Blogs & Opinion

Unhappy endings

Rounding off another Premier League season

Martin Tyler - Martin Tyler Posted 25th May 2011 view comments

Martin Tyler's stats and facts column is here!

Every week he will be here to offer you statistical gems to make your day, impress your mates and, on occasion, to settle the odd bet.

Sky Sports' voice of football and his back-up team of experts are here to answer your questions and queries on all things statistical and historical from the beautiful game.

Campbell: scored plenty but couldn't save Blackpool's Premier League life

Campbell: scored plenty but couldn't save Blackpool's Premier League life

If you have spotted something from a game or have been stumped by a pub quiz question, simply email and he will do his best to help.

This is Martin's final column of the season, but if you think of any questions over the summer months send them in, and he will endeavour to answer them when the new season kicks off in August...

Tyler's Starting Stat

I was at Old Trafford for the final day of the Premier League season to witness two very different endings. Blackpool of course, returned to the Championship, but left a fitting legacy of being the highest scorers in a 38-game season to get relegated. Their 55 goals sets them apart from anyone and they are indeed the only side to have broken the half-century and not survived. Of those, Charlie Adam netted his 12th league goal of the campaign and 13th in all competitions, which included eight penalties, two free-kicks and memorably, one corner! And he was the first visiting player to score a first-half Premier League goal at Old Trafford since Joe Cole, in Chelsea's win, in April 2010.

One start that Blackpool supporters won't enjoy reading is that Sunday was the fifth time in their last seven away games they have lost a leading position, picking up just two points in the process. The draws at Spurs and Blackburn were small consolation though, when you consider that's 13 points they have surrendered from winning positions.

The happier flipside to Sunday was of course Manchester United's title celebrations. They also set a new record for English champions, having picked up an impressive 68.8 per cent of their points at home, surpassing the previous high set by Sheffield Wednesday way back in 1929! Ian Evatt's own goal was only the third in their favour this season, joining Brede Hangeland and Anton Ferdinand (courtesy of the dubious goals panel) in putting through his own net against United - compared to 10 last term. Oh and in case you have been living under a rock for the last three weeks, their 19th title is of course a new English record!

Hi Mr Tyler, amazing column! My question for you is, in the Chelsea v Newcastle match the other weekend, out of the four goals scored, three were scored by defenders, so which team has most goals scored by defenders this season? I believe Chelsea would be quite near the top, with the likes of Branislav Ivanovic, John Terry and David Luiz. Thanks. Priya Ramesh
Now the season is done and dusted it is a fitting time to give defenders a bit of credit they rarely get, Priya. And you should take some yourself, because in the Premier League it was Chelsea's defenders who were the most prolific, netting 11 goals between them. Branislav Ivanovic did indeed lead the way with four goals, John Terry had three, while Alex and David Luiz chipped in with two apiece. Next in the table come Everton and Stoke with 10 apiece from their defenders.

Stoke, no doubt aided by Rory Delap and those long throws, had five different scorers, none more so than Robert Huth who, with six goals, was their joint second top scorer, along with Jonathan Walters - only Kenywne Jones scored more. And if you throw in their fabulous cup exploits this season, they total 17 goals in all from the back. Huth was also the Premier League's joint top scorer this season with six, a total matched by Fulham's Brede Hangeland, with both centre-backs managing a brace in league games; Huth's against Sunderland and Hangeland's in the recent win over Birmingham which helped push the Blues towards relegation.

At the other end of proceedings, once again we find West Ham, whose defenders were obviously a little too busy to bomb downfield and managed just two goals from Manuel da Costa and James Tomkins. West Brom and Sunderland could only boast three apiece at the end of difficult campaign.

We should also give a special mention to Arsenal, so often criticised for not scoring any headed goals, the defender's best bet, because they are sat comfortable in mid-table with six - including three headers, from Johan Djourou, Sebastien Squillaci and Laurent Koscielny. Here, as always, is a list in full courtesy, for the last time this season, to the boffins at Opta.

Chelsea 11
Everton 10
Stoke City 10
Blackburn Rovers 9
Fulham 9
Birmingham City 8
Manchester City 8
Manchester United 7
Arsenal 6
Aston Villa 6
Liverpool 6
Blackpool 5
Bolton Wanderers 5
Newcastle United 5
Tottenham Hotspur 5
Wolverhampton Wanderers 5
Wigan Athletic 4
Sunderland 3
West Bromwich Albion 3
West Ham United 2.

