Skip to content

Ref Watch special: Would VAR have changed these calls?

BURTON-UPON-TRENT, ENGLAND - [DATE]: General images during Premier League VAR training at St Georges Park on October 10, 2017 in Burton-upon-Trent, England
Image: We take a look at four key incidents from past Premier League games

In a special edition of Ref Watch, Dermot Gallagher determines whether VAR would have overturned these key refereeing decisions.

Monday's FA Cup third-round match between Brighton and Crystal Palace will see the introduction of Video Assistant Referees (VAR) as part of a trial agreed between The FA, EFL and Premier League.

The Carabao Cup semi-final first leg between Chelsea and Arsenal, live on Sky Sports, will also take part in the scheme.

Video referees: Questions answered
Video referees: Questions answered

We break down all of the pressing questions ahead of the first games in England to use Video Assistant Referees.

To help supporters better understand the VAR process, we take a look at four key incidents from the Premier League...

Awarding a goal

Incident: Callum Wilson offside and handball, Bournemouth v West Ham, December 26, 2017

Callum Wilson is in an offside position as he turns home Nathan Ake's header across goal with his arm. The goal was eventually given.

Callum Wilson's controversial goal stole a point for Bournemouth
Image: Callum Wilson's controversial goal stole a point for Bournemouth

Gallagher's view: VAR would have cleared this up in seconds. One of the first replays you see after the goal is the sideward angle of the incident, which shows Wilson as being offside. With the facility they've got for drawing the lines across the pitch, that would make it easier too.

Also See:

The key thing is, it would have been picked up immediately because of the offside. Bobby Madley wouldn't have been put in any stressful situation during and after the game.

Awarding a penalty

Incident: Eden Hazard penalty, Arsenal v Chelsea, January 3, 2018

Anthony Taylor points to the spot after Hector Bellerin is adjudged to have kicked Eden Hazard in the penalty area. Hazard steps up to score the penalty in the 2-2 draw.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Eden Hazard was brought down in the area by Hector Bellerin last week

Gallagher's view: Let's make one thing clear: VAR will not give us a clean game. We won't have utopia, where referees don't make mistakes, because so many decisions are subjective. This is a classic example, where many people think it is a penalty, and many think the opposite.

If I was the referee in this situation, and VAR suggested I take a look at that incident, I may still stick with my original decision. You may not think that it's a penalty, but that's immaterial. The referee still has to make that decision. In my view, the referee would look at that and still think it's a penalty.

Red card offences

Incident: Sadio Mane dismissal, Man City v Liverpool, September 9, 2017

Sadio Mane is dismissed for a high boot on Man City goalkeeper Ederson early on in Liverpool's 5-0 defeat at the Etihad Stadium.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Sadio Mane was shown a straight red card for his high footed challenge on Ederson, but was the decision harsh on the forward?

Gallagher's view: I don't think the referee needs to go to VAR here. If the VAR had told Jon Moss to go to the side to buy a little bit of time to look at the incident, I am convinced the decision would have stood.

Mistaken identity

Incident: Kieran Gibbs sent off, Chelsea v Arsenal, March 22, 2014

Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain handles the ball on the goalline, but his team-mate Kieran Gibbs is dismissed

Gallagher's view: The VAR would have asked the Andre Marriner to take another look, and they would have seen straight away that it was Oxlade-Chamberlain who handled on the goalline, not Gibbs.

Of the four criteria, I think this is the most important. Through no fault of his own, the referee made the error, it was just an error.

Super 6 £1m jackpot
Super 6 £1m jackpot

Simply predict six correct scores to win Jeff's £1 million. Enter your selections for free here.

Around Sky