Skip to content

Paul Pogba to Manchester United: Record buys don't guarantee league success

Mourinho compared Pogba's fee to Gareth Bale's move to Real Madrid
Image: Gareth Bale is yet to win a league title with Real Madrid

Manchester United may have broken the world transfer record to bring Paul Pogba back to Old Trafford but history shows that splashing the cash on a big money signing isn't always a guarantee for immediate league success.

A glance back at the last eleven record-breaking fees shows that on just one occasion was the new arrival able to help steer his new club to a league title.

Will Pogba be able to buck the trend and lead Mourinho's men back to the top of the Premier League? We look at previous record-breaking arrivals and the impact they made...

Gareth Bale
Tottenham to Real Madrid - £85.3m
Real Madrid's 2013/14 league finish: 3rd

Image: It was all smiles as the Welshman became a Real Madrid player

Bale played an important role in Real Madrid's Champions League and Copa del Rey successes in his first season at the Bernabeu, but he was unable to make the difference in La Liga. Madrid finished the season in third place on 87 points, three points behind title winners Atletico Madrid and behind Barcelona on their head-to-head record.

Cristiano Ronaldo
Manchester Utd to Real Madrid - £80m
Real Madrid's 2009/10 league finish: 2nd

Real Madrid forward Cristiano Ronaldo celebrates after scoring against Deportivo
Image: Ronaldo wasn't able to win La Liga in his first season with Real

Ronaldo hit the ground running in his first season at Real Madrid with 26 goals in 29 La Liga appearances but ended the season trophyless. Madrid were pipped to the league title by Barcelona and were dumped out of the Champions League Round of 16 by Lyon, while on a personal level Ronaldo also lost out to Messi in the Ballon D'Or and Pichichi that year.

Kaka
AC Milan to Real Madrid - £56m
Real Madrid's 2009/10 league finish: 2nd

A star at AC MILAN, KAKA became the then-2nd most costly player ever when REAL MADRID paid £50m for him. He lasted 4 underwhelming years before returning.
Image: Kaka was briefly the world's most expensive player

Arriving in Madrid a couple of weeks before Ronaldo, Kaka only briefly held the world record for a transfer fee in pounds sterling but his eight goals and six assists helped Real to a mammoth haul of 96 points in his debut season, only to fall short of rivals Barcelona by three points.

Zinedine Zidane
Juventus to Real Madrid - £46.6m
Real Madrid's 2001/02 league finish: 3rd

Glasgow, UNITED KINGDOM:  TO GO WITH AFP STORIES ABOUT ZIDANE's RETIREMENT - (FILES) - Picture taken 15 May 2002 in Glasgow showd Real Madrid's Zinedine Zi
Image: Zinedine Zidane won the Champions League in his first season at Real Madrid - but not La Liga

Although Zidane's debut season will forever be remembered for his sensational volleyed winner against Bayer Leverkusen in the Champions League final, Madrid could only muster a third-place finish in La Liga that year. Real ended with 66 points, two behind Deportivo La Coruna in second, and nine points behind champions Valencia.

Also See:

Luis Figo
Barcelona to Real Madrid - £37m
Real Madrid's 2000/01 league finish: 1st

Real Madrid's Luis Figo (C) darts betwen Bacelona's players Gabri (L) and Gaizka Mendieta (R) during their Spanish League match.
Image: Luis Figo helped Real Madrid to the title in 2000/01

The exception to the rule. Figo's controversial move from Barcelona signalled the beginning of the Galactico era at Real Madrid and immediately paid dividends with a first league triumph in four years.  The Portuguese winger scored nine goals as Madrid romped to the La Liga title with 80 points, seven points clear of runners-up Deportivo La Coruna.

Hernan Crespo
Parma to Lazio - £35.5m
Lazio's 2000/01 league finish: 3rd

8 Sep 2000:  Hernan Crespo of Lazio celebrates victory after the Italian Super Cup match against Inter Milan played at the Stadio Olimpico, in Rome, Italy.
Image: Hernan Crespo and Lazio were beaten to the Serie A title by Roma

Crespo followed on from his prolific form at Parma with 26 goals in his first season for Lazio but was unable to help the Biancocelesti defend their Serie A title.  Cross-city rivals Roma won their first Scudetto since 1982/83, with Juventus finishing second and Lazio ending the season back in third on 69 points.

Christian Vieri
Lazio to Inter Milan - £32.1m
Inter Milan's 1999/00 league finish: 4th

Christian Vieri Inter
Image: Christian Vieri couldn't help Inter to the Serie A crown

The powerful Italian striker was brought to the San Siro as Inter Milan looked to bounce back from an eighth place finish the year before.  Injuries disrupted his first season but Vieri still managed a respectable 13 goals in 20 games as Inter climbed to a fourth-place finish.

Denilson
Sao Paulo to Real Betis - £21.5m
Real Betis's 1998/99 league finish: 11th

16 Dec 2001:  Denilson of Real Betis and Vincente Engonga of Real Mallorca in action during the Primera Liga match between Real Betis and Real Mallorca, pl
Image: Despite spending big on Denilson, Real Betis finished mid-table

Denilson's move to Betis provides one of the more cautionary tales of the inflated expectations associated with record transfer fees.  The mercurial Brazilian winger failed to impress at the Benito Villamarin, managing two goals from 35 appearances in his debut season, as Betis slumped to a mid-table 11th place finish, before being relegated the next season.

Ronaldo
Barcelona to Inter Milan - £19.5m
Inter Milan's 1997/98 league finish: 2nd

20 Sep 1998:  Ronaldo of Inter Milan celebrates a goal during the Serie A match against Piacenza in Milan, Italy. Inter won the game 1-0. \ Mandatory Credi
Image: New signing Ronaldo was unable to lead Inter Milan to the title

Ronaldo quickly adapted to life in Italy and hit 25 goals in his first season at Inter Milan, only bettered by Oliver Bierhoff's 27 for Udinese.  Nevertheless, Inter were unable to translate this into a Scudetto win, finishing second and five points behind Juventus, but did claim silverware after beating Lazio 3-0 in the Uefa Cup final with Ronaldo on the scoresheet.

Alan Shearer
Blackburn to Newcastle - £15m
Newcastle's 1996/97 league finish: 2nd

Alan Shearer scores for Newcastle United against Sunderland in 2006
Image: Alan Shearer finished second with Newcastle after his famous move

Shearer joined Newcastle fresh off the back of a prolific spell at Blackburn Rovers with the aim of guiding his boyhood club to an elusive Premier League victory.  Shearer netted 25 goals in 31 appearances but it wasn't enough as Keegan's men fell short once again, losing out to Manchester United for a second consecutive season.

Ronaldo
PSV to Barcelona - £13.2m
Barcelona's 1996/97 league finish: 2nd

1996:  Ronaldo of Barcelona during the Primera Liga match against San Lorenzo at the Nou Camp in Barcelona. \ Mandatory Credit: Shaun Botterill /Allsport
Image: Ronaldo's 34 goals in 37 appearances weren't enough to fire Barcelona to the title

Despite Ronaldo's phenomenal form in his one and only season at the Nou Camp, Barcelona's 90 points were not enough to win La Liga as they finished two shy of champions Real Madrid.  Ronaldo scored 34 times in 37 league appearances and made up for the league disappointment by firing them to victory in the Cup Winners' Cup and Supercopa.

Around Sky