Skip to content

Top 10 Super Bowl moments: 'Philly Special' touchdown, David Tyree's helmet catch and Malcolm Butler's goal-line pick

Watch Super Bowl LVII from State Farm Stadium in Glendale, Arizona, live on Sky Sports NFL on Sunday February 12; the AFC's Kansas City Chiefs will face the Philadelphia Eagles from the NFC (kick-off, 11.30pm), with live coverage under way from 10pm

Top 10 Super Bowl Moments

What is the best moment in Super Bowl history?

Ahead of Super Bowl LVII between the Kansas City Chiefs and Philadelphia Eagles - live on Sky Sports NFL from 10pm, Sunday (Kick-off, 11.30pm) - we have delved back into the archives and plucked out some of the biggest plays, most dramatic finishes and shocking upsets to make up our top 10 moments.

Click on the video above to take a trip down memory lane to relive some of those Super Bowl stunners and read on for our list below...

1) Butler's goal-line, game-winning pick

New England Patriots 28-24 Seattle Seahawks, Super Bowl XLIX, Phoenix, 2015

OUT OF CAMERA FILE - New England Patriots cornerback Malcolm Butler (21) intercepts a pass intended for Seattle Seahawks wide receiver Ricardo Lockette (83) during the second half of NFL Super Bowl XLIX football game Sunday, Feb. 1, 2015, in Glendale, Ariz. (AP Photo/Kathy Willens)
Image: Patriots cornerback Malcolm Butler intercepts a pass intended for Seahawks receiver Ricardo Lockette on the goal line to end Super Bowl XLIX

Although hard to believe, given the record seven Super Bowl rings Tom Brady has since retired with, he was enduring somewhat of a drought in the years between his third in 2005 and this one a decade later - and it looked for all the world as though Super Bowl XLIX was to be a third to slip through his grasp in that time.

A circus catch from Jermaine Kearse had helped set the Seattle Seahawks up at the goal line, trailing by four but with 26 seconds to spare - more than enough time to hand the ball off to 'Beast Mode' running back Marshawn Lynch for the game-winning score, right? Wrong.

In one of the craziest play-calls in football history, Seattle opted to pass, and quarterback Russell Wilson was picked off by rookie Patriots cornerback Malcolm Butler in this truly incredible finish.

Also See:

2) Tyree's helmet catch defeats Pats

New York Giants 17-14 New England Patriots, Super Bowl XLII, Phoenix, 2008

David Tyree's helmet catch in Super Bowl XLII
Image: David Tyree hangs on for his helmet catch in the Giants' win over the previously unbeaten Patriots in Super Bowl XLII

It was supposed to be a procession, as the 16-0 Patriots, aiming to become the first team to go a whole season undefeated since the 1972 Miami Dolphins, took on the 10-6 New York Giants in Super Bowl XLII, but Eli Manning and company had obviously not read the script.

The Giants' ferocious pass rush got to Brady with regularity, limiting New England's explosive offense to just 14 points heading into the final two minutes. Manning, with the ball back in his hands, was then tasked with leading his team on a game-winning drive and pulled off the unthinkable.

The drive's most memorable play, and arguably the greatest of all time in Super Bowl history, saw Manning somehow escape pressure from the Patriots pass rush and launch the ball downfield on a prayer to David Tyree, who pulled off that catch - a stunning, one-handed grab on the side of his helmet - for a crucial 32-yard pickup on third-and-five.

A few plays later, with just 35 seconds left on the clock, Manning then picked out Plaxico Burress in the endzone for the game-winning score.

3) Titans stopped one yard short

St. Louis Rams 23-16 Tennessee Titans, Super Bowl XXXIV, Atlanta, 2000

Super Bowl XXXIV
Image: Titans receiver Kevin Dyson is tackled one-yard short of the goal line in their Super Bowl XXXIV loss to the Rams

The Tennessee Titans - having recovered from a 16-point deficit to the St Louis Rams and their 'Greatest Show on Turf' in the third quarter - were driving down the field in the dying seconds looking for a potential game-tying touchdown to take Super Bowl XXXIV to overtime.

