Skip to content

Rafael Benitez v Premier League managers? Newcastle boss's hot streak against Sam Allardyce

Sam Allardyce and Rafael Benitez have fractious relationship

Rafa Benitez is back in the Premier League with Newcastle but what is his record against the current crop of managers?

The Spaniard was appointed Newcastle boss on Friday after Steve McClaren was finally relieved of his duties and is tasked with steering the second-bottom Magpies to safety.

It will be no easy initiation for Benitez, with league leaders Leicester up first in Monday Night Footballbut Newcastle fans with one eye on Sunday's Sky Live derby clash with bitter rivals Sunderland may take hope from their new manager's previous against Black Cats boss Sam Allardyce.

Live Ford Monday Night Football

Benitez has claimed seven wins from 12 matches against Allardyce - giving him a win percentage of almost 60 per cent.

That ratio is only marginally bettered by his record against a previous Newcastle manager in Alan Pardew - and Pardew's Crystal Palace visit Tyneside at the end of April in what could be another crunch clash in Benitez's bid to keep his new club in the top flight. 

Benitez record against current PL managers

Opp Manager Played Won Drawn Lost Win Percentage
Alan Pardew 5 3 1 1 60%
Arsene Wenger 13 4 4 5 30.8%
Mark Hughes 11 4 6 1 36.4%
Mauricio Pochettino 1 0 0 1 0%
Sam Allardyce 12 7 2 3 58.3%
Tony Pulis 5 2 3 0 40%

Improving an already striking win ratio against Allardyce would likely give Benitez, as well as the long-suffering Toon Army, satisfaction because it's fair to say the pair don't see eye-to-eye.

Their feud started when the then-Liverpool boss was critical of Allardyce's Bolton and their physical playing style - a sentiment that did not sit well.

Also See:

"Rafa would be very lucky to be in a job if he hadn't got to two Champions League finals, because they've had some very poor finishes in the Premier League," Allardyce was quoted as saying in a magazine interview in September 2007, after he had left Bolton to take the Newcastle job.

Bolton, UNITED KINGDOM:  Bolton Wanderers manager Sam Allardyce (R) and Liverpool manager Rafa Benitez (L) give their players instructions during their Eng
Image: Allardyce (right) and his Bolton side earned criticism from Rafa

"While they are a very good Champions League team, they're not a Premier League-winning side. They don't have the mentality to win that yet."

Things came to a head, after several other spats, in 2010, following another victory for Benitez - Liverpool's 2-1 success over Blackburn at Anfield.

Benitez PL record v Allardyce

Date & venue Benitez team Score Allardyce team
29/08/04, Reebok Stadium Liverpool 0-1 Bolton
02/04/05, Anfield Liverpool 1-0 Bolton
02/01/06, Reebok Stadium Liverpool 2-2 Bolton
09/04/06, Anfield Liverpool 1-0 Bolton
30/08/06, Reebok Stadium Liverpool 0-2 Bolton
01/01/07, Anfield Liverpool 3-0 Bolton
24/11/07, St James' Park Liverpool 3-0 Newcastle
11/04/09, Anfield Liverpool 4-0 Blackburn
05/12/09, Ewood Park Liverpool 0-0 Blackburn
28/02/10, Anfield Liverpool 2-1 Blackburn
01/12/12, Upton Park Chelsea 1-3 West Ham
17/05/13, Stamford Bridge Chelsea 2-0 West Ham

"I think he is a model for all the managers all around the world," jibed Benitez. "His style of football, his behaviour, everything.

"He is the perfect role model for all the kids. I am sure parents will enjoy this model and encourage their kids to be the same. I also think Barcelona are trying to copy his style of football."

Allardyce responded - and didn't hold back.

Alan Pardew  (left) hasn't had much joy against Benitez
Image: Alan Pardew (left) hasn't had much joy against Benitez

"It was a good cover-up by Rafa because he knows how bad his side were," Allardyce said.

"He's got personal with it for many, many years now - that's why I don't like him and the feeling is probably mutual."

Allardyce later wrote in his book: "Of course, he can say he won the Champions League with Liverpool, which is something I never did. But it has nowt to do with him."

Live Ford Super Sunday

Watch Benitez's first game back in the Premier League live on Sky Sports 1 HD from 7pm on Monday.  Or watch for £6.99 without a contract, on NOW TV.

Around Sky