The Ashes: Athers and Nas share their verdict on Carey's controversial Snicko decision

Wednesday 17 December 2025 12:05, UK

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Nasser Hussain and Michael Atherton reflect on the incident during the third Test of the Ashes, where Australia's Alex Carey survived a controversial decision of 'not out' after seemingly clipping England's Josh Tongue's delivery.

Watch Next

England bowler Josh Tongue (L) appeals for a decision again Australian batsman Alex Carey (R) on the first day of the third Ashes cricket Test match between Australia and England at the Adelaide Oval in Adelaide on December 17, 2025. (Photo by William WEST / AFP) / --IMAGE RESTRICTED TO EDITORIAL USE - STRICTLY NO COMMERCIAL USE--

'Snicko' operator admits mistake led to wrong Carey not out call

Australia's Alex Carey plays a shot during play on day one of the third Ashes cricket test between England and Australia at the Adelaide Oval in Adelaide, Australia, Wednesday, Dec. 17, 2025. (AP Photo/James Elsby)

Live

HAVE YOUR SAY: Should Snicko be scrapped for Ashes after Carey error?

The Ashes Daily

Podcast

Ashes Daily: Snicko controversy on scorching day one in Adelaide

England's Jofra Archer celebrates after dismissing Australia's Cameron Green on the first day of the third Ashes cricket Test match between Australia and England at the Adelaide Oval in Adelaide on December 17, 2025. (Photo by William WEST / AFP) / --IMAGE RESTRICTED TO EDITORIAL USE - STRICTLY NO COMMERCIAL USE--

England make inroads to keep Ashes hopes alive despite superb Carey ton

Jofra Archer, England Test cricket, The Ashes (PA Images)

Scorecard: Australia vs England, third Ashes Test, Adelaide

A moment of silence is held ahead of the third Ashes Test to pay tribute to victims of the Bondi Beach attack

Tributes paid to Bondi shooting victims during third Ashes Test

England's Josh Tongue

Tongue in but no Bashir as England make one change for third Ashes Test

England's Harry Brook reacts as he leaves the field after losing his wicket on day two of the first Ashes cricket Test

'I've got to rein it in' - Brook ready to change tactics in third Ashes Test

Joe Root, Ben Stokes, England cricket (Getty Images)

Exclusive

Root says England inspired by 2023 Ashes comeback as he explains Noosa trip

Credit - PA/AP Photo

Opinion

Stokes' rebuke of England players reminds Nasser of Klopp methods

Brendon McCullum, Ben Stokes (Ashes)

Opinion

Atherton: McCullum's 'overprepared' England claim 'tone deaf'

Pat Cummins (PA Images)

Cummins back for third Ashes Test as England's beach break defended