At the Rams' 10-yard line, with six seconds on the clock, quarterback Steve McNair quickly got the ball out of his hands, finding receiver Kevin Dyson at the three-yard line, who seemed set to streak into the endzone.

Not so. Rams linebacker Mike Jones came up with a clutch tackle, dropping Dyson short of the goal line and the Rams held on for a stunning win.

4) Santonio scores in dying seconds

Pittsburgh Steelers 27-23 Seattle Seahawks, Super Bowl XLIII, Tampa Bay, 2009

Santonio Holmes, Super Bowl XLIII
Image: Santonio Holmes goes up and makes the game-winning grab for the Steelers against the Cardinals in Super Bowl XLIII

This Ben Roethlisberger to Santonio Holmes stunner saw the Pittsburgh Steelers clinch a then-record sixth Vince Lombardi Trophy with a 27-23 win over the Arizona Cardinals in Super Bowl XLIII.

Pittsburgh had ended the first half up 17-7 after a title-game record 100-yard interception return for a touchdown by James Harrison, but a 127-yard and two-TD outing by Arizona receiver Larry Fitzgerald had edged them ahead by three going into the final two minutes of the game.

Big Ben wrestled the game back in Pittsburgh's favour, however, driving the Steelers down the field and breaking the hearts of Cards fans the world over with the most perfectly placed ball for Holmes in the back corner of the endzone with just 35 seconds left on the clock.

5) Foles' 'Philly Special' TD for Eagles

Philadelphia Eagles 41-33 New England Patriots, Super Bowl LII, Minneapolis, 2018

Philadelphia Eagles' Nick Foles catches a touchdown pass during the first half of the NFL Super Bowl 52 football game against the New England Patriots Sunday, Feb. 4, 2018, in Minneapolis. (AP Photo/Jeff Roberson)
Image: Eagles quarterback Nick Foles catches a touchdown pass as part of their 'Philly Special' play in Super Bowl LII against the Patriots

Several records were set, including most combined yards gained in an NFL game (1,151), fewest punts by both teams in a Super Bowl (one), and most points scored by a Super Bowl losing team (33) in this thriller!

The most famous moment of it all was undoubtedly when Philadelphia Eagles backup quarterback Nick Foles, who had so inspired their run to the big game after the late-season injury to starter Carson Wentz, dialled up the 'Philly Special' with head coach Doug Pederson shortly before half-time.

Faced with a fourth-and-goal, on the one-yard line, with 38 seconds left in the half, the play call saw running back Corey Clement take a direct snap, pitch the ball to tight end Trey Burton, who then picked out a wide-open Foles in the right of the endzone.

It gave Philly a 22-12 lead at the break and they would hold on for a stunning 41-33 triumph over the Patriots.

6) Hester's kick-off TD to open Super Bowl

Indianapolis Colts 29-17 Chicago Bears, Super Bowl XLI, Miami, 2007

Devin Hester's opening kickoff return for a touchdown, Super Bowl XLI
Image: Devin Hester is off to the races on his way to scoring a touchdown off the opening kickoff in Super Bowl XLI

The greatest returner in the history of the NFL. That is the widely-held view of Devin Hester, who holds the record with 14 punt returns for touchdowns, to go along with five TDs on kick-off returns.

This was Hester's most famous of them all, a 92-yard score to open up Super Bowl XLI and stun the watching world.

All the more remarkable is the fact Hester was just a rookie on a Chicago Bears team that ultimately lost 29-17 to the Indianapolis Colts. He backed up that 2006 season, in which he had six return scores, by doubling his TD tally with another six in his sophomore season. Electric!

7) Norwood misses wide right for Bills

New York Giants 20-19 Buffalo Bills, Super Bowl XXV, Tampa Bay, 1981

Scott Norwood misses his game-winning field goal attempt, Super Bowl XXV
Image: Bills kicker Scott Norwood misses wide right with his game-winning field goal attempt in Super Bowl XXV

Perhaps one of the greatest disappointments in sport, let alone just the Super Bowl era, as poor old Buffalo Bills kicker, Scott Norwood, missed the game-winning field goal wide right from 47 yards out as time expired in Super Bowl XXV.