Hi Mr Tyler, great column. Birmingham got relegated today, being defending champions of Carling Cup. My question is how many teams have got relegated while being defending champions of a major trophy in English football? Anonymous, via email
Well, that's another good question - unless you happen to be a Bluenose, of course. To go back through all the trophy winners in English football would take more time than the two-month gap between seasons allow, but I can tell you the last time it happened. You have to go back through the Premier League era to 1985 when Norwich City - who ironically have been promoted this season - won the League Cup, or the Milk Cup as it was known at the time, yet still went down to the old Second Division.

Ken Brown's side beat Sunderland 1-0 in the final at Wembley, thanks to an own goal from Gordon Chisolm, yet finished in 20th place in the old 22-club top flight. They did pick up 49 points which seems high by today's standards, but remember it was a 42-game season, as opposed to 38, with three points for a win.

On top of that, the beaten finalists were also relegated that season, Len Ashurst's Sunderland side finishing second bottom, with 40 points. It has never happened in the Premier League era, but the closest we came was in in the 1996-97 season when Bryan Robson's Middlesbrough reached both the FA and League Cup finals, lost them and were relegated!

But I think the best example of 'defending champions' suffering has to be Manchester City, who won the old First Division for the first time back in 1937, only to relegated the very next season!

Hi Martin, I really enjoy your weekly column. After seeing DJ Campbell move up to sixth in this season's top scorers' list but with his team Blackpool in the bottom three, it got me wondering: which players have been among the top goal scorers in the Premier League but seen their side suffer relegation? Thanks, Dale Charge
Good question Dale, there have been a few instances of a side getting relegated yet having a player in the top 10 of the Premier League scorers' chart. As you mentioned, DJ Campbell achieved it this season, netting 13 times in his 31 Premier League appearances, despite his team, Blackpool, going down on the final day of the campaign.

That feat was replicated by Darren Bent - a man who always seems to be in the upper echelons of the top scorers' chart - in the 2006-07 season when he played for Charlton. The Addicks went down after a seven-year stint in the top flight, but Bent still managed to notch 13 goals.

Peter Crouch (Southampton), Fabrizio Ravanelli (Middlesbrough), Chris Armstrong (Crystal Palace) and Paul Wilkinson (Middlesbrough) have also fired their way into the top scorers' standings, despite playing in a side suffering the ignominy of relegation, as the table below shows.

Those eagle-eyed amongst you may point out Nottingham Forest's Teddy Sheringham, who finished as the top Premier League scorer during the 1992-93 campaign with 22 goals as Forest were relegated. However, Sheringham only scored once for the Tricky Trees - his further 21 strikes came after a switch to Tottenham, so we didn't think it right to include him as a Forest player!

I also thought I'd throw former Leicester midfielder Muzzy Izzet into the mix. The ex-Turkey international was not amongst the top scorers when the Foxes went down at the end of the 2003-04 campaign, but he did chip in with an excellent 14 assists.

2010-11DJ CampbellBlackpool13
2006-07Darren BentCharlton13
2004-05Peter CrouchSouthampton12
1996-97Fabrizio RavanelliMiddlesbrough16
1992-93Chris ArmstrongCrystal Palace15
1992-93Paul WilkinsonMiddlesbrough15

Hi Martin. Great column. I was wondering if the points total in the respective league campaigns for the finalists of the Champions League has any bearing on the outcome? I.e. Inter Milan had 12 more points in Seria A than Bayern Munich did in Bundesliga 09/10. Thanks, Mark GrindleMARTIN SAYS:
That's an interesting question as we look forward to Wembley this weekend Mark - although of course, different leagues across Europe have varied in the number of games played at various stages. But I have looked back over the last 18 years, since the Champions League has been in its current format and it seems the omens might well favour Manchester United, because on 10 occasions, the side heading into the final with the fewer league points has gone on to lift the famous trophy.

On seven occasions the side with more points has done it and only once, in 2001 when Bayern Munich beat Valencia have the two finalists had the same amount of points. This season Barcelona amassed 96 points on their way to winning La Liga, 16 more points than United managed in winning their record 19th title. That difference of 16 will be the second biggest between Champions League finalists, but again if it's omens you're looking for, the only time the gap was bigger it was the side with least points that went on to win - and an English side at that!

