Skip to content

Harry Kane or Sergio Aguero: Which striker would you want in your side?

Tottenham v Manchester City, 7pm, Monday, Sky Sports Premier League

Harry Kane
Image: Harry Kane and Sergio Aguero will face each other on MNF

Ahead of Tottenham's MNF clash with Manchester City, we want to know who would make it into a combined XI of the two teams - and we are onto the strikers.

Few would complain if their team had a striker pairing of Harry Kane and Sergio Aguero, but to select just one is tricky.

The Spurs centre-forward has led the line and propelled his team forward into becoming genuine challengers for major trophies.

Aguero has made himself a City legend since joining from Atletico Madrid, becoming the club's greatest ever goalscorer and winning three Premier League titles in the process.

We asked our Soccer Saturday pundits who they'd pick. See who they went for, take our poll and then pick your combined Spurs-City XI with our interactive team selector below...

Live MNF

Phil Thompson - Aguero

It's a tough one but Kane has done it for the last few years while Aguero has done it for a longer spell of time. Harry is developing now and works a lot harder than Aguero coming deep and getting other players into the game, but I think Aguero will go down as one of the star strikers of the Premier League era. Right now, he'd get my vote.

Pick your Sky Sports Fantasy Football team
Pick your Sky Sports Fantasy Football team

Do Lloris or Ederson make your Fantasy Football team? Select your line-up here

Matt Le Tissier - Aguero

There's nothing in it between the two strikers as they are both excellent in front of goal, but Aguero has just been doing it for that little bit longer. For me, he just about edges it because of that.

Also See:

Paul Merson - Aguero

How hard is this? I have got to go for Aguero - his movement is slightly better than Kane's. Plus, he is one of those strikers that can score four or five in one game.

Charlie Nicholas - Aguero

I would just give it slightly to Aguero but only because he has been doing it for so long. Aguero has done it and won the league, Kane has been doing it but they have not won anything yet. He's a fabulous footballer, as we know, but he needs to do it in a big game to win the league or a trophy to reach the pinnacle Aguero is at.

Over to you...

Play Super 6
Play Super 6

Predict 6 correct scores for your chance to win £250K.

Around Sky