Skip to content

Manchester derby classics: Best of Man Utd v Man City at Old Trafford


It’s a huge Manchester derby on Sunday with United having moved above City in the Premier League table as the power shifts again in the North West.

From Roy Keane to Mario Balotelli, this fixture has produced some of the most memorable moments in Premier League history.

Here we pick out six of the best Manchester derbies at Old Trafford as we look forward to a Super Sunday…

Man Utd 0-3 Man City, March 2014

It was a one-sided affair the last time that the two teams met at Old Trafford with Edin Dzeko’s first-minute goal setting the tone. The City striker added another in the early stages of the second half before Yaya Toure capped a miserable afternoon for United boss David Moyes. City were superior in every department and the performance was a hint at the sort of form that would ultimately take them to the title as Manuel Pellegrini’s men won their final five matches of the campaign.

Yaya Toure of Manchester City celebrates scoring the third goal with his Fernandinho and Vincent Kompany during the 3-0 win over Manchester United in 2014
Image: Yaya Toure celebrates scoring Man City's third goal in their 3-0 win in 2014

As for United, they were left languishing well adrift of their rivals in seventh spot. Having lost their previous Premier League game at Old Trafford to Liverpool by the same 3-0 scoreline, the defeat left Moyes clinging to his job and he was gone within a month – not helped by his post-match summary of the derby. "I think we've played a very good side and it's the sort of standard and level we need to try and aspire to get ourselves to at this moment in time.”

Man Utd 1-6 Man City, October 2011

More from Man Utd V Man City

Manchester City’s October 2011 visit to Old Trafford proved to be one of the most famous matches in Premier League history as Roberto Mancini’s side pulled off an astonishing 6-1 victory to inflict United's worst home defeat since February 1955. The defending champions were ruthlessly cut apart in the latter stages of the match as City moved five points clear at the top of the table.

Why Always Me? Who could forget this epic celebration
Image: Mario Balotelli reveals a message for everyone after scoring the opener in 2011

Mario Balotelli, who had been in the news for accidentally setting fire to his house with fireworks, opened the scoring and revealed a T-shirt that read ‘Why always me?’ before doubling the lead after the break. Sergio Aguero added a third following Jonny Evans’ sending off and while Darren Fletcher pulled one back with a brilliant strike, a late flurry of goals left United humiliated.

Sir Alex Ferguson insisted: “We battered them for 40 minutes in that game – absolutely battered them." But there could be no denying that one from David Silva and two by Dzeko made for an emphatic scoreline and the Scot was prepared to concede in his autobiography that his team had been embarrassed. “After the final whistle, I informed the players they had disgraced themselves.”

Man Utd 2-1 Man City, February 2011

Nani’s first-half goal had given United the lead before Silva’s deflected effort levelled things up, but this contest was all about one spectacular goal by Wayne Rooney. The England forward’s stunning overhead kick will live long in the memory of supporters at Old Trafford and Ferguson even suggested that it was the greatest goal scored during his time as Manchester United manager.

12/2/11 - United 2 City 1: Once voted the best goal in Premier League history, Rooney's incredible late overhead kick also inspired Utd to the title.
Image: Wayne Rooney scores an incredible overhead kick against Man City in 2011

The victory extended the gap between the two clubs to eight points and succeeded in getting United’s campaign back on track after they had unexpectedly lost their unbeaten record against bottom club Wolves the previous week. This was a spectacular way to bounce back en route to claiming the crown and extend City’s then sequence of one win in 27 visits to Old Trafford.

Man Utd 4-3 Man City, September 2009

The build-up to the 2009 meeting between the teams was particularly rowdy following Carlos Tevez’s summer switch as the ‘noisy neighbours’ really started to threaten United’s dominance of Manchester. This clash certainly lived up to the billing with Michael Owen’s winner late in stoppage time providing one of the great derby moments.

Michael Owen celebrates his winning goal for Manchester United against Manchester City in their 4-3 win at Old Trafford in 2009
Image: Michael Owen celebrates his winning goal for Manchester United in 2009

City had earlier shown remarkable resilience to level things up no fewer than three times. Rooney put United in front only for Gareth Barry to equalise soon after, then Craig Bellamy came up with a second equaliser to a Fletcher goal. With 10 minutes remaining, the Scotland international appeared to have finally secured victory only for Bellamy to capitalise on a Rio Ferdinand error and level it at three apiece.

Live Ford Super Sunday

But with Mark Hughes visibly frustrated by the amount of added time, Ryan Giggs calmly picked out Owen in the left channel and the former England hero – a surprise free transfer arrival in the summer – finished left-footed to send Old Trafford into ecstasy. “I felt the game would be in their box,” Ferguson told Sky Sports afterwards. “In the last 20 minutes we sensed that and there is no one better than Michael Owen when that happens.”

Man Utd 1-1 Man City, April 2001

Roy Keane had been waiting for this one. Alf-Inge Haaland had accused him of feigning injury in a game against Leeds four years earlier and the incident was evidently in the mind of the United captain as he produced a horror challenge on the Norwegian that left the City man writhing in agony and gave referee David Elleray no option but to send him off. Despite this, and Paul Scholes missing a penalty, the game finished all-square at 1-1.

Manchester United's Roy Keane stands over Manchester City's Alf-Inge Haaland following his foul at Old Trafford in April 2001
Image: Roy Keane stands over Alf-Inge Haaland following his foul in 2001

Teddy Sheringham put United ahead from the spot with a penalty of his own to celebrate having been crowned Footballer of the Year but Steve Howey equalised for the visitors late on to give Joe Royle’s men a welcome boost in their battle against the drop. Ultimately, it was a battle they were to lose as they were relegated with only 34 points.

In contrast, United claimed the Premier League title for a third successive season. For their skipper, there were no regrets. “Even in the dressing room afterwards, I had no remorse,” he later wrote of the Haaland incident in his autobiography. “What goes around comes around. He got his just rewards.”

Man Utd 5-0 Man City, November 1994

Andrei Kanchelskis later played for Manchester City but it was his hat-trick for Manchester United that lit up the derby in November 1994 as the home side ran out 5-0 winners at Old Trafford. Despite operating on the right flank, Kanchelskis was United's top scorer with 14 Premier League goals that season and recalls the win over City as one of his best moments.

Andrei Kanchelskis celebrated the second of his three goals for Manchester United against Manchester City in a 5-0 win at Old Trafford in November 1994
Image: Andrei Kanchelskis celebrates the second of his three goals for in a 5-0 win in 1994

“I will never forget that match,” he told the Manchester Evening News in 2010. “Eric Cantona opened the scoring and I got my first goal just before half-time. I scored again just after the break and managed to complete my hat-trick just before the end. Mark Hughes also got a goal. I remember that Paul Ince and Cantona played really well and it was a superb occasion for the fans. It was a great game to play in.”

Incredibly, it wasn’t even close to being United’s biggest win of that season – they went on to put nine past Ipswich in March – but Blackburn still took their Premier League crown on the final day of the season. As for Kanchelskis, he was sold to Everton in the summer with David Beckham groomed as his replacement.

Watch Man Utd v Man City live on Sky Sports 1 HD this Sunday from 3.30pm

Around Sky