Skip to content
Analysis

England player ratings for third Test at Edgbaston: Dan Lawrence, Jordan Cox and Emilio Gay add to selection headache

Dan Lawrence earns Player of the Match honours at Edgbaston after hitting fifty, taking two wickets and claiming a stunning slip catch; Emilio Gay and Jordan Cox also hit half-centuries, with the trio tussling for a permanent place in the Test team as England sweep series against Pakistan

Dan Lawrence celebrates his stunning slip catch with team-mates during the third Test at Edgbaston
Image: Dan Lawrence celebrates his stunning slip catch with team-mates during the third Test at Edgbaston

England clinched a first home series whitewash of Pakistan with an eight-wicket win in the third Test at Edgbaston, but who stood out from Joe Root's side - and who didn't?

Ben Duckett - 3

Batting: 11 and 0

England opener Ben Duckett struggled during the series, scoring a combined 44 runs over his five innings
Image: England opener Ben Duckett struggled during the series, scoring a combined 44 runs over his five innings

A Test match to forget for Duckett. In fact, it has been a pretty miserable series as a whole, with his first-innings 17 at Lord's serving as his highest score.

He did, however, notch England's only Test ton of the summer against New Zealand at Trent Bridge, so his place at the top of the order isn't under threat - at least for now...

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Ben Duckett hit the only England Test century this summer against New Zealand at Trent Bridge in June

He was also a bit butter-fingered in the slips this week, dropping three chances, albeit his two put down in the first innings didn't prove too costly as Pakistan were still bundled out for 133 in only 33.5 overs.

Emilio Gay - 6

Batting: 60 and 0

It has been a bit of a back-and-forth affair with regards to Gay's place in the starting Test side going forward, with the Durham left-hander seemingly locking up his spot with another battling half-century in the first innings - his third such score this summer.

But then his second-innings duck has somewhat opened up the debate again, especially given the performance of others who could end up elbowing him out of the way when the currently injured Jacob Bethell likely returns to the team.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

England's start to day four could not have gone worse after Mohammad Abbas removed Ben Duckett and Emilio Gay in the first over

It was, admittedly, a terrific delivery from Mohammad Abbas that ensured he wouldn't trouble the scorers in the second innings, but it's precisely why he'll be kicking himself with how he got out first time round - dragging a wide one from Razaullah back onto his stumps - when a first Test hundred was there for the taking.

Jordan Cox - 7

Batting: 4 and 59no

Much like Gay, Cox's fortunes and future prospects see-sawed a touch over the course of this Test, as he copped a low one in the first innings - also falling foul of Abbas, lbw - but his calm, unbeaten half-century alongside the skipper on the fourth morning saw England to victory from a positon of peril at 2-2.

Jordan Cox scored 59 hugely valuable runs as part of an unbroken 128-run partnership with Joe Root that took England to victory at Edgbaston
Image: Jordan Cox scored 59 hugely valuable runs as part of an unbroken 128-run partnership with Joe Root that took England to victory at Edgbaston

It will have been hard for Joe Root not to have taken note of that, as he looks for the right sort of characters to take this side forward. And Cox seems to have character in spades.

That was also evident with his keeping, when deputising impressively for Jamie Smith, who sat out the second innings with an injured thumb. He claimed four terrific catches and a stumping to finally end Razaullah's extraordinary knock.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Jordan Cox took a superb catch to dismiss Babar Azam in the second innings at Edgbaston

Joe Root - 7

Batting: 8 and 62no

Just when England needed a captain's innings, Root duly obliged, his unbeaten half-century on the fourth morning - just his third of a barren summer by his standards - allaying any fears of a catastrophic late collapse to defeat.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Highlights from day four of the third Test between England and Pakistan at Edgbaston as Joe Root steered his side to victory

Instead, he celebrates a series sweep - England's first at home over Pakistan - on his return as permanent Test captain, though his lbw issues persist after Razaullah was the one to pin him in the first innings, in spectacular fashion with only his fourth ball in Test cricket. It takes Root's tally to eight such dismissals from his 10 Test innings' this summer.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

21-year-old debutant Razaullah took the wicket of England's all-time leading Test run-scorer Joe Root with only his fourth ball

Also, he moved one clear of Australia's Steve Smith and onto 220 in their personal battle to claim the record number of catches by an outfielder in Test cricket.

Harry Brook - 7

Batting: 75

Brook will be another kicking himself for missing out on a hundred in the first innings, with one seemingly at his mercy before he needlessly ran himself out on the second morning.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Harry Brook spurned his chance of making a century in the first innings as he ran himself out on 75

He's been England's most consistent batter in the testing conditions served up this summer, with this his fifth half-century, while he has had starts of at least 20 in all but two of his innings.

It will make him all the more frustrated at the fact that a century has eluded him, but he has shown greater responsibility with the bat - certainly against Pakistan - which is encouraging after fans began growing tired of his, at times, reckless approach in the Bazball era.

Dan Lawrence - 8

Batting: 65
Bowling: 2-17

Player of the match. With Ollie Robinson denied for the first time in a Test he's played this summer.

