Skip to content

Debate: Was Gareth Southgate right with his penalty shootout selections?

Gareth Southgate admits he takes full responsibility for England's penalty shootout defeat after selecting the five takers, but should Bukayo Saka have been handed the fifth kick? Where were the more experienced members of the squad?

Was Gareth Southgate right to select Bukayo Saka in the shootout?
Image: Was Gareth Southgate right to select Bukayo Saka in the shootout?

Gareth Southgate defended his England players following their shootout defeat to Italy, but was he right to enforce his list of five takers or should those with more experience have stepped up in shootout?

England's defeat to Italy was in their first major tournament final in 55 years and they will hope to bounce back at the 2022 World Cup in 18 months' time.

Southgate told his young side to hold their heads high after a historic summer came to a crushing end, but Roy Keane led the criticism of the overly structured selection approach, claiming Bukayo Saka should not have been given the task of taking their crucial fifth penalty.

Saka, 19, had to score to send the shootout to sudden death but his kick was saved by Gianluigi Donnarumma. The Italy goalkeeper had also saved from Jadon Sancho after Marcus Rashford had hit the post.

Southgate shouldered the blame for his side falling short in the shootout, revealing he selected the five takers based effectively on data drawn from practice at St George's Park - a similar strategy which served England well against Colombia at the World Cup in 2018 and in the UEFA Nations League against Switzerland a year later.

Southgate talks to his players ahead of the shootout
Image: Southgate talks to his players ahead of the shootout

When asked what he would say to Saka, Southgate replied: "That it's down to me. I chose the penalty takers based on what we have done in training and nobody is on their own. We have won together as a team and it's absolutely on all of us in terms of not being able to win the game tonight.

What is England's overall penalty shootout record?

Won Lost
3 7

"But in terms of the penalties, that's my call and totally rests with me.

Also See:

"We had two [penalty takers] go off earlier in the game, so that's why we made the changes that we did. We have tracked what they have done with their clubs over a long period of time and what they have shown in training as well so that's the process that worked for us in Russia and the Nations League, but tonight, it has not quite worked."

Jordan Pickford saved two in the shootout but still ended on the losing side. England missed three. So where did it go wrong?

Automatic choices

Harry Kane made no mistake to get England up and running
Image: Harry Kane made no mistake to get England up and running

Southgate insisted after the match that "the calls for the penalties were mine - my decision to ask the players to take the penalties that they did".

Those calls were based largely on performance during penalty practice in training, though we can also look at players' record from the spot in competitive action to assess the candidates.

Captain and regular penalty taker Harry Kane is first choice at club level with Tottenham, as was Rashford for Manchester United until Bruno Fernandes' arrival.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Gareth Southgate made the right call with the five players he selected to take England's penalties in their Euro 2020 final but the wrong decision with the order in which they were taken, says Mark Bosnich

Combining publicly available figures from with Opta data, Kane had an 85 per cent success rate prior to Sunday night having scored 47 out of 55 penalties, including three from three in shoot-outs.

Rashford was even better at 89 per cent, 17 out of 19, with the only question mark over his involvement being his lack of match involvement.

What else does the data say about the takers?


During the 4-3 shootout win over Colombia in Russia, Harry Kane, Marcus Rashford, Kieran Trippier and Eric Dier all scored while Jordan Henderson's miss did not prove costly.

The Liverpool midfielder also missed from 12 yards in England's warm-up game against Romania after taking the responsibilities off the designated taker Dominic Calvert-Lewin - a decision which did not go down well with Southgate.

Southgate said at the time: "We had Marcus Rashford on penalties then James Ward-Prowse but both came off. We expected Calvert-Lewin to take it and I was expecting Hendo to go over to him and let him take it. We will pull rank next time."

England's Marcus Rashford reacts after missed a penalty shot during the penalty shootout during the Euro 2020 soccer final match between England and Italy at Wembley
Image: Marcus Rashford struck the post during the shootout

So it was perhaps not a surprise when Southgate elected to bring off his own substitute in order to bring on a more specialist taker ahead of the shootout in extra-time.

Interestingly, John Stones revealed last month he would have been the sixth taker in the victory over Colombia, had Dier not converted.

"That was a scary moment," he said. "But I was ready because of this process that we've always talked about. It's about making you as comfortable as possible in that situation. Because, unless it's Harry (Kane) or the boys who take penalties for their clubs regularly, it's a zone that we have not stepped into before."

Luke Shaw celebrates after putting England ahead against Italy
Image: Luke Shaw was among those left out of Southgate's five

England secured third place in the Nations League in 2019 by overcoming Switzerland 6-5 on penalties, scoring all of their spot-kicks. Maguire, Ross Barkley, Sancho, Raheem Sterling, Jordan Pickford and Dier all found the net as England took bronze at the inaugural competition.

It is clear Mason Mount and Trippier were in Southgate's thoughts for the spot-kicks were they not among those who were replaced during the course of the 120 minutes, so who else could have taken a penalty?

Calvert-Lewin remained an unused substitute and certainly would have jumped at the chance of being among the list of five, but the data shows that Sterling's record from 12 yards is poor.

