Skip to content

Manchester City avoid transfer ban after winning Benjamin Garre case

Benjamin Garre during the UEFA Youth League match between Feyenoord Rotterdam U19 and Manchester City U19 at the van Donge & de Roo stadium on September 13, 2017
Image: Benjamin Garre joined Manchester City from Velez Sarsfield in 2016

Manchester City have avoided a transfer ban after winning their case against Velez Sarsfield at the Court of Arbitration for Sport.

The Argentine club had claimed that the new Premier League champions, who were given a ban from signing certain academy players by the league last year, broke FIFA rules when they signed teenager Benjamin Garre in 2016.

Garre was 16 at the time but Argentine officials accused City of tapping him up when he was still 15, pointing to FIFA rules that say no player can leave their home country until they are 18, unless the player's parents move countries for "non-footballing reasons".

Benjamin Garre arrives ahead of the UEFA Youth League Group F match between Napoli and Manchester City on November 1, 2017
Image: Garre holds an Italian passport

FIFA agreed with City, however, saying that because Garre holds an Italian passport he was free to leave Argentina after his 16th birthday.

Velez then took the case to the CAS and City were facing the prospect of being banned from registering any new players for two transfer windows, similar to previous punishments given to Atletico Madrid, Barcelona and Real Madrid.

Velez could yet make a technical appeal against its decision.

Also See:

City were banned from signing youth players between 10 and 18 for two years, the second of those being suspended, and fined £300,000 last year after being found guilty by the Premier League of illegal approaches to two players registered with other clubs.

Live Nissan Super Sunday

Play Super 6 for £250k
Play Super 6 for £250k

Could you be the next Super 6 jackpot winner? Enter your predictions for free here.