Skip to content

NFL Pick Six: Mitch Trubisky's career day, heartbreak for the Browns and frustration for Earl Thomas

at Oakland-Alameda County Coliseum on September 30, 2018 in Oakland, California.
Image: The Cleveland Browns could feasibly be unbeaten had things gone their way this season

Neil Reynolds picks six storylines from Week Four, including Mitch Trubisky's career day, more heartbreak for the Cleveland Browns and Earl Thomas' devastating injury...

I'm beginning to feel like a broken record, but it is genuinely the case that each weekend in the NFL is turning into a white-knuckle roller coaster ride that is fascinating yet impossible to call.

You never know what is going to transpire, and Sunday night was no different as we saw three games decided in overtime, a last-second touchdown-pass winner in Atlanta and controversy during Seattle's win over Arizona.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Watch this brilliant touchdown which saw Cincinnati beat Atlanta in the final seconds of their game

Let's dig into Week Four in the NFL with my six leading storylines...

Order restored in AFC East

I felt like I spent much of last week and a good portion of Sunday's pre-game painting the picture of a New England Patriots team on the ropes and in desperate need of a good performance against the 3-0 Miami Dolphins.

All along, in the back of my mind, I felt a Patriots backlash game was just around the corner. And that proved to be the case as they hammered the Dolphins 38-7. Miami's seven points only came because New England eased off at the end.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Highlights of the Dolphins' clash with the Patriots in Week Four of the NFL

Bill Belichick out-coached Adam Gase. The Patriots came into Week Four with concerns over their offense and found a timely running game through Sony Michel and James White. Dolphins quarterback Ryan Tannehill, meanwhile, came in red hot but left with his tail between his legs after throwing for just 100 yards and an interception.

Also See:

Coach rolls the dice - the good

Blaine Gabbert #7 of the Tennessee Titans looks to pass the football during their game against the Jacksonville Jaguars at TIAA Bank Field on September 23, 2018 in Jacksonville, Florida.
Image: Mike Vrabel has got off to a great start in his first year as an NFL head coach in Tennessee

Mike Vrabel is doing an excellent job in his first year as an NFL head coach, leading his Tennessee Titans to three straight wins and a 3-1 record on the season. Vrabel has been digging deep each week to overcome key injuries and had to go to his bag of tricks again on Sunday.

His Titans trailed the reigning Super Bowl champion Philadelphia Eagles 17-3 but clawed back to 20-20 at the end of regulation. Into overtime and the Eagles took a 23-20 lead via a field goal. But the Titans, led by heroic quarterback Marcus Mariota, got in range for a 50-yard kick of their own - but that would only have allowed them to record a tie, given the limited time left on the clock.

WATCH: NFL plays of the week
WATCH: NFL plays of the week

It was another wild and wacky week in the NFL and we have picked out the best plays from Week Four...

So Vrabel rolled the dice, but in a very clever way. He sent his field goal team onto the field, knowing all along his offense was coming back on to run a play. The coach wanted time to plan but didn't want to tip his hand to the Eagles. After calling a timeout, Mariota completed the fourth-down pass to Dion Lewis and the game-winning touchdown to Corey Davis, keeping the Titans on course for the playoffs. Clever stuff from Vrabel.

Coach rolls the dice - the not so good

INDIANAPOLIS, IN - SEPTEMBER 09: Head Coach Frank Reich of the Indianapolis Colts at Lucas Oil Stadium on September 9, 2018 in Indianapolis, Indiana. (Photo by Andy Lyons/Getty Images)
Image: Colts head coach Frank Reich fell foul of his gutsy call in overtime against the Texans

Indianapolis Colts head coach Frank Reich also tried to go for it on fourth down in order to avoid a tie in his team's encounter with the Houston Texans. What is it with American sports that they cannot recognise the benefits of a well-earned draw?

The big difference in the two calls was field position. Vrabel took a gamble from the Philadelphia 32-yard line and they still would have had to make a long field goal to level things up. As for Reich's Colts, they were tied 34-34 with the Texans and were camped at their own 43-yard line with 27 seconds left.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

ProFootballTalk journalist Peter King reflects on the main talking points from Week Four in the NFL

If the Colts punt the ball away, they cannot win but they are pretty much set for a tie. If they had gone for it - which they did - there were no guarantees of a win but they could certainly lose. Andrew Luck's fourth-and-four pass to Chester Rogers fell incomplete, the Texans took full advantage of the excellent field position and won with a field goal.

Reich was bullish after the game, suggesting he would do the same thing again "10 times out of 10" and that tells me he knows the Colts are not contenders this season. This was simply a move to a) try to win the game and b) win over his locker room by showing he had faith in his players. On reflection, that is hard to criticise.

