Skip to content

Rob Baxter: Playing whole 2022 Guinness Six Nations in one country may be best option

"For the national bodies, their responsibility goes beyond the professional sport, it goes right down to grassroots rugby, so if playing the tournament provides a level of income that cancelling it or no crowds doesn't create, then we've got to look at the next best scenario"

six nations
Image: With crowd restrictions currently in place in Wales, Scotland, Ireland and France, moving the 2022 Six Nations to England has been argued for

Rob Baxter believes playing this season's Guinness Six Nations Championship in one country has "got to be better than cancelling it" or playing in empty stadiums. 

The tournament is due to kick off in Dublin and Edinburgh on February 5, but currently finds itself shrouded in uncertainty.

Under current Welsh Government restrictions imposed due to the coronavirus pandemic and its omicron variant, Wales would have to play scheduled home games against Scotland, France and Italy behind closed doors.

Indeed, the Welsh Government has told Sky Sports News that it is currently not in a position to rule out restrictions preventing crowds watching elite sport in Wales continuing and therefore impacting those forthcoming Six Nations matches.

Ireland vs Wales (AP)
Josh Van Der Flier
Image: Last year's Six Nations Championship was played exclusively behind closed doors, but each nation had full crowds back in November

On Boxing Day, new Covid-19 protocols came into force in Wales which banned large crowds from gathering, and on Wednesday a Welsh Government spokesperson told Sky Sports: "As a result of the rapidly spreading omicron variant, Wales is currently at alert level two. The Cabinet is reviewing the situation on a weekly basis."

Last month Economy Minister Vaughan Gething told Sky Sports News he understood the concerns of professional football and rugby clubs in Wales who would have to play behind closed doors. It was his hope that restrictions could be lifted to allow crowds back "as soon as possible."

The Welsh Rugby Union (WRU) continues to sell tickets for Wales' Six Nations fixture against Scotland in Cardiff on February 12 despite not knowing whether Government rules will have changed to allow the return of crowds. If current restrictions remain in place in five weeks time, the WRU will not be permitted to allow any spectators into it's 74,500 capacity Principality Stadium.

Also See:

Guinness Six Nations - Rounds One and Two

Round One Ireland vs Wales February 5 at 2.15pm
Scotland vs England February 5 at 4.45pm
France vs Italy February 6 at 3pm
Round Two Wales vs Scotland February 12 at 2.15pm
France vs Ireland February 12 at 4.45pm
Italy vs England February 13 at 3pm

In Scotland, the current restrictions are in place until January 17 and they limit attendances to just 500 fans.

On Wednesday, First Minister Nicola Sturgeon gave a potentially positive update for the Six Nations and shared that conversations are taking place with the Scottish Rugby Union regarding their home fixtures at Murrayfield.

"I hope very much we won't have to go beyond January 17, with these restrictions," Sturgeon said.

"All of us, including myself, want to be able to cheer Scotland on at Murrayfield in the Six Nations. But I don't do anybody any good if I try to give certainty ahead of our ability to do that. We will continue to use the data and the evidence and reach the judgments to get that clarity as soon as possible.

"I certainly do, very firmly, hope that these matches will go ahead - and will go ahead to crowds of supporters," she added.

Scotland are due to host England in their opening Six Nations fixture on February 5
Image: Scotland are due to host England in their opening Six Nations fixture on February 5

"We have right throughout had very good discussions with the SRU [Scottish Rugby Union] about matches at Murrayfield. They have been very constructive at working with us to enable games to go ahead.

"I know how important clarity is for those who cater for big sporting events and not least matches at Murrayfield, so that's very much in our minds as we take decisions."

The current rules in Ireland state a maximum of 5000 supporters may attend outdoor sporting events, with Andy Farrell's side due to host Wales, Italy and Scotland in 2022.

Capacity crowds are currently allowed in England, provided spectators can prove full vaccination status or provide a negative lateral flow test.

Against such a backdrop, playing the whole competition - it takes place across five weekends between early February and mid-March - in one country with permitted crowds has also been mooted in some quarters.

Financial implications of behind-closed-doors home games for any of the unions would be significant.

Full crowds were allowed at the Principality Stadium, Aviva Stadium and Murrayfield for the recent Autumn Nations Series Tests, before fresh restrictions took effect.

"The whole beauty of the Six Nations has been that change of environment, that change of weather conditions, going to play in Scotland, Wales, Ireland - those are the great challenges," Exeter rugby director Baxter said.

"That's what makes the Six Nations such a great competition to win.

"You've seen French teams in that one week they can beat anyone in the world in Paris, and then the next week it doesn't go quite so well in Cardiff.

"That's the beauty of the tournament, that's what from a rugby perspective I am sure we would all want to see happen.

"That said, we can't all sit here and pretend the world is in an ideal place at the moment.

Rob Baxter
Image: Exeter Chiefs director of rugby Rob Baxter says moving the tournament to one place for 2022 may well be the best option

"For the national bodies, their responsibility goes beyond the professional sport, it goes right down to grassroots rugby, so if playing the tournament provides a level of income that cancelling it or no crowds doesn't create, then we've got to look at the next best scenario.

"If the next best scenario is playing it in one country, where you can have sell-out crowds, you can raise some revenue and you can keep that income stream going for all the bodies, then it's got to be better than cancelling it.

"I think with every sporting body, it's revenue that is the biggest thing that has been damaged, so anything that can keep revenue online has got to be preferable to just binning things for a season.

"We've all had to try and find a way to keep going, to try and keep revenue coming in. It's the same with any business, you've got to explore those options."

Around Sky