Skip to content

Clash of the Codes: A rugby league XV to play union

Watch the 'Clash of the Codes' matches between Wigan and Bath from 1996 at 7pm and 9pm on Sky Sports Arena on Friday.

Picture by Chris Mangnall/SWpix.com - 30/01/2020 - Rugby League - Betfred Super League - Wigan Warriors v Warrington Wolves - DW Stadium, Wigan, England -
Wigans Sean O'Loughlin

With Sky Sports re-running the 'Clash of the Codes' matches between Wigan and Bath on Friday, we try to imagine what the teams would look like if a similar match were to take place today.

Yesterday we put together a rugby union XIII to play in a league match and now we are imagining what a rugby league XV to play union might look like.

We have trawled Super League and the NRL to bring together this all-star team, and you can see who made it into our side below…

Full-back and wingers

Jonny Lomax of St Helens
Image: Jonny Lomax gets the full-back shirt in our team

The full-back role does not differ too much between the codes, although having one who can kick in union makes them a useful asset. That is why we have gone with Jonny Lomax in this position, who has experience of playing there for St Helens as well.

With his reputation as the fastest man in rugby league, New South Wales and Australia flyer Josh Addo-Carr get one of the spots on the wing and would be able to utilise that pace to exploit gaps in the defensive line.

Josh Addo-Carr
Image: Josh Addo-Carr's speed would be useful on the wing
SYDNEY, AUSTRALIA - SEPTEMBER 08: Kalyn Ponga of the Knights runs the ball during the round 25 NRL match between the Penrith Panthers and the Newcastle Knights at Panthers Stadium on September 08, 2019 in Sydney, Australia. (Photo by Jason McCawley/Getty Images)
Image: Kalyn Ponga can step opponents and open defences

His compatriot Kalyn Ponga, who has the mesmerising ability to step defenders at close quarters and darts through holes he creates, would be perfect out wide as well.

Centres

With a strong all-round game and the ability to make the most of having room to run into, Jake Connor seems like an ideal fit for the outside centre berth in this team - even if he would prefer to play in the halves at league.

Also See:

Jake Connor crosses for a try against Hull KR
Image: Jake Connor's attributes lend him well to playing a role in the centres
Picture by Chris Mangnall/SWpix.com - 08/02/2020 - Rugby League - Betfred Super League - Salford Red Devils v Toronto Wolfpack - AJ Bell Stadium, Salford, England -
Toronto's Sonny Bill Williams
Image: Sonny Bill Williams' rugby union experience would be a big asset

There is one man who stands out as a candidate for the inside centre shirt and that is none other than cross-code star Sonny Bill Williams, who performed the role with distinction for the All Blacks during his nine years in the 15-man code.

Halves

The fly-half is arguably the heartbeat of any team in rugby union, pulling the strings and organising the side, along with needing to have a strong kicking game. That is why we think Catalans Dragons half James Maloney would slot in well here.

Picture by Laurent Selles/Catalan Dragons/via SWpix.com - 15/02/2020 - Rugby League - Super League - Catalans Dragons v Castleford Tigers - Stade Gilbert Brutus, Perpignan - France - Catalans' James Maloney.
Image: James Maloney gets the all-important fly-half role
Picture by Allan McKenzie/SWpix.com - 02/02/2020 - Rugby League - Betfred Super League - Toronto Wolfpack v Castleford Tigers - Emerald Headingley Stadium, Leeds, England - Castleford's Paul McShane thanks the fans after his side's victory over Toronto.
Image: Hooker Paul McShane has the attributes to be a success at scrum-half

Along with similar attributes, the role of the scrum-half shares similarities with the hooker in rugby league in terms of being first to the ball. We could see Castleford Tigers hooker Paul McShane excelling there, particularly if he can get quick ball at a ruck and dart at the defence.

Front row

The rugby league players would have a disadvantage at the scrum due to it being merely a way of quickly restarting the game in the 13-man code rather than the contest it is in union, but there are still plenty of props with the physical attributes required.

thompson
Image: Luke Thompson gets one of the prop positions
Alex Walmsley  carries hard for Saints
Image: Alex Walmsley's physical presence would be welcome in the front row

Luke Thompson - rated by many as the best prop in league at present - and St Helens team-mate Alex Walmsley would put up some stiff resistance, as well as having the ball-carrying ability to get over the gain-line and make valuable metres.

Hull FC hooker Danny Houghton
Image: Danny Houghton's tackling would prove vital for the team

It is a similar dilemma when it comes to finding a hooker, who would be responsible for the line-out throws too, but Hull FC's Danny Houghton certainly has the defensive attributes required as he is regularly the leading tackler in Super League and is a threat with the ball in hand.

Second row

Again, we have gone for physical presence in the two lock positions, as well as a bit of height to help out when it comes to the line-out.

Tonga forward Jason Taumalolo , during the rugby league match between the Australian Kangaroos and Tonga Invitational XIII, during the Triple Header matches for the Great Britain Lions rugby league Tour & the Oceania Cup, held at Eden Park, Auckland. 02 November 2019 Photo: Brett Phibbs / www.photosport.nz /SWpix.com
Image: Jason Taumalolo lines up as one of the locks in our team
SYDNEY, AUSTRALIA - SEPTEMBER 28: during the NRL Preliminary Final match between the Sydney Roosters and the Melbourne Storm at the Sydney Cricket Ground on September 28, 2019 in Sydney, Australia. (Photo by Jason McCawley/Getty Images)
Image: Boyd Cordner brings size and strength to the second row

It is two internationals who get these roles, with Tongan star Jason Taumalolo and Australia captain Boyd Cordner bringing their size and strength to the team.

Back row

The position of flanker was eliminated in rugby league in 1906 when teams were reduced from 15-a-side to 13-a-side, but there are still candidates to fill these two places.

Picture by Allan McKenzie/SWpix.com - 01/03/2020 - Rugby League - Betfred Super League - Hull FC v Catalans Dragons - KC Stadium, Kingston upon Hull, England - Hull FC's Manu Ma'u celebrates his try against the Catalan Dragons.
Image: Manu Ma'u could be dangerous as a flanker in this team
Picture by Paul Currie/SWpix.com - 15/03/2019 - Rugby League - Betfred Super League - Warrington Wolves v Wigan Warriors - Halliwell Jones Stadium, Warrington, England - Sean O'Loughlin of Wigan Warriors tackles Daryl Clark of Warrington Wolves
Image: Sean O'Loughlin gets one of the flanker roles

It is easy to imagine the 'Togan Terminator' Manu Ma'u would be a menace the breakdown and hunting opponents to shut down attacks, as would Wigan Warriors and England captain Sean O'Loughlin.

Leeds's Konrad Hurrell.
Image: Konrad Hurrell's running ability sees him get the No. 8 shirt

Finally, the No. 8 role goes to someone who plays as a back in rugby league but has that hard-charging, line-busting running which would make him a big threat there. Step forward, Konrad Hurrell.

Around Sky