In 2005, Liverpool finished fifth in the Premier League and totalled a whopping 21 league points less than their opponents in Istanbul, AC Milan - and you don't need me to tell you what happened there. But to balance it all out, the previous two times United have been crowned Champions League winners, they went into the final with more points than their opponents. They had two more than Chelsea in 2007 and one more than Bayern Munich in 1999, but had played two games more.

2010 Winners INTER had 12 points more than runners-up Bayern Munich
2009 Winners BARCELONA had 3 points less than runners-up Manchester Utd
2008 Winners MANCHESTER UTD had 2 points more than runners-up Chelsea
2007 Winners MILAN had 7 points less than runners-up Liverpool (but played two fewer games)
2006 Winners BARCELONA had 15 points more than runners-up Arsenal
2005 Winners LIVERPOOL had 21 points less than runners-up Milan (despite playing two more games)
2004 Winners PORTO had 7 points more than runners-up Monaco (despite playing two fewer games)
2003 Winners MILAN had 11 points less than runners-up Juventus
2002 Winners REAL MADRID had 3 points less than runners-up Bayer Leverkusen (despite playing two more games)
2001 Winners BAYERN MUNICH had the same points total as runners-up Valencia (but played two fewer games)
2000 Winners REAL MADRID had 2 points less than runners-up Valencia
1999 Winners MANCHESTER UTD had 1 more point than runners-up Bayern Munich (but played two more games)
1998 Winners REAL MADRID had 11 points less than runners-up Juventus (despite playing two more games)
1997 Winners BORUSSIA DORTMUND had 2 points less than runners-up Juventus
1996 Winners JUVENTUS had 8 points less than runners-up Ajax
1995 Winners AJAX had 1 more point than runners-up Milan
1994 Winners MILAN had 6 points less than runners-up Barcelona (but played two fewer games)
1993 Winners MARSEILLE had 5 points more than runners-up Milan but were subsequently disqualified from Ligue 1 due to a betting scandal.

Martin, A question that came up the other day and thought you would be the right man to answer it. How many current Premier League players have Champions League winners medals? Also, are there any other players in the rest of the English Football league that have a medal as well? Thanks, Michael Davey
That's a very good question Michael. We have scoured through the record books and have come up with 31 players who were at Premier League clubs for the season just gone. Of that 30, one, Sulley Muntari was on loan, but five stand out as having won the Champions League twice. And three of them, can make it a hat-trick if Manchester United beat Barcelona on Saturday.

Hardly surprisingly for a man who keeps breaking records, Ryan Giggs can complete the hat-trick having been part of United's previous two triumphs, as can Wes Brown and Edwin van der Sar, the latter having lifted the trophy with Ajax way back in 1995. Sadly injury will keep Owen Hargreaves out of the equation, but like Van Der Sar he has won the competition with United and a foreign side, Bayern Munich, in 2001.

And Michel Salgado, who has become a cult favourite at Blackburn also has two winners' medals, in 2000 and 2002 with Real Madrid. As their arch rivals Barcelona are in town, we should mention two of their former players plying their trade on these shore who won it with the Catalans two years ago, Yaya Toure and Eidrr Gudjohnsen, who ended the season on-loan at Fulham.

Here is the list in full...

Edwin van der Sar - (Man Utd) Ajax 1995, Man Utd 2008
Ryan Giggs - (Man Utd) Man Utd 1999, 2008
Wes Brown - (Man Utd) Man Utd 1999, 2008
Michel Salgado (Blackburn) - Real Madrid 2000, 2002
Owen Hargreaves (Man Utd) - Bayern Munich 2001, Man Utd 2008
Phil Neville (Everton) - Man Utd 1999
Jonathan Greening (Fulham) - Man Utd 1999
Nicolas Anelka (Chelsea) - Real Madrid 2000
Roque Santa Cruz (Man City) - Bayern Munich 2001
Paulo Ferreira (Chelsea) - Porto 2004
Jose Bosingwa (Chelsea) - Porto 2004
Benni McCarthy (West Ham) - Porto 2004
Jamie Carragher - Liverpool 2005
Steven Gerrard - Liverpool 2005
Scott Carson (WBA) - Liverpool 2005
Rio Ferdinand, Nemanja Vidic, Patrice Evra, Paul Scholes, Michael Carrick, Wayne Rooney, Carlos Tevez, Tomasz Kuszczak, John O'Shea, Anderson, Nani, Darren Fletcher (all Man Utd) Man Utd 2008
Yaya Toure (Man City) - Barcelona 2009
Eidur Gudjohnsen (Fulham on loan from Stoke) - Barcelona 2009
Sulley Muntari (Sunderland on loan from Inter) - Inter 2010
Mario Balotelli (Man City) - Inter 2010