The Bills' 20-19 defeat to the Giants was the first of four straight losses for the franchise in the biggest game of them all, but was easily the toughest of the lot to take - a certain defensive coordinator called Bill Belichick masterminding the Giants' victory over the best offense in football that year.

8) Edelman's miracle catch in Pats comeback

New England Patriots 34-28 Atlanta Falcons (OT), Super Bowl LI, Houston, 2017

AP - New England Patriots' Julian Edelman makes a catch as Atlanta Falcons' Ricardo Allen and Keanu Neal defend
Image: Patriots receiver Julian Edelman makes a stunning catch in their incredible comeback win over the Falcons in Super Bowl LI

Another circus catch on this list, this time working in favour of the Patriots as wide receiver Julian Edelman pulled off a gravity-defying grab in the team's stunning comeback win over the Atlanta Falcons in Super Bowl LI.

I think we all know the story by now; New England, having trailed 28-3 midway through the third quarter, somehow turned things around and pulled off a remarkable comeback win in overtime, with Edelman playing a key role.

With three minutes and 30 seconds left in the game, New England were still down by eight and backed up at their nine-yard line, still with it all to do. Brady began to inch them down the field with a couple of completions, but then could, and perhaps, should have been picked off by Robert Alford on this throw intended for Edelman.

Instead, Alford batted the ball in the air, it fell into the arms of the Patriots wideout, who made a diving catch as it bounced off Alford's shoe - even managing to juggle the ball further without ever losing control or letting it hit the turf.

Soon after that 23-yard completion, New England tied the game with a touchdown and successful two-point conversion, going on to win a fifth Vince Lombardi in OT.

9) Elway's 'helicopter' run in beating Green Bay

Denver Broncos 31-24 Green Bay Packers, Super Bowl XXXII, San Diego, 1998

John Elway's helicopter run, Super Bowl XXXII
Image: John Elway dives for the first-down marker in his famous 'helicopter' run in Denver's Super Bowl XXXII win over Green Bay

Denver Broncos quarterback John Elway was reaching his then record-equalling fourth Super Bowl with the Denver Broncos at the ripe old age of 37. The only problem was, Elway had yet to win one, being handily beaten in his hat-trick of prior visits.

He was not to be denied on this occasion, though, putting his body on the line - literally - with this memorable 'helicopter' run in Denver's Super Bowl XXXII win over the defending champion, and heavily favoured, Green Bay Packers.

With the game very much in the balance, tied up at 17-17 in the third quarter, the Broncos faced a third-and-six from the Green Bay 12-yard line. Elway scrambled for the first down and, in diving for the marker, he was hit so hard by the two closing Packers defenders that he spun 360 degrees in mid-air.

A few plays later, Terrell Davis scored the second of his MVP-worthy three touchdowns on the day and Denver held on to finally earn Elway the Super Bowl ring his gutsy, determined effort so deserved.

10) Belichick and Brady dynasty begins

New England Patriots 20-17 St. Louis Rams, Super Bowl XXXVI, New Orleans, 2002

Adam Vinatieri, Super Bowl XXXVI
Image: Patriots kicker Adam Vinatieri celebrates as he fires through the game-winning field goal in Super Bowl XXXVI

Given the upward trajectory both Belichick and Brady's careers have taken since, it is easy to forget the Patriots were 14-point underdogs for Super Bowl XXXVI, when they took on the 'Greatest Show on Turf', looking to claim the first of their record haul of six rings.

Belichick's Pats restricted the explosive St Louis offense to just three points in as many quarters until the Rams finally found some form in the fourth, scoring two touchdowns to tie the game up at 17 apiece.

But step forward New England kicker Adam Vinatieri, who fired through the game-winning field goal from 48 yards out as time expired to truly signal the start of the Patriots dynasty.

Watch Super Bowl LVII - Kansas City Chiefs vs Philadelphia Eagles - live on Sky Sports NFL and Main Event from 10pm on Sunday February 12, with Ryan Fitzpatrick, Christian Wilkins and Efe Obada among the guests joining Neil Reynolds and Hannah Wilkes for 90 minutes of build-up to the big game.

Around Sky