Jack Grealish missed his only penalty at professional level for Aston Villa when his attempt against Sheffield United in December 2019 slammed against the crossbar.

Saka was tasked with taking his first penalty at senior level but has shown on countless occasions previously he can handle the pressure, so criticising Southgate's decision to put his faith in the teenager after the event might appear churlish.

Southgate's substitutions

England's Jadon Sancho reacts after he missed to score during the penalty shootout of the Euro 2020 soccer championship final between England and Italy at Wembley
Image: Jadon Sancho reacts after becoming the second to miss

Rashford and Sancho have shown themselves to be good penalty-takers at club level. Perhaps the soundest conclusion is that they ought to have been brought on sooner to get a feel of the ball, but Southgate is not the first manager to deploy this tactic, and will not be the last.

Sancho, too, had an impressive prior record from the spot, scoring all three of his efforts at senior level for Borussia Dortmund and 10 out of 11 in the dataset overall, with his only miss coming at the Under-17 World Cup in 2017.

It is understandable, therefore, why Southgate would want to turn to him and Rashford - but the lateness of the changes left them coming in cold.

The penalty shoot-out

Player Team Outcome
Domenico Berardi Italy Scored
Harry Kane England Scored
Andrea Belotti Italy Saved
Harry Maguire England Scored
Leonardo Bonucci Italy Scored
Marcus Rashford England Missed
Federico Bernardeschi Italy Scored
Jadon Sancho England Saved
Jorginho Italy Saved
Bukayo Saka England Saved

Rashford was also left to play right-back as a direct replacement for Kyle Walker - effectively ruling out the introduction of any further specialists such as Calvert-Lewin and his 100 per cent record from four penalties.

Conor Coady, who did not play a single minute in the tournament, is another with a strong penalty record - although his Championship goal against Bolton in 2018 is the Wolves defender's only attempt at senior level.

Walker's only ever penalty, which he scored, came in Tottenham's 2013 League Cup shoot-out against Hull while the other player replaced late on, Jordan Henderson, has scored only one of four and missed for England in both their 2018 World Cup shoot-out win over Colombia and last month's warm-up game against Romania.

Who was missing?

Kieran Trippier's cross set up England's opener
Image: Kieran Trippier was substituted during normal time

Southgate noted after the game that "we had to take a couple off during the game", suggesting Mason Mount and Kieran Trippier may have been among the planned takers.

Mount has scored four out of five career penalties, all bar one of those in shoot-outs, while Trippier scored against Colombia and in Atletico Madrid's Spanish Supercopa shoot-out against city rivals Real last January but has missed his two efforts in regulation.

Luke Shaw and Stones have scored in shoot-outs, Shaw in Manchester United's recent Europa League final loss to Villarreal and Stones in Everton's FA Cup defeat to West Ham in 2015 - with the latter adding a Panenka in a friendly win over Juventus in 2013.

Kalvin Phillips, with two from three in shoot-outs, would have been considered while goalkeeper Jordan Pickford scored confidently against Switzerland.


Grealish denies ducking out

Jack Grealish has hit out at claims he avoided stepping up to take a penalty after the finger was pointed at some of England's more senior players who were still on the pitch after 120 minutes and did not take one of the five spot-kicks.

Grealish tweeted on Monday morning: "I said I wanted to take one!!!! The gaffer has made so many right decisions through this tournament and he did tonight!

"But I won't have people say that I didn't want to take a peno when I said I will…"

What is the psychology behind penalties?

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Football psychology researcher Geir Jordet discusses what makes the perfect penalty amidst the pressure of a tournament shootout

Football psychology researcher Geir Jordet discussed in the build-up to the final what makes the perfect penalty amid the pressure of a tournament shoot-out...

"You don't need me to tell you this, but England have a complicated relationship when it comes to penalties. There's been a very tough, very traumatic past and we have done a lot of research to document the specifics of this to find out exactly why that's the case.

"But then, things have turned around with Southgate coming in. His team have brought a very new approach to the game as a whole but also a very new approach to penalties. It's a very structured, systematic and professional approach.

"As of this moment, England are probably leading the pack in European football with respect to having the most structured and professional regiment for dealing with this part of the game."

Southgate's series of calculated gambles finally backfires

Jordan Pickford encourages Bukayo Saka before his spot-kick
Image: Jordan Pickford encourages Saka before his spot-kick

Sky Sports' Ben Grounds:

"Southgate is clearly hurting very much inside and his comments were clearly designed to protect his players. His thought process was based on wanting to keep as many of his perceived specialists on the pitch without leaving the team open to being beaten in extra-time, hence why Sterling and Rashford ended up as wing-backs only in the final few minutes.

"That England very nearly conceded from the one piece of defending they had to negotiate with such a lopsided system backed up why he had left the changes so late. There was a clear strategy but you cannot replicate the conditions of Sunday night at St George's Park.

