Skip to content

Mayweather vs McGregor: Our panel of experts choose the boxer they believe could best make the transition to MMA

LAS VEGAS, NV - AUGUST 12:  UFC featherweight champion Conor McGregor sits to do promotional spots during an open workout at his gym on August 12, 2016 in
Image: Which boxer would fare best in the cage where Conor McGregor has made his name?

Ahead of UFC star Conor McGregor entering a boxing ring to take on Floyd Mayweather, we asked our panel of experts which boxer would best make the switch in the opposite direction...

Book Mayweather vs McGregor
Book Mayweather vs McGregor

You can book the unique Las Vegas event online here...

Spencer Oliver

American boxer Rocky Marciano (1923 - 1969) batters Roland La Starza against the ropes in the 11th round of their heavyweight contest at the Polo Grounds,
Image: The Brockton Blocbuster Rocky Marciano (L) retired with a record of 49-0

I would pick Rocky Marciano because he was a real roughhouse and liked that style of fighting. He's the one holding the 49-0 record, if you look back at the history, it's so impressive the fights he had to come through, especially ones where he had to climb off the floor.

It wasn't about skill back then as much, but who was the toughest and roughest, who could bite down on the gum shield the best and come through rough patches.

Matthew Macklin

12th March 1973:  World heavyweight boxing champion George Foreman at a press conference in London.  (Photo by Arthur Jones/Evening Standard/Getty Images)
Image: George Foreman was a two-time world heavyweight champion and an Olympic gold medallist

George Foreman would be my choice. He's an absolute beast, an animal who was freakishly strong and powerful when in the boxing ring.

Whether it is in boxing or MMA, if Foreman catches you with a big shot then it's likely you're knocked out. You only need to have a look at how many people he stopped during his career.

Johnny Nelson

Wladimir Klitschko takes part in an open workout at Wembley Arena
Image: Johnny Nelson believes recently retired Wladimir Klitschko would adapt to the UFC

I am going to say Wladimir Klitschko - and not just because he's retired from boxing! I just see him as the one who can adjust to the discipline quicker than anyone. He was a successful kickboxer as well.

At his peak - and not a million miles away from his Wembley display - he had fast legs, fast hands and he could tie fighters up. And punch.

Also See:

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Watch Mayweather v McGregor exclusively live on Sky Sports Box Office on the August 26

David Coldwell

Roberto Duran
Image: Known as Manos de Piedra (Hands of Stone) Roberto Duran never shied away from a fight

I would go for someone like Roberto Duran. He was a vicious animal in the ring and very good on the inside. He was also a boxer who could always fight dirty if he had to and find a way to win.

For a fighter to go from lightweight up to super-middleweight, fighting the likes of Sugar Ray Leonard, you've got to have a certain level of toughness about you.

Darren Barker

Anthony Joshua celebrates victory over Wladimir Klitschko in their heavyweight world title bout
Image: Anthony Joshua celebrates his unification victory over Klitschko

Do you fancy getting in the octagon with Anthony Joshua? He's huge and if he caught you with a shot with 4oz gloves on, you are bang in trouble.

From the past, someone like Naseem Hamed. He had that explosive power and unorthodox style where he was jumping from all over the place, coming up with big uppercuts. When a cage fighter was going to lunge forward, you can imagine Hamed throwing a big uppercut.

Tony Bellew

Tony Bellew celebrates his shock 11th-round TKO victory over David Haye
Image: Tony Bellew defeated London's David Haye back in March

I would back myself to get in the cage. I can wrestle, I can grapple, I punch hard, I can kick and I've got some kickboxing experience.

Bellew: Bring on Bisping
Bellew: Bring on Bisping

Tony Bellew would happily enter a cage or a ring and would be open to facing Michael Bisping.

You can forget about me getting in the cage with someone like Jon Jones [UFC light-heavyweight champion] - not a chance, but with a puncher, why not?

Carl Froch

9 Nov 1996: Steve Collins of Ireland (left) swings and misses Nigel Benn, with a left hook, during the Benn v Collins rematch at the Nynex Arena in Manches
Image: Steve Collins beat both Nigel Benn and Chris Eubank Sr twice

I suppose everyone said Mike Tyson, so I am going to go for Steve Collins. He was rock hard, he could take a shot and he had more skills than people give him credit for.

The Irish support would be right behind him, which would help, and having watched Collins beat Nigel Benn and Chris Eubank, I just think he would like it in the octagon!

f you are using skysports.com you can comment below to get involved in the debate, but please adhere to our House Rules. If you wish to report any comment, simply click on the down arrow next to the offending comment and click 'Report'.

Watch Mayweather vs McGregor, from the T-Mobile Arena, Las Vegas, from midnight August 26, live on Sky Sports Box Office. Book via your Sky remote or online here.

Around Sky