The Sky Sports cricket team answered emails in the lunch break - and it was bad news for Paul Collingwood.
Hussain and Atherton expect Flintoff to return at five
Enter Andrew Flintoff, exit Paul Collingwood.
That was the reluctant verdict of former England captains Nasser Hussain and Michael Atherton as they answered veiwers e-mails at lunch on the last day at Lord's.
With England struggling to break South African resistance in the morning session, thoughts already began to turn towards Thursday's second Test at Headingley - and the probable return of Flintoff to the England fold.
The all-rounder's recall raised two major issues, with Hussain and Atherton both agreeing that if he does come back, it will have to be as one of FIVE bowlers and at the expense of Collingwood.
"It's never a given, any player has to earn the right to come back into the side, but I think think Flintoff has done that with his bowling - not his batting," said Hussain
"Reports from county cricket is that either side of his injury he was bowling fast and accurate with reverse swing, which is what England need, so both Flintoff and Simon Jones are both candidates, Flintoff being the obvious one.
"If he does come back, for me it will have to be as one of five bowlers. I wouldn't want Flintoff as one of four; the template for beating Australia in 2005 was five batsmen, Flintoff at six and the wicket-keeper at seven getting runs.
Unfortunate
"So that means Flintoff comes in for Collingwood. He's been very unfortunate in this Test match and hasn't done anything wrong, but he hasn't got any runs for a while and it would have to be at the expense of Collingwood."
The duo were not done there though.
They went on to answer several more questions about Test cricket, coming to the conclusion that Steve Harmison's refusal to play one-day cricket has probably called time on his Test career.
Atherton was also left disappointed by England announcing just two Test dates on their winter tour of India, while Hussain admitted that he was right behind Michael Holding, who quit the ICC over their decision to change the result of the controversial England-Pakistan Test to a draw.