Lawrence is another vying for a regular place in this side and he's certainly done his chances no harm, with bat, ball and in the field.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Dan Lawrence produced a stunning catch at slip off Gus Atkinson to dismiss Shan Masood for 95, denying the Pakistan batter a century at Edgbaston

His standout contribution was a spectacular catch in the slips - one-handed, diving low to his right - to see off Shan Masood five shy of a century. But he also grabbed two wickets in his 4.4 second-innings overs, including Azan Awais (59) to end his 125-run third-wicket stand with Masood and finally the wicket of Razaullah to end day three.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Dan Lawrence claimed England’s first wicket of day three as Azan Awais fell for 59 following a successful Joe Root review and sharp catch from Jordan Cox

If anything his off-spin was under-used, with that being a key string to his bow to support England's preference for a four-pronged pace attack looking ahead to the winter tour of South Africa and next summer's Ashes.

With the bat, like Gay and Brook before him, he'll rue missing out on a first-innings ton when dragging a rather innocuous delivery from Mohammad Imran back onto his stumps.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Dan Lawrence couldn't hide his fury after chopping one back onto his stumps when eyeing up a maiden Test century

Jamie Smith - 7

Batting: 69

The forgotten man in this Test, with his involvement ended two days in, as a blow to the finger when stood up to the stumps on day one prevented him from donning the gloves in the second innings.

It looks a precautionary measure more than anything, with it not keeping him from batting on day two as he again impressed with a typically brisk 69 before chipping one back to Razaullah off his own bowling.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

A fired-up Razaullah celebrated wildly as caught and bowled Jamie Smith

While Cox impressed in his absence, Smith has also barely put a foot wrong behind the stumps all summer, so he'll likely still start if fit for South Africa.

Gus Atkinson - 6

Bowling: 0-31 and 3-109
Batting: 19

It's been tough sledding for Atkinson this series, with only one wicket to show for his efforts prior to the second innings - as the rest of the pace quartet profited.

He has bowled better than his numbers would suggest, often coming on as second change, sidelined as others wreaked havoc with the new ball and when bowling to the tail.

Gus Atkinson claimed three second-innings wickets after having only taken one through the first two and a half Tests
Image: Gus Atkinson claimed three second-innings wickets after having only taken one through the first two and a half Tests

But Root showed faith in his fast bowler after lunch on day three, with Pakistan 184-3 in their second innings, letting him loose for an eight-over spell that was his best yet and brought with it the wicket of Masood - as much as he owed a debt of gratitude to Lawrence too.

He'd later add Ghazi Ghori and Imran before he too couldn't escape punishment from the blade of Razaullah.

Ollie Robinson - 8

Bowling: 3-15 and 2-54
Batting: 50

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Ollie Robinson took two wickets for no runs in the opening over of Pakistan’s second innings in the third Test against England

Robinson was at it yet again with the new ball, dismissing Saim Ayub and Abdullah Shafique in his opening spell in both innings, needing only four deliveries to see the back of them second time round - the former out for a pair upon his sudden, surprise call up to the touring side in between Tests that did him no favours.

Robinson's wicket of Saim in the first innings was his 100th in Test cricket, while his double strike in the first over of the second took his tally for the series to 21 at an average of 6.66 a pop, which grew to just the 8.76 apiece upon Pakistan's battling display on day three.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Ollie Robinson claimed his 100th Test wicket with his first-innings dismissal of Saim Ayub

In all seriousness, his effectiveness does diminish when taken deep into later spells, which could be a concern on flatter decks if that's what awaits in South Africa or next year's Ashes, but it's extremely hard to pick fault given just how impressive his reintroduction to the side has been this summer.

Also pitched in with the bat, scoring his second Test fifty.

Jofra Archer - 6

Bowling: 3-25 and 1-120
Batting: 32no

Jofra Archer has taken 23 wickets at an average of 24.82 apiece over the five Tests he's played this summer
Image: Jofra Archer has taken 23 wickets at an average of 24.82 apiece over the five Tests he's played this summer

Not his best showing, with at least one of his three first-innings wickets a real gift from Masood, spooned straight to midwicket.

His dismissal of Saud Shakeel to a brute of a short ball in the second gave nod to him at his best, but he was one of several England bowlers to lose the plot late on the third evening as Razaullah smacked them to all parts.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Razaullah smashed NINE sixes to equal Tim Southee’s record for the most by a player on Test debut during a remarkable innings against England at Edgbaston

Still, an encouraging summer on the whole, with five consecutive Tests for the previously injury-plagued pacer a real tick for England.

Josh Tongue - 7

Bowling: 4-42 and 2-106
Batting: 15

Trademark Tongue in the first innings, with three of his four wickets scattering the stumps - the top of Babar's off peg knocked back with the fast bowler's dream delivery, Imran undone by a toe-crushing yorker and Shakeel seen off by a devastating nip-backer.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Josh Tongue led the way with the ball for England in the first innings, with three of his four dismissals clean-bowled!

He was expensive in the second innings, going at more than six an over, until his and Archer's bouncer theory proved incisive - until Razaullah arrived at the middle, that is - as Tongue got Babar to glove one behind.

England vs Pakistan - Test series results

Watch every England match during the international summer live on Sky Sports, including the white-ball series' against Sri Lanka, staring with the first T20I on Tuesday. Not got Sky? Latest Sky Sports deals or stream with no contract on NOW

Sky Data Layer Viewer