Would Philippe Coutinho get straight back into Liverpool's starting XI if he was fit? And should they sell him after their impressive recent displays?
Those were among the questions for Phil Neville, Danny Mills and Alan Smith on The Debate on Sky Sports Premier League on Monday evening.
Coutinho is currently away on international duty with Brazil even though he has yet to play for Liverpool this season due to a back injury.
Barcelona have seen three bids rejected for the 25-year-old this summer and sporting director Robert Fernandez says they want to make two more signings before the window closes.
But should Liverpool sell the Brazilian after seeing their attacking players impress in the Champions League win over Hoffenheim and then the 4-0 home victory over Arsenal on Sunday?
Neville, Mills and Smith debated the topic on The Debate. Hit play on the video at the top of the page to see what was discussed.