Skip to content
Analysis

WWE draft 2019: Who were the winners and losers on the annual roster reshuffle?

Jefferson Lake

WWE Editor @jeffersonlake

Wednesday 16 October 2019 10:03, UK

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Brock Lesnar was selected as the second pick in the draft, but was SmackDown's acquisition of the WWE champion actually the best move of the entire process?

Raw and SmackDown made their selections of 61 WWE superstars as the company's annual brand was completed.

The draft was staged in a new presentation style which featured Stephanie McMahon announcing the picks five at a time and with 'war rooms' representing the respective United States broadcast partners reacting as the selection process unfolded.

The red brand went first on both Friday and Monday night and also gained three names for every two for SmackDown by virtue of their longer show duration.

But did those advantages mean Raw came out on top of the annual roster refresh? We take a look…

Could Randy Orton be about to embark on one last glorious run as a WWE world champion?
Image: Randy Orton is back on Raw, and could find himself in line for one or two final runs in the main event

Men's division:

Raw: Drew McIntyre, Randy Orton, Ricochet, Bobby Lashley, Kevin Owens, Seth Rollins, Andrade, Rusev, Aleister Black, Cedric Alexander, Humberto Carillo, Erick Rowan, Buddy Murphy, Jinder Mahal, R-Truth, Samoa Joe, Akira Tozawa, Shelton Benjamin, Rey Mysterio, Titus O'Neil, EC3, Eric Young, Sin Cara

SmackDown: Roman Reigns, Bray Wyatt, Braun Strowman, Brock Lesnar, Daniel Bryan, Shinsuke Nakamura, Ali, Dolph Ziggler & Robert Roode, The Miz, Baron Corbin, Chad Gable, Elias, Apollo Crews, Drew Gulak, Heath Slater

SmackDown picked up arguably the biggest name in WWE today by bagging Brock Lesnar and they also took the hottest 'sports entertainment' commodity by landing Bray Wyatt.

Also See:

There was a controversial finish to the Seth Rollins-Fiend match at Hell In A Cell
Image: The Fiend, the hottest property in WWE today, will be on SmackDown from now on

That deal will presumably include his fabled Fiend, and their acquisition of Roman Reigns gives SmackDown a ready-packaged program should they need one for Wyatt's macabre creation.

Daniel Bryan and Braun Strowman are main-event level players, with Baron Corbin also in that mix now, and they can also call upon high-quality in-ring performers such as Ali and Chad Gable to fill out their cards.

Raw has a definite edge in terms of numbers and will therefore be able to absorb any injuries better than SmackDown and they also have some big guns, including Universal champion Seth Rollins, Kevin Owens, Samoa Joe and Randy Orton, who almost certainly has a run or two left in him in the main event.

They also have plenty of WWE's up-and-coming talent on board, notably Andrade, Aleister Black and a man the company is said to be very high on: Humberto Carillo.

But the win probably has to go to SmackDown by a very narrow, but Brock-shaped, margin.

Winners: SmackDown

Bayley displayed a new vicious edge prior to her SmackDown main-event match against Charlotte Flair
Image: SmackDown picked up one of the most talked-about people in wrestling in Bayley but their overall women's roster looks quite thin

Women's division

Raw: Becky Lynch, Natalya, Charlotte Flair, Kabuki Warriors, Liv Morgan

SmackDown: Sasha Banks, Bayley, Alexa Bliss, Nikki Cross, Lacey Evans, Carmella, Tamina

One of the most meme-friendly moments of the draft was the shot WWE aired of the Raw 'war room' reacting excitedly to the acquisition of Natalya but while those high-fives were met with some mirth by fans, it is hard to argue against anything other than a big draft win for the red team.

Becky Lynch's exceptional 2019 to date includes a WrestleMania main event, in which she become the only person to beat Ronda Rousey in WWE
Image: Raw women's champion Becky Lynch was the #1 pick overall in this year's draft

SmackDown have a retooled Bayley - who was the talk of the fan community all weekend after fully cementing her heel turn with a ruthless slashing of the 'Bayley buddies' - and Sasha Banks, who has reminded everyone of her quality since returning but is now out with an injury.

Raw have the number one woman in the business (and the #1 pick in this draft) in Becky Lynch, plus a ready-made opponent for her in Charlotte Flair and the superb Kabuki Warriors in what looked initially like a clear win for the red team.

But an overnight trade on Wednesday saw Alexa Bliss and Nikki Cross move to SmackDown, immediately deepening their roster and taking a former top-tier champion from the Monday crew.

Both brands could now plunder the free agency pool - which includes competitors such as Mandy Rose and Naomi - and there could also be some NXT call-ups to add some new blood to both divisions.

Winners: Raw at first, but now SmackDown

The New Day are today beginning their sixth reign as WWE tag-team champions
Image: Alongside The Usos, the New Day remain in the free agency pool, making the tag-team side of the draft difficult to assess

Tag-team division

Raw: The OC (AJ Styles, Karl Anderson, Luke Gallows), The Viking Raiders, Street Profits, The New Day

SmackDown: The Revival, Lucha House Party, Heavy Machinery, Dolph Ziggler & Robert Roode, The B Team

The duos division is an interesting area for analysis, with SmackDown again probably getting the better of the picks.

Several teams remain in the free agent pool: AOP, Curt Hawkins & Zack Ryder, the long-lost pairings of The Ascension and The Colons, plus the probably now inactive Hardys are all without a home.

Heavy Machinery lost their SmackDown tag title match to Daniel Bryan & Rowan but their reputation was enhanced
Image: Heavy Machinery are widely regarded as one of the next big things in WWE

But the big names in there are The Usos, and their 'unassigned' status could see them float between both brands.

In terms of the actual known picks, it's much of a muchness. The Revival are a strong team but balanced out by the Viking Raiders, for example, and both brands have an up-and-coming team in Heavy Machinery and Street Profits.

Winners: Draw

Around Sky

Upgrade to Sky Sports to watch more games than ever before

Not got Sky? Get instant access to Sky Sports with no contract