Skip to content

Gary Neville and Roy Keane: Man Utd response at Man City was embarrassing - they threw the towel in

Manchester United were comprehensively beaten 4-1 by Manchester City at the Etihad Stadium on Super Sunday; Gary Neville: "Man Utd's response to going 3-1 down has been embarrassing. The scoreline isn't the problem. It's the response that's the problem. They have thrown the towel in"

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Gary Neville reflects on Manchester United's terrible derby day on the Gary Neville Podcast after they were hammered 4-1 by rivals Manchester City

Gary Neville labelled Manchester United "embarrassing" and says they "threw the towel in" during Sunday's 4-1 defeat by rivals Manchester City, while Roy Keane insists "five or six players" should never play for the club again.

Doubles from Kevin De Bruyne and Riyad Mahrez restored City's six-point lead at the top of the Premier League as the champions delivered a commanding performance at the Etihad Stadium.

Jadon Sancho had equalised in the first half for United, but City soon showed their dominance and after De Bruyne's second goal restored the hosts' lead, the result was never in doubt.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

FREE TO WATCH: Highlights from Manchester City's win over Manchester United

"Manchester United's response to going 3-1 down has been embarrassing. Ninety-two per cent possession for City? They have given up," Sky Sports pundit Neville said. "They are walking around the pitch. It's nowhere near good enough.

"There can be no complaints. City have been absolutely outstanding. But as a Manchester United fan, it's embarrassing.

"City played brilliantly in the second half. But the effort and intensity from United in the last 20 minutes was non-existent.

"The scoreline isn't the problem. It's the response to going 3-1 down that's the problem. They have thrown the towel in.

Also See:

"At the end of the game, Manchester United finished like an absolute shower. They were a disgrace in the last 25 minutes."

Keane: 'Man Utd were shameful'

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Roy Keane accused Manchester United's players of giving up during the second half of their 4-1 defeat to rivals Manchester City

Keane agreed with Neville's withering assessment, describing United's response as "shameful".

"The worst thing that you could say about United is that they gave up," Keane told Sky Sports. "In any game, if you give up, it's unforgivable really. The beauty of top-level sport is that there's no hiding place.

"I know United have done well there in the last few years, but we saw all of United's shortcomings today. Man City were very good in the second half, but there are ways to lose football matches.

"You've got players not putting in performances and players not running back. They stopped running and they gave up. I don't understand it.

"The manager will be criticised about his tactics, but players not running back when you're playing for Man Utd is really unacceptable.

"They threw the towel in which is shameful. You need character and personality when you're up against it and after the third goal, it was game over."

Keane: Five or six players shouldn't play for Man Utd again

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Roy Keane was appalled by Fred's positioning for the second goal United conceded in the Manchester derby

Keane continued by arguing United's performance was so poor that "five or six players" should never play for the club again.

"You've got to run back and you've got to tackle. United players have shown quality over the years but we've seen a reflection of where the team is and where the club is," Keane added.

"They're so far behind the other teams. You hear noises all the time about things going on in the dressing room with a new manager coming in, but your own bit of pride eventually has to kick in at some stage.

"There were five or six players there who should never play for Manchester United again. It was shameful.

"City are a fantastic team and that's why they are champions. You hoped the subs who came on would have an impact, but they're not prepared to run around, couple of lads in midfield, Wan-Bissaka, Fred, Maguire, Rashford, I could go on.

"City didn't have to be at their best. They still had another couple of gears to go. They toyed with them like they did at Old Trafford.

"It was men vs boys as the old saying goes. They gave up and shame on them.

"United's history has been built on character and personality when you're up against it. I feel like I've been sat here for two weeks.

"United were never going to get back into it. The white flag came up and the game was over. It was unthinkable."

How poor were Manchester United in the second half?

Manchester United created an xG of 0.00 against Man City in the second half of Sunday's derby.

They failed to produce a shot of any description, had just four touches of the ball in City's box and secured only 21% of possession.

Keane: Ronaldo injury doesn't add up

Before kick-off, United interim manager Ralf Rangnick confirmed Cristiano Ronaldo was ruled out of the game due to a hip injury, but Keane believes something about the forward's absence "doesn't add up".

He had earlier said: "There seems to be more to the Ronaldo story when a manager comes out and talks about a hip flexor. I don't get it. We talk about Ronaldo being a machine and very rarely getting injured but every now and again he comes out with that... a hip flexor? It doesn't add up to me."

After the match, Keane added: "The Ronaldo stuff before the game worried me. There's something going on in the background with the club, the team and the players.

"There's something really amiss and we've been saying this for months now. There was no hiding place today and it was hard to watch."

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Speaking before kick-off, Keane said something about Cristiano Ronaldo missing the Manchester derby due to a hip injury 'doesn't add up'

Redknapp: 'Man Utd a million miles off'

Fellow Sky Sports pundit and former City defender Micah Richards agreed with Keane's view that it was "men vs boys" in the second half, while Jamie Redknapp insists United are "a million miles off" challenging for the title.

"I don't feel these City players feel the pressure. They know about the quality of Liverpool but they've turned up today and they've done the business," Richards said.

"It was men versus boys in that second half. Give praise to Manchester United at half-time as they did well up to that point, but in the second half they just took the game to a different level. When Kevin De Bruyne plays like that, he's the best midfielder in the league.

"The City team are relentless and if they turned up today they would win. They're just better."

Redknapp said: "There's a massive gulf between the two sides. What City have done over the past 10 years is they've created a team and they've thought about signings. With United, they've thrown together a team and they've hoped it's going to work.

"They've spent £50m on a right-back in Aaron Wan-Bissaka and there's been no improvement since he's been there.

"The other full-back, there's been no improvement. At centre-back they can't find a pair, in midfield they're not good enough and going forward they played with Pogba and Fernandes up front and it didn't work.

"As a team, it's not working. It takes time and needs the right culture. Right now, United are a million miles off.

"Whoever comes in next is going to need so much time and so many things to go for him. If you were Jurgen Klopp or Liverpool players watching that, you'd be fuming. They didn't even try a leg in the second half."

Follow Manchester United with Sky Sports

Follow every Man Utd game in the Premier League this season with our live blogs on the Sky Sports website and app, and watch match highlights for free shortly after full-time.

Want the Man Utd latest? Bookmark our Man Utd news page, check out Man Utd's fixtures and Man Utd's latest results, watch Man Utd goals and video, keep track of the Premier League table and see which Man Utd games are coming up live on Sky Sports.

Get all this and more - including notifications sent straight to your phone - by downloading the Sky Sports Scores app and setting Man Utd as your favourite team.

Hear the best Premier League reaction and expert analysis with the Essential Football and Gary Neville podcasts, keep up-to-date with our dedicated Transfer Centre, follow the Sky Sports social accounts on Twitter, Instagram and YouTube, and find out how to get Sky Sports.

    Win £250,000 with Super 6!
    Win £250,000 with Super 6!

    Another Saturday, another chance to win £250,000 with Super 6. Play for free, entries by 3pm.

    Around Sky