

Posted 05:20 2nd January 2011

Scott Bannan says...

I think that australia have finally reached the rebuilding stage. Most countries have already reached this stage. The hangover of losing so many great players like glen mcgath and shane warne has finally hit home. Their players are not world class anymore but merely average. If they are not careful the situation will get worse when their only world class players retire as well which is not too far away (ponting and hussey). All in all I think that australias domination of world cricket is over, and that's something they will have to come to terms with. I am proud to say south africa had a hand in winning the ashes, strauss.. Trott.. Pieterson. Perhaps the "england" team is not as strong as you think.

Posted 04:47 2nd January 2011

Dean Burback says...

Arrogance has a nasty habit of coming back and biting you in the b.tt and your comment about India reeks of arrogance, Krishna Venkat! SA folded like an cheap suit in Durban but on the other quicker and bouncer track in the first test at Centurion, you seemed to have quickly forgotten what happened to India there. Oh, so much for their batting line up in that test then!

Posted 17:51 1st January 2011

Andrew Kenneally says...

Barry Thomas says... 'Watson is a liability, move him down the order.' After Hussey, Watson has been Australia's best batsman, maybe along with Haddin, He may not be ideal but Australia have plenty bigger problems than him. Also I think his opening partnership with Katich has actually thus far a better average than the famed Langer Hayden one.

Posted 12:57 1st January 2011

Sai Santhosh says...

Bumble,last time when india toured england they won a match in nottingham and went on to win the series...eng were bundled out for 198 on a green top and india went on to make 483,so green top is not a problem for india..it suits their bowlers... and you can take perth and durban wins also as an example.....

Posted 07:39 1st January 2011

Robert Clifford says...

get rid of smith, he cant choose whether hes a batsmen that can bowl, or a spinner that can bat. and to be honest hes not that good a either. it thats the type of player the aussies are looking for they should of stuck with north, we proved in england hes a better bowler than smith, and normally a better batter. for the captiency i think ponting should go, under his reign the sussies have lost three ashes. hes a wolrd cals player, but a pub standard captain. i think hussey should captain the fith test, as clarke is not well liked as captain.

Posted 00:50 1st January 2011

Peter Mernagh says...

How is Watson a liability? he is averaging over fifty and along with Mike Hussey he is holding the Aussies together

Posted 21:20 31st December 2010

Keith Wilson says...

They should drop Ponting....and then we can hammer the Aussies and scar them mentally.If they are talking about getting rid of Ponting let them do it,Im sick and tired of watching Australia hammer us over the years so let them get rid and hopefully they will be even worse.

Posted 21:01 31st December 2010

Kaustubh Verma says...

Bumble......What did England do at Perth..and what did India do at Durban...??? Pace and bounce is more troublesome for most English players as well...Check your facts before writing articles!

Posted 20:58 31st December 2010

David Neale says...

Bumble, firstly happy new year, and secondly I agree with your article. I hope we don't follow the 1986 boys and lose to a shambles in the last test. Just like 1986 the score in the history books doesn't bare any correlation to our dominence. Make it 3-1 lads please to both ensure i win my bet with the neg fairies at work and also to reflect the hard work and preparation the team have shown. On Punter, the guy's an absolute legend in my book, the best Aussie batsman since Border and whilst I think Tendulkar has been the best bat of the last 20 years, Punter is right there behind him. I've just read Gilchrist's book and he makes reference to ponting being a natural leader and astute in the game. I beg to differ on his captaincy , whilst I think he is the best puller of a cricket ball I have seen (Robin Smith is no.2), he has guts by the bucket load and he's a great sportsman. The media never give him the credit for his humility. If he recognises he's been beaten by a better team he never makes excuses. Notice how many time this series at the end of a day's play he's gone over to the batsman and shook their hand. I commend him for sticking with Aussie cricket when he could have gone out on a high with all the big guns. He needs to do what Nasser did and play as a batsmen for the next 2 years and then call it a day. Ricky Ponting the batsmen still has a lot to offer, Ricky Ponting the captain should end at Melbourne.

Posted 20:04 31st December 2010

Richard Swales says...

Hi Bumble.. i think Ponting should still be in the team, but what about giving the captaincy to Hussey, he's a good bloke for an Aussie and not a bad cricketer. India, Sri Lanka and Bangledesh need to look at the piches out in Aussie instead of preparering plat batter friendly piches.

Posted 18:17 31st December 2010

Bryan Little says...

What a wonderful achievement by Strauss and his team. After what happened at the WACA the turnabout at the MCG gave me,and I am sure millions of other fans, a tremendous thrill. I have only been able to tune in to the written over updates but even that has been exciting - reminding me of when I was a boy listening on the radio to commentary that came in waves and was very indistinct. Sydney usually produces a result - it wont be easy for our lads but we shall be willing them on. It would be a bit special if Collingwood comes good.

Posted 16:54 31st December 2010

Barry Thomas says...

Watson is a liability, move him down the order.

Posted 12:53 31st December 2010

John Mc donagh says...

Good call Bumble,Clarke has hidden behind Ponting for years, lets see how he performs with responsibility?? Being a Yorkshireman it was to see Bresnan given his chance. If England keep it down to earth and work hard the NO 1 spot is a reality. Roll on Sydney for 3-1 it wont be easy the Aussie's will be hurting.

Posted 11:10 31st December 2010

Tim Starbuck says...

I agree they should not drop ponting, i am still in shock that david hussey never got mentioned for selection, a class batsmen with experience who will have faced most of our attack while playing a pivotal role for Notts, surely he would have been a better pick than the very raw smith, also Hughes has a massive technique issue and surely they would have been better moving up mike hussey to open and look at ferguson or the new guy thats been called up to replace ponting, a team of, m hussey, watson, ponting, haddin, clarke, hussey, ferguson and then 4 bowlers would look alot more solid batting lineup, either way our boys have done us proud and flower will keep them going for more

Posted 21:22 30th December 2010

  • Page 1 of 2
  • 1
  • 2

Latest Poll

Will Charley Hull beat Laura Davies' record of 45 Ladies European Tour wins?

View Results