The second part of your question is a little harder to answer, but we have come up with one permanent player, one loanee and a manager who were all in the Football League last year having won the Champions League previously. The first one is Portsmouth's Nwankwo Kanu, who won the competition with Ajax in 1995 and is still with Portsmouth. One of his team-mates in that Ajax win over AC Milan was Edgar Davids, who had a brief spell on loan at Crystal Palace beween August and November this season. And we should also give a special mention to Paul Lambert who won the competition with Paul Lambert with Borussia Dortmund in 1997 and of course guided Norwich City to promotion from the Championship.

Tyler's teaser

Fill in your answers to Martin's teaser using the feedback form below - and keep those questions coming in!

Just a quick thank you to all of you out there for sending in your questions - and having a crack at my teasers - this season. We do enjoy answering your queries whenever we can, so keep sending them in all summer. I will be back during the Euro Under-21 Championships, with my diary from Denmark. See you then...

Comments (33)

  • Page 1 of 2
  • 1
  • 2

David Pick (Newcastle United fan) says...

Hi Martin, great column as usual. Newcastle at home this season have been renowned for some colossal home wins. However, my question relates to their draws. Newcastle at home have had 5 different draw scorelines this season (0-0, 1-1, 2-2, 3-3 and 4-4) - has any club ever done this during a premier league season before - either just at home or both home and away? Keep up the great work Martin.

Posted 09:50 30th May 2011

Jack Riley (Newcastle United fan) says...

martin , kevin nolan has scored 12 goals this season for newcastle and in doing so scored his 50th premier ship goal with a header against bolton , but what i would like to know is how many english players have scored 50 premier ship goals and never had an england call up im not guessing many ?

Posted 02:57 30th May 2011

Andy Purvis (Sunderland fan) says...

Just regarding the top scorers at relegated clubs section, didn't Andy Johnson score 20+ goals when Crystal Palace were relegated from the Premier? May be wrong so I don't mind being corrected, but I'm pretty sure he's up there!

Posted 13:08 27th May 2011

Philp Beattie (Manchester United fan) says...

surely paul scholes got a medal for 1999? i know he wasn't part of the match squad for the final, but i thought each of the 25 registered players got one.

Posted 08:29 27th May 2011

Sefton Monk (Fulham fan) says...

I would like to know if the Premirleague diddn't count penatlies towards golden boot, what would the standings actually have been this season 1st to 10th . and also if it isn't too much trouble all previous premierleague seasons winner.

Posted 04:15 27th May 2011

Richard Cotman (Arsenal fan) says...

Hi martin i believe your wrong about the top scores who have been relegated, andrew johnson scored 21 league goals in the 2004/2005 season for crystal palace and got relegated with them that same season.

Posted 22:40 26th May 2011

James King (Everton fan) says...

your list for the players with champions league medals is wrong, your missing louis saha who has also won a champions league medal

Posted 22:26 26th May 2011

Kris Archer (Wolverhampton Wanderers fan) says...

In answer to who said it, no Diao and Diouf don't have Champions League medals from 2005, however, one player who does is now a coach at Leicester City, Didi Hamann. Also, Carvalho is not on the list as he doesn't play in England, so seems to make sense.

Posted 21:50 26th May 2011

Matthew Turvey (Aston Villa fan) says...

My Question for Martin is Aston Villa started the final day on the season in 13th and finished it in 9th. Moving up 5 places. Is this the largest movement up the table on the final day in Premier League History?

Posted 21:46 26th May 2011

Tim Sheedy (Reading fan) says...

What would this season's table have looked like if you factor out goals scored by each team's top scorer? e.g. Kuyt's (Liverpool's top scorer) hat-trick against Utd. would be taken away resulting in a new net score of 1-0 Utd. minusing 3 points from Liverpool's total. I have a feeling Liverpool may have finished 3rd if that was the case as Van Persie (18) and Tevez (21) have much more than Liverpool's top scorer Kuyt (13 for Liverpool) and Van Der Vaart (13) scored more important goals, changing results. West Brom as you pointed out earlier in your column would be relegated without Odemwingie's 15 (Aston Villa would have a similar drop) but who else would go down. West Ham may not have as Demba only sored 7 for them.

