Skip to content

Is Chelsea's John Terry the Premier League's greatest defender?

Is Chelsea captain John Terry the Premier League's greatest defender?

Is John Terry the greatest defender in Premier League history? We look at the stats to see where the Chelsea icon ranks…

Terry splits opinion like few other players and since he announced Chelsea will not be renewing his contract at the end of the season, the reaction has been predictably mixed.

Many will not mourn the departure of one of the Premier League's most controversial characters, but to those who have cherished his contribution to Chelsea, there is sadness, anger and regret.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Jamie Redknapp says not offering John Terry a new contract is a 'strange decision' by Chelsea

But whether you love him or loathe him, Terry's pedigree cannot be questioned. His trophy-laden career has spanned 18 Premier League campaigns, and his outstanding contribution to Chelsea's last title triumph was a testament to his remarkable endurance.

He is certainly not without admirers, either. "John Terry has been the best Premier League defender I've seen, the best centre-back I've ever played against," said Sky Sports pundit Jamie Redknapp on Sunday night. "He's just been a warrior."

Chelsea's treatment of Frank Lampard (L) and terry shows a lack of respect, according to Redknapp

Jamie Carragher offered a similar assessment after watching Terry lift his fourth title last season. "There have been a lot of great centre-backs in Premier League history, but I think he has been the best that we've seen," he said.

Terry has provided the foundations for the era of unprecedented success that has followed Roman Abramovich's takeover in 2003, and Chelsea's "Captain, Leader, Legend" will go down in Premier League history too.

Also See:

Most Premier League appearances for defenders

Player Appearances
Jamie Carragher 508
Rio Ferdinand 504
Sol Campbell 503
John Terry 477
Sylvain Distin 467
Aaron Hughes 455
Richard Dunne 431
Gareth Southgate 426
John O'Shea 406
Gary Neville 400

From his debut as a substitute in a 2-0 win over Southampton in 1998 to his inspirational performance in Chelsea's 1-0 win over Arsenal last weekend, Terry has made 477 Premier League appearances.

Terry the Premier League legend
Terry the Premier League legend

SSNHQ's Andy Burton reflects on John Terry's last six months at Chelsea.

He has played under 10 different managers and been written off more than once, but he has made a habit of proving his doubters wrong, and his recent displays at Old Trafford and the Emirates Stadium show he is still at home on the big stage.

John Terry of Chelsea speaks with Petr Cech of Arsenal
Image: John Terry impressed for Chelsea in their recent 1-0 win over Arsenal

Carragher, Rio Ferdinand and Sol Campbell may have the edge on him for Premier League appearances, but in 2014/15 he achieved something that no other outfield player has managed since Manchester United's Gary Pallister in 1992/93 when he played in every minute of every game of title-winning season. It's no mean feat for a man who turned 34 that year.

Zouma shocked by Terry exit
Zouma shocked by Terry exit

Kurt Zouma admits that he is surprised at Chelsea's decision not to renew John Terry's contract.

Terry played a pivotal role in Chelsea's 17 clean sheets in 2014/15, and his overall record of 212 shut-outs is unrivalled among Premier League defenders. No current defender even features in the top 10, and Terry will be aiming to add to his tally before the end of the campaign.

Most Premier League clean sheets for defenders

Player Clean sheets
John Terry 212
Jamie Carragher 195
Rio Ferdinand 189
Sol Campbell 153
Gary Neville 148
Ashley Cole 147
Gareth Southgate 136
Sami Hyypia 125
Denis Irwin 123
William Gallas 122

His clean sheets total gives him a rate of 44.4 per cent, which is only fractionally bettered by Tony Adams and Nemanja Vidic of defenders to have made at least 200 Premier League appearances.

Clean sheet percentage for defenders (min 200 apps)

Player Appearances Clean sheets Clean sheet %
Tony Adams 255 115 45.1%
Nemanja Vidic 211 95 45.0%
John Terry 477 212 44.4%
Gary Pallister 261 104 39.8%
Sami Hyypia 318 125 39.3%

Terry also ranks highly for win percentage, with 302 Premier League victories in 477 games giving him a win rate of 63.3 per cent.

John Terry

That puts him well ahead of the likes of Carragher, Ferdinand and Campbell, and means he also ranks in the top 10 for defenders with a minimum of 200 appearances.

Premier League win percentage for defenders (min 200 apps)

Player Appearances Wins Win %
Nemanja Vidic 211 149 70.6%
Patrice Evra 273 186 68.1%
Phil Neville 263 175 66.5%
Gary Neville 400 256 64.0%
Mikael Silvestre 275 176 64.0%
John Terry 477 301 63.3%
Ashley Cole 385 240 62.3%
Gael Clichy 290 178 61.4%
Vincent Kompany 215 130 60.5%
Pablo Zabaleta 200 118 59.0%

Terry doesn't just prevent goals, either. The former England captain is a major threat in the opposition penalty box and has a knack of popping up in the right place at the right time.

Chelsea's John Terry celebrates scoring his side's third goal against Everton
Image: John Terry scored his 40th Premier League goal in Chelsea's 3-3 draw with Everton last month

He is the highest-scoring defender in Premier League history with 40, and that total is all the more impressive considering none of them have come from the penalty spot.

Most Premier League goals from defenders

Player Goals
John Terry 40
David Unsworth 38 (inc. 22 penalties)
Ian Harte 28 (inc. 10 penalties)
Leighton Baines 26 (inc. 15 penalties)
William Gallas 25

Terry's departure will mark the end of an era. And while he remains a polarising figure, the statistics show he has a strong case to be considered the greatest defender in Premier League history.

Do you think Terry is the greatest? Leave a comment below or tweet us your thoughts @SkyFootball

Around Sky