Skip to content

England's penalty heartbreak: Spot-kick failures from Turin 1990 to Tychy 2017

Nathan Redmond looks dejected after his penalty is saved, knocking England out of the UEFA European Under-21 Championship
Image: England's defeat to Germany at the U21 Euros was the latest in a long line of penalty shoot-out failures by the national team

Defeat to Germany on penalties in the European U21 Championship on Tuesday night simply adds to the ever-growing list of spot-kick failures over the years for England.

Since 1990, the national teams across all age groups have won just four out of 15 penalty shootouts.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

See what may have given Germany’s U21 goalkeeper the edge in their penalty shoot-out win against England

Meanwhile, it is also the second defeat on penalties already for an England side this summer after the U17s were beaten by Spain in their European Championship final.

England U21 manager Aidy Boothroyd revealed in the build-up to the game that his players had been practising spot kicks after every training session since they first met a month ago.

In stark contrast, however, his opposite number Stefan Kuntz claimed that Germany did not practise spot kicks as he did not believe you could replicate the pressure of a match situation.

England's Nathan Redmond looks dejected after his missed  penalty meant England go out of the UEFA European Under-21 Championship, Semi Final match at Stad
Image: England forward Nathan Redmond (left) looks on after missing from the spot against Germany at the U21 Euros semi-finals

The German coach - who scored his country's fifth penalty against England at Wembley in the semi-finals of Euro 96 - said after his side won the shootout 4-3 that when your history is to score, maybe you believe a little bit more.

Unlike Germany, however, the Three Lions' history from the spot is to not score generally as this dismal record over almost 30 years shows…

Also See:

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

England U21 boss Aidy Boothroyd says he's gutted but felt confident once the match went to penalties. Boothroyd's boys lost 3-4 in the shootout to Germany

Seniors

1990 World Cup semi-final - lost 4-3 to Germany

Stuart Pearce saw his effort saved in Turin, before Chris Waddle blazed over the bar as Bobby Robson's side came within a whisker of reaching the World Cup final.

TURIN, ITALY - JULY 04:  WM 1990 HALBFINALE in Turin; DEUTSCHLAND - ENGLAND (GER - ENG) 4:3 n.E.; Chris WADDLE/ENG verschiesst den entscheidenden Elfmeter gegen TORWART Bodo ILLGNER/GER  (Photo by Bongarts/Getty Images)
Image: Chris Waddle fires over the bar against Germany in the 1990 World Cup semi-final

1996 Euro quarter-final - won 4-2 against Spain

Alan Shearer, David Platt, Pearce and Paul Gascoigne all converted, while Fernando Hierro hit the bar, before goalkeeper David Seaman beat clear Miguel Angel Nadal's strike

Image: Stuart Pearce shows his joy after scoring his penalty against Spain at Euro 96

1996 Euro semi-final - lost 6-5 to Germany

More heartbreak at the hands of Germany as at the home of football, Gareth Southgate missed from the spot in sudden death.

Image: Gareth Southgate (right) after missing from the spot against Germany at Euro 96

1998 World Cup last 16 - lost 4-3 to Argentina

After a thrilling 2-2 draw in St Etienne, Carlos Roa kept out both Paul Ince and David Batty's penalties.

Image: David Batty trudges back to the centre circle after missing from the spot against Argentina at the 1998 World Cup

2004 Euro quarter-final - lost 6-5 to Portugal

Once again, the Three Lions needed penalties after a four-goal thriller could not separate them from the hosts, before captain David Beckham's untimely slip and Darius Vassell's miss brought an end to their tournament.

David Beckham fired over the bar for England in Euro 2004 against Portugal
Image: David Beckham fires over the bar for England in Euro 2004 against Portugal

2006 World Cup quarter-final - lost 3-1 to Portugal

Frank Lampard, Steven Gerrard and Jamie Carragher all fail from the spot in Gelsenkirchen as Sven Goran Eriksson's men exit the competition at the last-eight stage again.

Image: Jamie Carragher misses from the spot against Portugal

2012 Euro quarter-final - lost 4-2 to Italy

Another European Championship quarter-final, another painful loss on spot kicks, this time to the Azzurri as Gianluigi Buffon kept out Ashley Young and Ashley Cole's penalties in Kiev.

Image: Gigi Buffon keeps out Ashley Cole's spot kick in Kiev

U21s

2007 Euro semi-final - lost 13-12 to Netherlands

The Oranje eventually prevailed by an incredible scoreline of 13-12 in the shootout as even goalkeeper Scott Carson took, and converted, a penalty in Heerenveen, only for failures from the likes of Justin Hoyte, Nigel Reo-Coker, Matt Derbyshire and Anton Ferdinand to cost Pearce's team.

2009 Euro semi-final - won 5-4 against Sweden

Despite blowing a 3-0 lead in normal time to draw 3-3 with the hosts, the Young Lions still reached the final thanks to Joe Hart's heroics in the shootout, with the 'keeper also scoring from the spot.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

England crashed out of the U21 Euros after losing 3-4 on penalties to Germany in the semi-finals with Nathan Redmond missing the decisive penalty

2017 Euro semi-final - lost 4-3 to Germany

After Jordan Pickford's early stop, Tammy Abraham and Nathan Redmond both then saw efforts kept out by Germany 'keeper Julian Pollersbeck as England's dreams of reaching the final came to an end.

 Julian Pollersbeck
Image: Germany 'keeper Julian Pollersbeck consults his notes during the penalty shootout with England in the U21 Euros semi-finals

U20s

1993 World Cup quarter-final - won 4-3 against Mexico

After 120 minutes of goalless action in Melbourne, England progressed into the semi-finals after being successful with all of their spot kicks, including the decisive fourth from Chris Bart-Williams, while David Watson crucially kept out Juan Solis' effort.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Highlights of the Under-21 European Championships semi-final between England and Germany

U17

2003 Euro semi-final - lost 3-2 to Portugal

Failures from the spot from Nathan Doyle, Luke Moore and Grant Leadbitter saw the Young Lions just miss out on a place in the final following a 2-2 draw in Viseu.

2004 Euro third-place playoff - lost 3-2 to Portugal

It is déjà vu all over again as England again lose to Portugal 3-2 on penalties after an eight-goal thriller in Chateauroux, with defender David Wheater the man to miss the crucial spot kick on this occasion.

2014 Euro final - won 4-1 against Netherlands

England's youngsters won the tournament for a second time after an emphatic shoot-out win at the Ta' Qali National Stadium in Malta, with Newcastle 'keeper Freddie Woodman the hero on this occasion.

2017 Euro final, lost 4-1 to Spain

Agony for Steve Cooper's men who first conceded an equaliser six minutes into stoppage time, before then comprehensively losing the shootout.

Lions Tour live only on Sky Sports
Lions Tour live only on Sky Sports

Watch every match from the British & Irish Lions tour of New Zealand only on Sky Sports. Get Sky Sports today!