Boxing Expert & Pundit
P4P Top 10: Matthew Macklin ranks Vasyl Lomachenko the world's best
Macklin puts Lomachenko a level above the rest but has 'Mikey' above American compatriot Crawford...
Last Updated: 22/08/18 12:34pm
The boxing 'season' is over so we have asked some of our Panel to pick their pound-for-pound list. There is no Floyd Mayweather and no Andre Ward anymore, so with an open field, see who Matthew Macklin has put top of the pile...
1 - Vasyl Lomachenko (11-1-KO9)
He could possibly be the most gifted boxer we've ever seen. Lomachenko is just sensational. He is just on a different level than the rest and although we are talking miniscule amounts, his skill, his class, everything about him stands out.
He could possibly be the most gifted boxer we've ever seen
Macklin on Lomachenko
2 - Mikey Garcia (39-0-KO30)
He is coming to his peak now. I think he is crying out for that signature fight, but it could well have to come against Lomachenko or Crawford. But until then, he has everything.
3 - Terence Crawford (33-0-KO24)
He's been a top fighter for a while but he is right on top of his game. They're just aren't any weaknesses to 'Bud'. He is clever, he hits hard, he's strong, wiry. He just has it all.
Froch's Top 10
'The Cobra' is the latest to call his P4P best, with some surprising names on the list...
4 - Gennady Golovkin (38-0-1-KO34)
I don't think he is the fighter he was, but of course 'GGG' is still top drawer. He has had a hectic schedule over the last five years - three or four fights a year - but is slipping back a bit.
5 - Saul Alvarez (49-1-2-KO34)
I was reluctant to put him in here but we are talking about talent and success. I do think he lost to Golovkin but the fact is, any highlight reel of that fight will be on him. He is still fresh and fast.
6 - Oleksandr Usyk (15-0-KO11)
One of the stand-out amateurs that has really stood up. Watching him make the World Boxing Super Series look relatively easy was unbelievable. He's only had 15 fights but already looks top drawer.
7 - Errol Spence Jr (24-0-KO21)
You could say he hasn't had to prove himself against the best yet, but in time he looks like he will do just that. Technically he is superb. Great jab, good body shots, good feet, distance and timing.
8 - Jermall Charlo (27-0-KO21)
The Charlo twins are both full of belief and have that nasty streak, but Jermall is the one I think will go on and establish himself as a big name in boxing. He could well take over the middleweight division.
9 - Naoya Inoue (16-0-KO14)
Jamie McDonnell might have been very tight at the weight, but 'The Monster' just blitzed him - and he's done that to plenty of people. Four weight divisions, three world titles, just something very special.
10 - Anthony Joshua (21-0-KO19)
We saw his heart when he got up off the canvas to beat Wladimir Klitschko but we have now seen his patience, sticking to a gameplan and controlling things behind that jab. He is still going to get better, so takes the final place from Keith Thurman, who hasn't boxed for 17 months.
Monday - Johnny Nelson's Top 10 is here!
Tuesday - Carl Froch's Top 10 is here!
Wednesday - Matthew Macklin's Top 10
Thursday - Tony Bellew's Top 10
Friday - Make your pick for the world's best pound-for-pound fighter
We will make sure you know where you can vote and debate the hot topic at the end of the week. Follow us @SkySportsBoxing, skysports.com/boxing or via the Sky Sports app.