Paige failed to win the Divas Title on Raw - but did leave champion Charlotte writhing in agony.
The British Diva was granted a rematch for the gold after footage from Sunday's Survivor Series pay-per-view showed Charlotte's arm was under the rope when Paige tapped out to the Figure Eight.
The Norwich-born grappler fought hard in Nashville on Monday night, even administering a submission move akin to Charlotte's, but saw her championship hopes quashed when she was speared through the ropes by The Nature Girl and both competitors were counted out.
Paige got to her feet first, however, and proceeded to hurl Charlotte into the steel ring steps and lock in a PTO on the announce desk, a fate that befell Becky Lynch a few weeks ago in Manchester.
Lynch, meanwhile, suffered defeat to Sasha Banks in Music City when The Boss' Team B.A.D. allies, Tamina and Naomi, distracted the Irish wrestler and allowed Banks to win via a sneaky roll-up.
Elsewhere, Heath Slater paid the price for whacking Ryback with a guitar when he was Shell Shocked by The Big Guy, while Bray Wyatt and Luke Harper responded to their Survivor Series defeat to Kane and The Undertaker by making mincemeat of The Dudley Boyz.
Dean Ambrose and Dolph Ziggler teamed up to down Tyler Breeze and Kevin Owens; Neville pinned the World's Strongest Man, Mark Henry, following a Red Arrow to prevail in a little-and-large contest; and Goldust and The Prime-Time Players edged The Cosmic Wasteland.
Plus, The New Day swiftly reneged on their decision to hold an open challenge for their WWE Tag Team Titles when The Usos and The Lucha Dragons emerged from the locker room - a move that led to the positive-thinking trio being pummelled by the Samoan twins and the luchadores.
And, finally, Roman Reigns clobbered Sheamus, the man he will fight for the WWE World Heavyweight Title at TLC on December 13, with a steel chair.
The Juggernaut asked for a bout with Sheamus during Raw's opening moments after the Dubliner cashed in his Money in the Bank contract at Survivor Series to pinch Reigns' newly-acquired strap but was told by Triple H he would have to wait until the next pay-per-view.
The former Shield star was instead placed in a scrap against Rusev but when that clash ended prematurely due to Sheamus' pal, King Barrett, clubbing him with a Bull Hammer, Reigns launched a frenzied assault on Barrett, Rusev and Sheamus with the aforementioned chair.
TLC BOOKING DETAILS
WWE TLC (Tables, Ladders and Chairs) will be shown on Sky Sports Box Office (channel 491) and Sky Sports HD Box Office (channel 492) at 1am on Sunday, December 13 (Monday morning).
WWE TLC will be repeated on Sky Sports Box Office (channel 491) but NOT Sky Sports HD Box Office (channel 492) between 9am, Monday, December 14 and 9pm, Thursday, December 17.
Repeat showings will last for three hours, with the final showing STARTING at 9pm on Thursday, December 17.
The event is priced at £14.95 for UK customers, €21.95 for viewers in the Republic of Ireland.
Viewers can call 03442 410 888 to book WWE TLC from Tuesday, December 1. (There may be an additional charge for telephone bookings).
You can also book WWE TLC online from Tuesday, December 1 by visiting this link: https://my.sky.com/orderboxoffice/
Only bookings via Sky TV remote are recordable using Sky Plus.
Sky TV residential customers only. Commercial customers contact Sky for price and to order. Sky Box Office terms apply.
Cable customers should contact their local cable operator.