Posted 19:00 26th May 2011

Abba Sanda (Chelsea fan) says...

pls tyler can u send my message to chelsea.they should buy neymar sanchez modric and van der wiel if not i will hating chelsea...Hiddink should be coach and wilkins d asst coach...

Posted 18:05 26th May 2011

Eric Hajdu (Leeds United fan) says...

El Hadji Diouf spent the first half of the season with Blackburn Rovers and won the Champion's League with Liverpool as did Stoke City's Salif Diao!

Posted 18:00 26th May 2011

Eric Hajdu (Leeds United fan) says...

Mr. Tyler, You made quite a noticeable oversight! In 2004-2005 season Andy Johnson (Crystal Palace) scored 21 goals in the Premier League and they were relegated!! He should be #1 on your list ahead of DJ Campbell. You very rarely make errors, so I hope someone takes notice of this. Thanks for the great articles, week in week out. - Eric

Posted 17:18 26th May 2011

Ben Wery (Milton Keynes Dons fan) says...

In response to who in the lower leagues has a champion league medal. Doesn't Neil Mellor (Preston North End - loan to Sheffield Wednesday) have one? Liverpool 2005

Posted 16:58 26th May 2011

Matt Dorsett (Crystal Palace fan) says...

Surely Andy Johnson should make the list of relegated top goalscorers during the Eagles last Premier League season???

Posted 16:41 26th May 2011

Rehan Hussain (Liverpool fan) says...

Hi Martin, Did Paul Scholes not win it twice? 1999 and 2008? I know he missed the final but am sure he played in the campaign. I'm sure he even scored against Barcelona in the 3-3.

Posted 16:13 26th May 2011

Tom Halpin (Arsenal fan) says...

Didn't Andy Johnson finish second in the goal scoring charts when palace got relegated in 04/05 ?

Posted 15:56 26th May 2011

Dan House (Wolverhampton Wanderers fan) says...

Could you explain why claiming 68.8% of your points at home is a good stat? If you won every game of the season that would only be 50% of points claimed at home, so by your logic worse.

Posted 15:55 26th May 2011

Conor Martin (Chelsea fan) says...

andy johnson got 21 league goals for crystal palace when they were relegated from the premiership in 2004/2005 season!

Posted 15:02 26th May 2011

Nick Mccluff (Manchester United fan) says...

Hi Martin, I didn't realise Carlos Tevez was still plying his trade at Man Utd!!! =D

Posted 14:51 26th May 2011

  • Page 1 of 2
  • 1
  • 2

back to top

Other Football Experts:

Latest Posts in Football:

Latest News RSS feeds

Chelsea in good shape for PSG

Chelsea boss Jose Mourinho is likely to have a strong squad to select from for their Champions League game with Paris Saint-Germain.

'Let's throw some punches'

New Aston Villa manager Tim Sherwood says he is planning to install a more attacking approach at the club.

LVG: We must sign a midfielder

Louis van Gaal has confirmed that Manchester United will attempt to sign a creative midfield player this summer.

Live transfer updates

Live transfer news as Louis van Gaal makes the signing a creative midfielder his top priority this summer.

Bony trains with new team-mates

Wilfried Bony has trained with Man City for the first time after winning the Africa Cup of Nations with Ivory Coast.


Tim Sherwood's to-do list: Five things the new Aston Villa manager must make a priority if he is to succeed

Tim Sherwood's to-do list: Five things the new Aston Villa manager must make a priority if he is to succeed

As Tim Sherwood settles into his first day at work as Aston Villa manager, the challenge of keeping the Premier League perennials in the top flight begins.

Pogba? Verratti? Manchester United boss Louis van Gaal wants a creative midfielder but who should he sign?

Pogba? Verratti? Manchester United boss Louis van Gaal wants a creative midfielder but who should he sign?

Only a fortnight after the transfer window closed, Louis van Gaal has set tongues wagging again by admitting that Manchester United need to sign a creative midfielder.

Xabi Alonso impressing at Bayern Munich under Pep Guardiola and eyeing a third Champions League medal

Xabi Alonso impressing at Bayern Munich under Pep Guardiola and eyeing a third Champions League medal

Adam Bate looks at Xabi Alonso's fine form with Bayern Munich and why he can make history this season.