Blogs & Opinion

Man of more seasons

City boss has kept cap on club issues well enough to stay, says Jeff

Jeff Stelling - Jeff Stelling Posted 5th April 2012 view comments

There appears to be an increasing clamour for Roberto Mancini's blood.

Now I don't know him at all, but I've grown to like him from a distance so I hope that should Manchester City miss out on this Premier League title, that Sheikh Mansour will give him at least one more season because there have been many more positives in his tenure than negatives.

Just the Rob: Mancini is the right man to guide City forward, says Jeff

Just the Rob: Mancini is the right man to guide City forward, says Jeff

Those negatives are, of course, well-documented - from the departure of former chief executive Garry Cook last September, to the constant problems with Carlos Tevez and Mario Balotelli.

Throw in the enviable challenge of vying for the league title and playing in the Champions League for the first time - juggling all those huge names (and egos) within the squad - and you could argue it's testament to Mancini's man-management that they trail Manchester United by only five points.

City aren't out of the Premier League race yet but my gut feeling is that this is United's title. I think their fate might be determined this weekend.

Jeff Stelling
Quotes of the week

Sky Sports Fantasy Football
Play Fantasy Football against Jeff Stelling each win for the chance to win great prizes. Pick your team.

Play Super 6
Think you know your football? Predict the scores for six matches for the chance to win £100,000. It's free to play and you could land the jackpot. Play now

I thought I was watching Winchester U13s again when Balotelli fell out with Aleksander Kolarov in Saturday's 3-3 draw with Sunderland.

You often see debates about who should take free-kicks around the edge of the box, but this was the stuff of second years at senior school NOT Premier League fare in front of a watching audience of thousands.


One-off flare-ups you can forgive; unfortunately City have had far too many incidents over the course of the season. In my view, Mancini has kept a cap on things pretty well.

There are things I don't understand - chiefly the fact that Adam Johnson has seemingly been condemned to the Siberia of the substitutes' bench and the signing of Owen Hargreaves, which was trumpeted at the time but has been a huge mistake.

Plus, like all managers, Mancini has had some bad luck along the way: Vincent Kompany got injured at the same time as Joleon Lescott, while David Silva (who has been wonderful) has hit the buffers and looks like he's got nothing left to give.

Then there's Sergio Aguero's injury... whatever caused it. The Argentine has been wonderful this season so losing him is a huge blow and one City may not recover from.

Don't get me wrong - City aren't out of the Premier League race yet but my gut feeling is that this is United's title. I think their fate might be determined this weekend.


City are so flat at the moment that it's hard to see them going to Arsenal and gaining the win they need.

It's odd to think that when the teams met earlier in the season in the Carling Cup, City could play a half-strength side and still win but now I'm not expecting them to collect all three points regardless of what side they play.

City were very fortunate against Sunderland and a tad lucky against Stoke; they weren't great against Chelsea and lost to Swansea before that. It's been a rotten March and I'm not sure that April is going to be that much better for them.

Meanwhile, United have got QPR this weekend and while the Londoners will give them a game there has to be a good chance that Sir Alex Ferguson's side will be eight points clear by the time City take to the field.


I know people will say that this is not the best United team we've seen - and it's not - but this is a team in transition.

Considering the number of players they've brought in and the number of youngsters they have blooded during the season - David De Gea, Jonny Evans, Phil Jones, Rafael, Javier Hernandez, Danny Welbeck, Antonio Valencia, Chris Smalling to name a handful - it's staggering to see them top of the pile.

Staying there with this squad would be one of Fergie's biggest achievements.

It may not be a great United side, but what about in two seasons' time? I think this current crop might well develop into an excellent outfit.

Then Mancini really will need to prove himself.

Join Jeff and the gang for Soccer Saturday, from 12pm on Sky Sports News HD.

Comments (3)

  • Page 1 of 1
  • 1

Reno Diamonte (Manchester United fan) says...

Jeff you mentioned...the bad luck that Mancini had with a couple of injuries...those of Kompany and Lescott. With the millions Mancini had at his disposal, surely he could've had that well covered. And while we're on the "injuries" subject, as we all know, that at one stage Man Utd had 8 to 9 top players injured. That is what I call, bad luck. As for Mancini's management, he should take a leaf out of Sir Alex's book. Had Balotelli was at United he would've lasted just one week and out the door. Mancini has one rule for his beloved Balotelli and another rule for the rest of the squad.And of course, the farcical saga of the Tevez affair. It has almost been over two and half years since Mancini took over at the City club...and as for the FA cup, there is nothing else to show. With the kind of money that he spent on top players Mancini should've produced better results. I remember when City went out of the Champions League, and Mancini was told, that his job was pretty safe only if he won the PL. Well, there is a very great doubt about that reslut happening. Finally, I have to agree with you and hope that City will keep Mancini for another year, because that will be another failure for city, the same conclusion for Liverpool, keeping Dalglish for another year. If I was a Liverpool fan, I would certainly be very worried.

Posted 20:31 5th April 2012

John Bostock (Chelsea fan) says...

Money - The Mad March Hare...! Owners of the Mad March Hare have let it loose against Chelsea in April. Perhaps the Fixture Fixers are also trying to fix Mancini.

Posted 19:49 5th April 2012

D Aziz (Manchester United fan) says...

Good article Jeff. I am a United fan and City has played very well this season but I don¿t agree with your sympathies for City. Missing Lescott and Company for two weeks is not exactly same as missing Vidic and Fletcher for the entire season. Given we have played Michael Carrick and Valencia in defence for nearly a month shows what United has been through this season. When we played Blackburn at OT we were missing 12 first team players but SAF never once complained and he kept on saying that he has faith in his squad even when us fans doubted it and now the squad is repaying that faith. Sooner or later City will have their time but this year belongs to United and long/forever it may continue.

Posted 17:11 5th April 2012

  • Page 1 of 1
  • 1

back to top

Other Football Experts:

Latest Posts in Football:

Martin Tyler

Tyler's Xmas stats

Martin Tyler brings you the most interesting Christmas Day and Boxing Day facts from over the years....

Latest News RSS feeds

Big Sam wins over Mourinho

Jose Mourinho has backtracked on his 19th century football jib against West Ham ahead of today's showdown with Chelsea.

Ten questions for Boxing Day

Where will Wayne Rooney play for Man Utd against Newcastle? We look at the talking points on the Premier League agenda.

Merson's predictions

Paul Merson expects Chelsea, Man City, Man Utd and Liverpool to seal Boxing Day victories.

Rio tips United for top three

Rio Ferdinand is convinced his old side Manchester United will finish the season in the Premier League’s top three.

Torres set for Atletico return

Chelsea striker Fernando Torres is understood to be set for a return to Atletico Madrid, according to Sky sources.


Happy Hammers: Five reasons for West Ham's good form

Happy Hammers: Five reasons for West Ham's good form

Adam Bate looks at five reasons for West Ham’s impressive upturn in form so far this season...

Festive tests

Festive tests

While titles can't be won or lost at Christmas, the festive schedule is a key spell in the Premier League calendar with plenty of points up for grabs.

Sky Sports Fantasy Football: Our scout looks at which players you should consider signing for Boxing Day

Sky Sports Fantasy Football: Our scout looks at which players you should consider signing for Boxing Day

The crucial festive period is upon us and, with games coming thick and fast, here are five in-form players to consider for your Sky Sports Fantasy Football team.