Blogs & Opinion


New scrum laws can improve attacking game, says Stuart Barnes

Stuart Barnes - Stuart Barnes Posted 9th September 2013 view comments

At the end of the match between Gloucester and Sale, a disgruntled home supporter turned to me and said, "So much for the new scrum laws then?"

The match had indeed made something of a mockery of the set piece which is at the centre of the newest of new laws which, ironically, are a throwback to previous times.

The supporter had a point. Collapses were in abundance, free kicks here and there and wasted minutes. All very déjà vu but hold on a minute; last Tuesday I heard Wayne Barnes state that the referees, players and coaches had to be held accountable.

Wayne Barnes: Gave a dominant performance at Bath's set pieces

Wayne Barnes: Gave a dominant performance at Bath's set pieces

So let's point a few fingers of blame in certain directions. Andrew Small yellow carded Nick Wood for persistently cheating at the scrum. There is one obvious finger pointing. However, it is hard not to think that Small himself failed to get a grip on the revised, depowered and technically more interesting new version of the scrums. It looked badly managed. Before fans dismiss the August 1 to end of season trial a wider analysis is a must.

It looked badly managed. Before fans dismiss the August 1 to end of season trial a wider analysis is a must.

Stuart Barnes
Quotes of the week

In the Gloucester game the home team played with an absence of rugby intelligence or poise and deserved defeat against the smart and committed Sale who had a beauty of a first try. It was a first phase move from a scrum that was held stable and enabled Dwayne Peel to dart to the short side and open Gloucester up. Properly managed, the new laws are an incentive for attacking rugby.

One night earlier, Barnes took charge of Newcastle's wet reintroduction to the Premiership against Bath. It was a filthy night with a sodden surface. Last season would have seen every scrum slip as the game slid away to an eighty- minute reset. But Barnes gave a dominant display at the set piece with the result that the superior scrum of Bath was rewarded with eventual, match winning domination.

Emphatic

Ditto Saturday morning's match in Brisbane where South Africa brought a seven match losing record at the Sun Corp Stadium to an emphatic end. Australia were worn down in the scrum and utterly destabilised by the final quarter. Technical supremacy was well and truly rewarded.

Even earlier that morning we saw a sterling scrum contest between New Zealand and Argentina with the South Americans losing the game but maintaining their pride; on the balance of the four matches I watched before writing this column (early Sunday afternoon) the overall early evidence is positive. The key remains the referee and the attitude of the coach and his players. If they want to play, rather than seek out a series of endless penalties, the game has taken a step in the right direction by looking back to the way scrums once were.

Traditional craft will play a bigger role than pure power. And that must be for the long term benefit of the game. It simply cannot keep getting bigger, fitter and faster at the startling rate witnessed in this century. Laws that make a place for a big fat tight head capable of nothing but stabilising the attacking team's scrum is great news. It might just open the field to attack with a few starters not the awesome physical machine most players now are.

By making the scrum a contest with technique and not just the power of the fit and shove an elemental requirement, some players might remember that just getting bigger, fitter and faster does not necessarily equate with being better.The world's Number One team, the All Blacks, have their fair share of giant athletes but it is rugby nous that glues them together. Richie McCaw is a great player but there are open sides with more speed and strength. There are none with greater rugby intelligence which explains his longevity at the summit of the game.

If a club team in Europe wanted to sign a back capable of changing the way they play, the first name on the book would be Conrad Smith. He's tall but gangly, elusive but hardly mesmerising on the run and a fine defender, yet not a brute of a hitter. But he has a brilliant rugby brain. A constant increase in size and an ever larger scrum is progress, but not all progress is of a beneficial nature.

Gloucester lost to Sale because they were rudderless. All the physical conditioning in the world cannot save a team that loses the ability to think for itself.

This weekend

Next week the cerebral Kiwis wits needs be quicker than at any time this season as they clash with South Africa at Eden Park. With home advantage the All Blacks are favourites but the Springboks have size and a clearly thought out strategy that could cause a few problems for New Zealand. Even if New Zealand win, South Africa have scored enough bonus points to leave them in a good position to make the Rugby Championship decider in Johannesburg the game of the year for the rugby neutral.

In British eyes that game has to be the third Test in Sydney and rightly so. The Lions don't often win series, but the manner of the Springbok demolition of the Wallabies is perhaps a reminder that the people charged with appointing the manager for the New Zealand tour in 2017 should not rush things.

Australia are not a good team and brilliant a performance as we saw in the deciding Test, we could easily have lost 2-1 had Christian Leali'ifano not been injured within a minute of the first Test. Warren Gatland has Lions knowledge and a series win to his name. He deserves to be in poll position at the moment, but Australia's constant losing run is a reminder that perspective needs to be kept and some time taken before reaching a decision that could look very different even a year from now.

So much for the Lions, it is the other championship for me at the weekend - My first Greene King IPA match. And having enjoyed a few sunny days in the company of Andy Robinson and Ian Davies, as The Cornish Pirates and Bristol prepare for their first games, I am excited to see some ambitious attacking play.

But It is fair to say that I am looking forward to the All Blacks versus the Springboks even more.

Comments (1)

  • Page 1 of 1
  • 1

Tom Greevy says...

Having now played & coached with the new scrum laws they are much better than before as they reward technique and nous as opposed to brute size. Whilst front rows are stereotyped for not being smart ours at Leamington RFC have shone way above our locals having dominated the scrum in all three warm up games. This has not been a result of any major focus in training other than 30 mins 4 weeks ago. One other good bit of news is you can compete for the ball and get turnover scrums which we have taken great joy in doing. Long live the new scrum laws

Posted 20:49 9th September 2013

  • Page 1 of 1
  • 1

back to top

Other Rugby Union Experts:

Latest Posts in Rugby Union:

Stuart Barnes

Ups and downs

Stuart Barnes says the drama of relegation must be kept in rugby, but the play-offs need changing....

Stuart Barnes

Rising to the top

Stuart Barnes says Toulon look like the team to beat after a mixed Heineken Cup play-off weekend....

Latest News RSS feeds

Carter inspired by Wilkinson

Dan Carter describes how 'ultimate professional' Jonny Wilkinson inspired him to climb to the summit of world rugby.

Duo agree Warriors deals

Rob Harley and Tyrone Holmes have both agreed new two-year deals with Glasgow Warriors.

Aussies unveil autumn fixtures

Australia will face two of their World Cup opponents of 2015 during this year's autumn trip to the northern hemisphere.

Carter: England are contenders

Stuart Lancaster has transformed England into genuine Rugby World Cup 2015 contenders, says New Zealand's Dan Carter.

Saracens receive Farrell boost

Saracens fly-half Owen Farrell has been cleared to resume training after suffering a foot injury against Northampton.

Features

Good week/Bad week: The winners and losers from the last sporting week

Good week/Bad week: The winners and losers from the last sporting week

It's been another incredible week of sport from Augusta to Anfield via Andalusia, but for every sporting hero there must be a villain.

Watch the Heineken Cup semi-finals live on Sky Sports

Watch the Heineken Cup semi-finals live on Sky Sports

The Heineken Cup has already thrown up some brutal encounters this season, and Sky Sports will be bringing you all the action from the semi-finals as Europe's finest take centre stage.