Skip to content

England's World Cup exit: Would Steffon Armitage have made a difference?

Chris Robshaw's England saw their World Cup hopes ended by defeat to Australia at Twickenham
Image: Chris Robshaw's England saw their World Cup hopes ended by defeat to Australia at Twickenham

England's balance in the back-row has long been a concern but nowhere has it been so cruelly exposed than in their 33-13 World Cup defeat to Australia at Twickenham.

Michael Hooper and David Pocock had a field day at the breakdown. Whether it was hunting as a duo or being split up, they helped Australia turn the ball over nine times - often when England were in the strike zone.

Concerns over how England attack the breakdown has been an issue for over three years now and Neil Back, who wore the No 7 shirt in England's 2003 World Cup triumph, says they have just not been good enough.

"England's back-row has not been consistently good - particularly at the breakdown and the key areas," said Back on England's World Cup Verdict show.

Michael Hooper (l) and David Pocock will pose a huge danger to England at the breakdown.
Image: Michael Hooper (l) and David Pocock were immense against England

"You only have to look back to the Lions section - two Welshmen were picked ahead of Chris Robshaw in the No 7 shirt and that was justified by their level of performance. 

Management to blame
Management to blame

Stuart Barnes has blamed England's coaches for their World Cup exit

"Michael Cheika came into the Australia job 12 months ago and said 'this is what I want in terms of players' and he made players that were unavailable (due to playing overseas) available so that he could get the best players.

"Steffon Armitage has to be a talking point - we were discussing him 12, 24 months ago when he was European Player of the Year and changes should have been made then to give him time to integrate into the team. We will never know [if Armitage would have made a difference] but we lost the battle convincingly against two opponents who were absolutely superb."

Also See:

The myth of Armitage?

Steffon Armitage of Toulon is pictured during the European Rugby Champions Cup Captain's Run at Twickenham
Image: Would Armitage have made a difference?

Dean Ryan questions whether Armitage was the right man for the job for England but says that England should have got him into the team to see if he was an option - and if not then looked elsewhere to find an alternative. 

"There is a danger that all this Steffon chat comes back - it has been around for three years and he has become the best international player by not playing," said the former England back-rower. 

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

The RFU should stick with Stuart Lancaster, says Will Greenwood

"England have been really stable in their selection but it is probably England's willingness to look at it that has caused the most criticism. Lancaster has not looked at an alternative like a Matt Kvesic. That is what has put him down a dead end without anywhere to go. Lancaster chose the back five's work rate over specialists.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Stuart Barnes felt England ran out of ideas and drowned under the weight of expectation

"I have mixed views on Steffon, I have seen him play Test rugby. He is outstanding for Toulon and the best place to be as a No 7 is with a pack on the front foot.

"England should have brought him in though, even just for the World Cup year so that you can judge him as an international player and not as a myth who sits across the channel and is growing in stature by not playing at all.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Stuart Lancaster says he takes full responsibility for England's World Cup exit

"The game is changing, it has changed in the last 12 months - the fact that Australia are picking both Pocock and Hooper together shows that the game is starting to break up a little bit and the only way to control it is by controlling that breakdown. England had no answer."

Around Sky