Skip to content

Makhaya Ntini says quota system devalues achievements of black South African cricketers

"That word 'quota' on its own is sensitive, it gives you a question mark on everything you are achieving. The quota name hit me hard"

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Makhaya Ntini shares his views on the South Africa quota system, as well as his trailblazing cricket career and meeting Nelson Mandela

Former South Africa seamer Makhaya Ntini believes the Proteas' quota system devalues the achievements of black cricketers.

Ntini, the first black African to play for South Africa, told Sky Sports he is not a fan of the target which stipulates the Proteas should select six players of colour in each squad, two of whom should be black African.

South Africa have had four non-white players in the first three Tests against England, with Rassie van der Dussen preferred to the fit-again Temba Bavuma in the batting line-up.

"That is the best way to go," said Ntini, when asked by Sky Sports Cricket's Nasser Hussain whether South Africa should be able to pick their team solely on talent.

Live Test Cricket

"Then you are not getting selected for the sake of a number, you are selected on merit, because you deserve it. That's number one.

"Then the word quota cannot be used. Then when you are selected you are given the same power.

"That word 'quota' on its own is sensitive, it gives you a question mark on everything you are achieving.

Also See:

"It's almost like you have done absolutely nothing. You can take a five-for but that is nothing. You haven't achieved anything yet. The quota name hit me hard."

Temba Bavuma
Image: Temba Bavuma has lost his spot in the South Africa side to Rassie van der Dussen

South Africa captain Faf du Plessis said how he "we don't see colour" when explaining Van der Dussen warranted his spot over Bavuma on current batting form, a viewpoint Ntini shares.

"[Du Plessis' answer] was perfect. If you don't see colour then every person that comes into the team you treat exactly the same. Then you are the best captain that the country needs.

"You are able to throw the ball to anybody, put the best man in any position. If South Africa wants to grow sport we should say that if he is good enough to be in that position, let him be in that position.

"Wipe the colour issue. If you look at that you are going backwards rather than forwards."

PORT ELIZABETH, SOUTH AFRICA - FEBRUARY 21: Faf du Plessis (capt) of South Africa during day 1 of the 2nd Castle Lager Test match between South Africa and Sri Lanka at St George's Park on February 21, 2019 in Port Elizabeth, South Africa. (Photo by Ashley Vlotman/Gallo Images)
Image: Faf du Plessis says South Africa 'do not see colour' when it comes to selection

Ntini, though, has lamented the lack of black players pushing to be part of South Africa's squads and feels the authorities have "done nothing" to help them grow as cricketers.

Kagiso Rabada is the only black African to have played for South Africa in the England series so far, with Bavuma injured for the first Test and then overlooked for the second and seamer Lungi Ngidi currently out of action with a hamstring problem.

"Almost every single black cricketer has come from my province in the Eastern Cape but nothing is happening in Border. Since the mixing of the provinces that has faded," Ntini said.

"The black cricketers have disappeared. There is no more rural coaching. Nothing has been done to bring black cricketers [into the game] and playing."

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Ntini talks about his journey to becoming South Africa's first black African cricketer and his concerns over the lack of black players in the current side

Reflecting on his own career, which included taking 390 wickets in 101 Tests and a further 266 in 173 one-day internationals, Ntini added: "There is always a massive pressure with us as black cricketers because it is the only sport where you are looked at all the time.

"It is not like football where everyone plays. Cricket is a harder sport for us to penetrate as we all know it is white-dominated. For us, being able to stay as long as we could was a lot of pressure.

"We wanted to break through the barrier and show that sport is sport. It doesn't matter what colour you are if you are good enough to represent the country."

Watch continued coverage of the third Test between South Africa and England, at St George's Park in Port Elizabeth, on Sky Sports Cricket.

Around Sky