"Southgate has made at least one alteration to the England starting XI for 37 consecutive matches, making a total of 200 changes in that time and last staying with the same starting line-up in the 2018 World Cup semi-final.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Steve McClaren says Gareth Southgate should have made changes earlier than he did in England's Euro 2020 final defeat to Italy

"England were set up to contain Italy, aware of their strengths, and duly posted their lowest possession in a game at Wembley (34.4 per cent) since November 2016 against Spain.

"Southgate admitted he picked a side based on a tactical problem his opponents posed but after an impressive first half, his forward line were unable to release the pressure on Pickford's goal. It became increasingly apparent penalties were the only route to victory, but ultimately the best team have won the tournament.

"Southgate's reign has been one of a series of calculated gambles that have largely paid off, but here his luck ran out."

More penalty heartbreak for England

England have won just 22 per cent (2/9) of their major tournament shootouts (World Cup/EUROs), the lowest ratio of any European nation to have been involved in three or more.

What the pundits said...

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Gary Neville gives his thoughts on England's defeat to Italy in the Euro 2020 final.

Gary Neville told Sky Sports: "I have been to eight major tournaments and I have been knocked out on penalties five times.

"I have seen it all. I have seen the one where the hero stands up and says, 'I want to take one,' when actually, I'm thinking, 'I don't really want you to take one!'

"Italy had an absolutely brilliant goalkeeper who was always going to save some of those penalties. He was outstanding.

"The people who take penalties in my mind should be the people who are most confident about putting the ball in the back of the net, who have a history of putting the ball in the back of the net in those situations.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Gary Neville says he is saddened but not surprised by the online abuse aimed at Marcus Rashford, Jadon Sancho and Bukayo Saka, after they failed to score penalties in England's Euro 2020 final defeat to Italy

"You cannot recreate it in training but you can have a comfort about doing it, you can be a better striker of a ball than others. I have got no doubt that Gareth and his staff will have done everything possible to have chosen those five penalty-takers. Those five were planned to stand up.

"Raheem Sterling, if we are honest, is not a great striker of a football. His finishing can be quite scruffy. Jack Grealish has not taken a penalty for his club in two years and there will be a reason for that.

"The manager will have looked at everything in fine detail - he's got so much so right but sometimes it just does not work out."

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Sky Sports News' Jess Creighton says the England squad have 'done something magical' by uniting the nation with their performances at Euro 2020

Roy Keane questioned why Saka took England's final penalty, telling ITV: "If you're Sterling or Grealish, you cannot sit there and watch a kid walk up ahead of you, you can't.

"You can't sit there and go 'I see a young kid, 19-year-old, a child, walking up in front of me, and I've played a lot more games, I've got a lot more experience'. "Sterling, who has won a lot more games, won trophies.

"Gareth might have been thinking he's going to be six or seven, you can't sit there. That must be hard to take, you've got to go to this young kid and say I'll step up before you'."

Jose Mourinho told talkSPORT: "The decision of the penalty takers, I think it is hard to leave Saka as the last one. I think it is hard for a kid to have everything on his shoulders at that moment. I just feel very sorry for him.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Danny Mills says the three England players who missed penalties will eventually get over the disappointment and learn from the experience

"In this situation where was Sterling, where was Stones, where was Shaw? I feel that Gareth is such an honest guy. Such a protective coach of his players. I don't think he would ever say players were not ready [to take a penalty]."

Alan Shearer told the BBC: "You are under enough pressure anyway as a player but the extra pressure you have put on those individuals when you've had no feel of the football, not involved in the game at all and then you are put in that situation. It's a big, big ask.

"I just feel for Rashford, Sancho and Saka. It's a lot for those young boys to take on in the future and it's so, so cruel. When you have not played a huge part in the tournament, or the game, then to come on and be asked for a minute. Mentally in that situation you have got to get yourself right.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

There were contrasting emotions for England and Italy fans following the dramatic penalty shootout at Wembley

Rio Ferdinand told the BBC: "[Making late subs for penalties] has happened for years. People have put players on. Maybe not as late but towards the end - the last five, four, three minutes.

"Players come on this pitch and they go on as penalty takers because they are recognised. Rashford is a recognised penalty taker for Man United. This happens.

"We look down the years in tournament football and it's the biggest players, the best players in the world at times miss penalties. These are young kids. They have got to look at that. Big players in the past, (Roberto) Baggio's etc have missed big penalties."

Was Southgate right with his spot-kick selections?

Reading on Join the debate below...

Join the debate

Comment below to the join debate, but please respect our House Rules. If you wish to report any comment, simply click on the down arrow next to the offending comment and click 'Report'

Heartbreak for England, but glass is half full | Euro 2020 final review

It was penalty shootout heartbreak again for England and Gareth Southgate in a crushing Euro 2020 final defeat to Italy.

Alice Piper is joined by Pete Smith and Gerard Brand to reflect on a dramatic Euro 2020 final, with England unable to mark their progress with the silverware.

Win £300,000 with Super 6!
Win £300,000 with Super 6!

The Super 6 jackpot has rolled over. Could you land the £300,000 on Tuesday? Play for free, entries by 8pm.


Around Sky