Skip to content

Football's child sexual abuse scandal: Crewe Alexandra chairman John Bowler resigns following Sheldon Review

Crewe chairman John Bowler resigns after the Sheldon Review's publication, which contained several allegations centred on convicted paedophile Barry Bennell; Bowler said: "I will always be deeply appalled and sorry that those young players suffered at the hands of this evil predator"

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Sky Sports News' Bryan Swanson explains the findings of the independent review into child sexual abuse allegations within football

John Bowler has stepped down from his role as Crewe Alexandra chairman following Clive Sheldon QC's review into child abuse in football.

Last week, a four-year review into child sexual abuse allegations within football concluded that the Football Association did not do enough to keep children safe between 1995 and 2000.

A number of the allegations centre on convicted paedophile Barry Bennell, who was a youth coach at both Crewe and Manchester City during the 1980s and 90s.

In light of the report, Crewe apologised to "every survivor of abuse" and expressed their regret at not learning of Bennell's offences sooner.

Bowler, who became Crewe chairman in 1987 having joined the board in 1980, said it was always his intention to stand down following the conclusion of the Sheldon Review.

"As the only person left with an association to that era, I truly believe it was important for me to see it through to conclusion," Bowler said in a statement.

"I am satisfied with the findings of the review that found that the club did not have any knowledge of Barry Bennell's heinous crimes.

"I will always be deeply appalled and sorry that those young players and their families suffered at the hands of this evil predator. I personally and sincerely apologise to them all for their suffering."

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

David Lean, who was abused by football coach Barry Bennell, talks about the struggles of living with the experience

Sheldon concluded in his report that it was likely three Crewe directors discussed Bennell over concerns which hinted at his sexual interest in children.

It also found there is no evidence that advice from a senior police officer to keep a "watching brief" on Bennell was heeded.

The club were also criticised for not checking in with boys who were staying overnight at Bennell's house.

"Had such steps been taken, this might have led to boys making disclosures to the club," Sheldon wrote in his report.

Sheldon Report: The key points

  • Four-year review published into child sexual abuse in football between 1970 and 2005
  • Evidence from 62 survivors and 157 further individuals
  • Clive Sheldon QC: "Survivors deserve to be listened to, and their suffering deserves to be properly recognised"
  • Sheldon: "It is important that this terrible history is not repeated"
  • FA "did not act appropriately" following Barry Bennell's release from prison in 2003
  • Historical failures identified involving Chelsea, Aston Villa, Newcastle, Manchester City, Crewe Alexandra, Stoke, Peterborough, and Southampton
  • By August 2020, Operation Hydrant had identified 240 suspects and 692 survivors
  • Sheldon: "I do not want to give the impression that abuse in football was commonplace. It was not"
  • Report makes 13 recommendations, including publishing safeguarding report every year

Bowler said a board shake-up would help the club move forward, adding the League One side would welcome "future recommendations" that come from the review.

"Crewe Alexandra is a community based club with good people. I apologise to all our supporters that the name of the club has been tarnished," Bowler added.

"I have worked on the formation of a new board and know they will do all they can to move the club forward.

"Our Academy remains one of the finest in the country and we have every confidence in our safeguarding policies and procedures.

"There is always room for improvement and as a club will welcome the future recommendations of The Sheldon Review."

'Resignation only after days of pressure' - The Offside Trust

The Offside Trust, an organisation founded and run by survivors of child sexual abuse in sport, has welcomed the decision, although it believes the resignation should have happened earlier.

A statement read: "We thought it might have been made in 2016. And again in 2018. For it not to have happened once the Sheldon report was published rubbed salt into the wounds of survivors. It has taken several days of pressure from survivors, journalists and ultimately the club's own supporters to force this resignation today.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Julian Knight MP says once a new FA chair is appointed, they will be called before the select committee to explain how they are working to prevent any future safeguarding issues within football

"This was the very least that should have been expected and hopefully it clears the path for a new chapter. The Offside Trust looks forward to a positive relationship with Crewe Alex in the future - in the same way as we have enjoyed with many other clubs in the last five years.

"Lessons must be learned. Longevity in an organisation is overrated - whether it's in the boardroom or the dug-out. Closed organisations run by small cliques can be breeding grounds for complacency and far worse. Transparency, honesty and humility should be championed above insularity and tribalism."

'Strip Gradi of his MBE' - The Offside Trust

FA chief executive Mark Bullingham, who called the report a "dark day for football", last week said former Crewe manager and director of football Dario Gradi, who was in charge of the club during Bennell's time there, has been "effectively banned for life" by the FA.

Former Crewe manager Dario Gradi (PA)
Image: The Sheldon report said that Gradi 'should have done more' to help investigate rumours about Bennell, but there was 'no evidence' that he had 'acted inappropriately'

Gradi was suspended in 2016 by the FA pending an investigation into claims he "smoothed over" a complaint of sexual assault against Chelsea scout Eddie Heath when he was assistant manager at the London club in the 1970s.

The Sheldon report said that Gradi "should have done more" to help investigate rumours about Bennell, but there was "no evidence" that he had "acted inappropriately".

However, Bullingham confirmed that Gradi's suspension had not been lifted since first being put in place in 2016, and will not be in the future.

"Dario Gradi is banned from football," Bullingham said. "Now that, unfortunately, I can't go into further details on. There are a number of reasons why someone might be banned from football, but just to say that he is and will remain so.

"Effectively he's banned for life"

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Former Southampton manager David Merrington says he reported sexual abuse at the club in the 1980s but it wasn't properly followed up

The Offside Trust has called for more action to be taken.

It has asked the Cabinet Office to strip Gradi of his MBE and added: "We will be making similar requests to the Professional Footballers' Association and Football Hall of Fame to revoke any other honours."

Historical failures were also identified at a number of other clubs, including Chelsea, Aston Villa, Newcastle, Stoke, Peterborough, and Southampton.

The report highlighted numerous examples where clubs linked to abusers had heard rumours or received complaints and failed to handle them properly.

In all, the review said data passed to it by Operation Hydrant in August 2020 had identified 240 suspects and 692 survivors.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Premier League managers Scott Parker, Ralph Hasenhuttl and Graham Potter react to the safeguarding for children report published by Clive Sheldon QC

There were also apologies issued in statements from the Premier League and English Football League, while Manchester City released the findings of a report of their own.

City issued a statement to "apologise publicly and unreservedly" to those who were abused by three individuals named in their own report, commissioned in 2016 and carried out by Jane Mulcahy QC.

The report found that the club's response to allegations concerning Bennell, John Broome and Bill Toner was "wholly inadequate" in its failure to investigate fully or inform the police.

If you need further information on child abuse, sexual abuse or exploitation, for either you or someone close to you, please see the list of organisations listed in the child abuse section on this page:

Around Sky