Skip to content

Hugo Lloris or Ederson: Which goalkeeper would you want in your side?

Tottenham v Manchester City, 7pm, Monday, Sky Sports Premier League

Hugo Lloris and Ederson
Image: Hugo Lloris and Ederson face off on Monday Night Football

Ahead of Tottenham's MNF clash with Manchester City we want to know who would make it into a combined XI of the two teams - and we're kicking off with the goalkeepers.

France's Hugo Lloris will be in goal for the hosts on Monday, having produced a fine performance in his last Premier League outing against West Ham, which won him praise from his manager Mauricio Pochettino.

Brazil's Ederson will be at the other end, having become a key part of Pep Guardiola's side since replacing Claudio Bravo at the start of last season.

But which 'keeper would make it into a team made up of Tottenham and Manchester City's best players?

We asked our Soccer Saturday pundits who they would pick. See who they went, take our poll and then pick your combined Spurs-City XI with our interactive team selector below...

Live MNF

Phil Thompson - Ederson

They are both great goalkeepers but I just think Lloris makes more errors than Ederson does.

Ederson does not get as much work as Lloris but he hardly ever makes a mistake and his distribution is excellent.

Also See:

Pick your Sky Sports Fantasy Football team
Pick your Sky Sports Fantasy Football team

Do Lloris or Ederson make your Fantasy Football team? Select your line-up here

Matt Le Tissier - Ederson

The Brazilian is just a better all-round keeper for me.

They are both pretty good but Ederson is more reliable and is excellent with the ball at his feet.

Paul Merson - Ederson

Wow. One's a World Cup winner and one is not but I will just go for the Brazilian. I'm not a great believer in goalkeepers being good on the ball but Ederson is a classy operator. Lloris has been a bit wobbly this season - sometimes he comes steaming out of his goal and he does not need to do that.

Charlie Nicholas - Ederson

He's the better decision maker, there is mistakes in every goalkeeper nowdays but as you saw with Lloris against Barcelona at Wembley he just seems to have a few more in him than Ederson.

Who gets your vote?

Play Super 6
Play Super 6

Predict 6 correct scores for your chance to win £250K.

Around Sky