Play the NFL Challenge
Play the NFL Challenge

Follow all the excitement of the 2018 season by playing the NFL Challenge, with weekly prizes and the chance to win a pair of season tickets to the 2019 games in London.

Trubisky enjoys career day

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Watch each of Mitch Trubisky's six touchdown passes for the Bears in the thrashing of the Buccaneers

What an afternoon second-year quarterback Mitchell Trubisky enjoyed during his Chicago Bears' 48-10 hammering of the Tampa Bay Buccaneers. Trubisky was on fire from the very start and threw six touchdown passes - one short of the NFL record.

Importantly for the Bears, Trubisky threw scoring strikes to tight end Trey Burton, and wide receivers Allen Robinson and Taylor Gabriel. All were free agent signings during this past offseason.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

We hear from the Around the NFL podcast team and get their take on Week Four in the NFL

The Bears are now 3-1 on the season, top of the NFC North and roaring on defense with another new arrival - pass-rushing demon Khalil Mack - having a monster year. At this stage of the season, general manager Ryan Pace must be feeling pretty good about the roster-building work he oversaw in the spring and summer.

Browns lose a heartbreaker

 at Oakland-Alameda County Coliseum on September 30, 2018 in Oakland, California.
Image: The Browns lost a heartbreaker to the Raiders in overtime on Sunday

The Cleveland Browns are 1-2-1 after the season's first month, yet it is not ridiculous to suggest that the team who couldn't win a single game in 2017 should be 4-0 on the year. They definitely should be on two wins by now because they got robbed in Sunday's 45-42 overtime loss to the Oakland Raiders.

First, they had a defensive touchdown taken off the board after a strange ruling that suggested Oakland quarterback Derek Carr was stopped and down when he clearly wasn't. But more damaging was a late call overturned by the instant replay officiating department in New York.

NFL Team of the Week
NFL Team of the Week

Who were the top performers from Week Four in the NFL? We have picked out our team of the week...

With one minute and 41 seconds left in the game, Cleveland faced a vital third-and-two play at their own 17-yard line. Carlos Hyde appeared to dive forward for just about the required yardage and the referee on the field signaled a first down. But the call got overturned, the Raiders tied the game late and then won it in overtime.

It was another heartbreaker for the Browns, who have the talent on board but now must learn the art of winning games. I still believe it will take a new head coach to get this club over the hump and that Hue Jackson is not the man to take this team to greater heights.

Frustration for Earl Thomas

GLENDALE, AZ - SEPTEMBER 30: XXX during the XX quarter at State Farm Stadium on September 30, 2018 in Glendale, Arizona. (Photo by Norm Hall/Getty Images)
Image: Earl Thomas is carted off the field on Sunday

I went on an NFL UK Live stage show tour of Ireland and Northern Ireland with Seattle Seahawks safety Earl Thomas in the spring and I can tell you that while he appears intense and serious, he is a great guy and a true family man with a big heart.

I felt awful on Sunday night watching Earl being carted off the field during Seattle's win over the Arizona Cardinals with a broken leg. The injury alone is upsetting enough, but what is more disconcerting is the precarious state of Thomas' career and his relationship with a Seahawks team that has been unwilling to give him a new long-term contract.

Seattle safety Thomas breaks leg
Seattle safety Thomas breaks leg

Seattle Seahawks safety Earl Thomas suffered a lower leg fracture on Sunday and appeared to make an obscene gesture towards his team's sideline.

Earl was adamant he wanted out if they didn't want him and demanded to be signed to a new deal or traded. The Seahawks have been holding firm and using Thomas - as is their right - for the full length of his current deal. There is genuine bad blood between the two sides and that is why we witnessed the terrible sight of Earl giving his own sideline the middle finger as he was carted off.

He is clearly done in Seattle now. And this injury is exactly the reason he skipped practice last week. In hindsight, if he really wanted a new deal, Earl should also have skipped the games because that's where the serious injuries occur. Now he will be 30 and coming off back-to-back broken legs (on the same leg) as he enters free agency in March. No wonder he was fuming as he left the field.

Bell offers support to injured Thomas
Bell offers support to injured Thomas

Pittsburgh Steelers running back Le'Veon Bell sends support to injured Earl Thomas and vows to continue holdout.

Every Sunday Sky Sports is your home of the NFL in the UK with three live games and Redzone and you can join in the conversation by making sure you follow us @SkySportsNFL for behind the scenes coverage, live fixture announcements and much more

Around Sky