The Ashes: Athers and Nas share their verdict on Carey's controversial Snicko decision

Wednesday 17 December 2025 13:15, UK

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Nasser Hussain and Michael Atherton reflect on the incident during the third Test of the Ashes, where Australia's Alex Carey survived a controversial decision of 'not out' after seemingly clipping England's Josh Tongue's delivery.

Watch Next

England bowler Josh Tongue (L) appeals for a decision again Australian batsman Alex Carey (R) on the first day of the third Ashes cricket Test match between Australia and England at the Adelaide Oval in Adelaide on December 17, 2025. (Photo by William WEST / AFP) / --IMAGE RESTRICTED TO EDITORIAL USE - STRICTLY NO COMMERCIAL USE--

'Snicko' operator admits mistake led to wrong Carey not out call

Alex Carey replied with a cheeky response if he's a 'walker' following the controversial not-out call during the third Ashes Test.

'Are you a walker? Clearly not!' | Carey's cheeky response to not-out controversy

Australia's Alex Carey plays a shot during play on day one of the third Ashes cricket test between England and Australia at the Adelaide Oval in Adelaide, Australia, Wednesday, Dec. 17, 2025. (AP Photo/James Elsby)

HAVE YOUR SAY: Should Snicko be scrapped for Ashes after Carey error?

Jofra Archer, England Test cricket, The Ashes (PA Images)

Analysis

'Excellent' Archer leads from front as Australia rue missed opportunity

England's Jofra Archer celebrates after dismissing Australia's Cameron Green on the first day of the third Ashes cricket Test match between Australia and England at the Adelaide Oval in Adelaide on December 17, 2025. (Photo by William WEST / AFP) / --IMAGE RESTRICTED TO EDITORIAL USE - STRICTLY NO COMMERCIAL USE--

England make inroads to keep Ashes hopes alive despite superb Carey ton

The Ashes Daily

Podcast

Ashes Daily: Snicko controversy on scorching day one in Adelaide

Joe Burns

Update

Why ex-Australia star won't be playing for Italy at 2026 T20 World Cup

Australia's Cameron Green, Test cricket (Associated Press)

Update

Green most expensive overseas player in IPL as Livingstone earns over £1m

Rajasthan Royals' Jofra Archer, IPL (Associated Press)

IPL squads for 2026 with 13 England players involved

Alex Carey, Australia Test cricket, The Ashes (PA Images)

Scorecard: Australia vs England, third Ashes Test, Adelaide

Steve Smith has been ruled out of the third Ashes Test after battling illness

Australia star Smith ruled out of third Ashes Test

A moment of silence is held ahead of the third Ashes Test to pay tribute to victims of the Bondi Beach attack

Tributes paid to Bondi shooting victims during third Ashes Test